How to use this Page

WOW! We play croquet regularly at our summer picnics and we are all passionate about Harry Potter (tickets in hand already) so we will have to give this a try at next week's picnic! Of course, now all the kids will be fighting over who will be the Bludger and who will be the Snitch. :) Fun fun fun!!!

To raise the stakes, I think each player should also be armed with three water balloon Bludgers.

Heading to Universal Orlando in November... anxious to hear your report.

That sounds fabulous. I'll have to remember your rules for the next time I play croquet. :)

(And right now--how could anyone NOT be in a Harry Potter frame of mind?)

Cheryl, this sounds like a fun version of Croquet!! I live in Alaska where we have 24 hours of daylight in the summer. Last night I played croquet with friends until 2 a.m.

Cheryl, In case you're interested, I'm sharing an article I just read featuring LeakyCon 2011 speaker Vera Lee. Her book, "On the Trail of Harry Potter," examines "all seven volumes from a literary perspective."

http://www.metrowestdailynews.com/arts/x1850042843/Much-ado-about-Harry-in-Newton-authors-book

Hi Cheryl, I've just found your blog and I will be attending Lit Day at LeakyCon. I'm wondering if you will be selling your book there? I've been to every bookstore in my area and none of them seem to have it in stock. I would very much like to get my hands on it, so I do hope you'll be selling copies at the conference. :)

Krissi

Were you thinking of THE ALCHEMYST, THE MAGICIAN, and soon-to-be-released SORCERESS?

Tricia took my guess!<br /><br />But wow--LOVE the Hallows observation.

It's like Harry Potter meets The Davinci Code... what a fan fic...

Nope, sorry. The one I have in mind is a considerably older work of children's literature. <br /><br />And Christina, my sister and I saw the Amorina gelato place you mentioned (I think it was you) across from the Centre Pompidou -- Best. Gelato. Ever. Thanks so much for the rec!

Whoa--it IS the Hallows!<br /><br />BTW, there is a real place in the Alps called Grindelwald. Some friends of mine (all red-haired, with many children) vacationed there recently...<br /><br />I was going to guess Eleanor Updale's Montmorency: Thief, Liar, Gentleman series, but I see it's Scholastic.

The Montmorency family from A Little Princess, who turned out to be the Carmichaels?<br /><br />I hope it is! I loved all the long fancy names Sara gave them. The copy I actually have at home is Scholastic's Apple Classics paperback version.

Wow (ref: the second picture). Makes you think that Harry's world might just be real after all...

Ding ding ding! S got it -- the Montmorency family from A LITTLE PRINCESS.

Oh I'm too late. I thought you might be thinking of Anne of Green Gables's Lady Cordelia de Montmorency.

I was wrong too -- my first thought was of DEREK THE KNITTING DINOSAUR.

Wow. I actually "whoaaa"-ed at the second picture. Amazing!

I loved all the Twilight books. Here's a link to a Caitlin Flanagan essay in this month's Atlantic that explains that love better than I could, and hopefully answers your question about loving the series and/or thinking Bella and Edward are interesting people. http://www.theatlantic.com/doc/200812/twilight-vampires

Twilight - I know they're bad but love them anyway and think Bella and Edward are interesting people. AustenBook was cute. Thanks!

Hmm, clearly answers to that comment are going to come down to how each of us defines "interesting." And I loathe Caitlin Flanagan, so that article didn't help.

thank you so much for the link to that gaurdian article:"Whenever she responds physically to his kisses, he immediately draws away and berates her. Supporters will call this the erotics of abstinence. I call it fear and distaste for female sexuality and a poisonous message to be feeding young women."excellent review - sums up basically everything i hated about twilight..

I didn't know anything about Caitlin Flanagan, apart from the Twilight essay, and I was so surprised to see the word "loathed" that I had to look her up to see what inspired it, and yeah serious yuck. But I did love those books, for the reasons she described. My problem with so much of the Twilight hate is that it's really nasty, and disparaging of the readers who liked the books. I also think

I don't have any contempt for the readers -- many of my good friends love the books (indeed, I'm reading TWILIGHT because one of my best friends said I had to do it), and I understand the basic appeal of Edward and the situation (I love BUFFY and DIRTY DANCING, so I get hot vampires and female sexual awakening). What puzzles me is how the book works as a whole while the individual pieces of the

Ah, envious of all the money?More like the attention, I would think. As a writer, I often wonder where it is that that story comes from-- that spark or hook that snags a reader, forces them to continue-- That certain something that makes a character's voice impossible to get out of your head, or the puzzle that makes a girl scream over her intercom at her friends when they ring her doorbell

I'm glad you agree with me on Twilight. I thought maybe I was the only one who thought it wasn't good because it came so highly recommended. My biggest complaint is that nothing interesting EVER happens! I was finally excited when a chapter ended with me wanting more...I wanted to find out what happened to him in the sun. And I found out that what happens is he SPARKLES. I just had to close

I read all of the Twilight books, begrudgingly. Bella seemed pretty vapid and drove me crazy. For such big books, they seemed like they had a lot of filler. And I don't feel like they had to cut a lot to make the movie.I was also looking for complex plot points that carried between the books, but was disappointed. Gee, I wonder where I got that expectation from?

"The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants is about female empowerment as it’s currently defined by the kind of jaded, 40-something divorcées who wash ashore at day spas with their grizzled girlfriends and pollute the Quiet Room with their ceaseless cackling about the uselessness of men."Spot on! The Guardian article simply recycled the same tired feminist arguments that made me a pariah in Women's

I'm also in the process of reading Twilight and think it's abysmal. Not only is it poorly written (can we have some more redundnat adverbs and adjectives, please? The "shiny car" and "loud slam" just aren't doing it for me!), but the characters are horrific. Bella's only flaw is that she falls over every now and then, and Edward is apparently perfect. And Bella isn't even sympathetic: her

Ha, and now I've read your comment about the adverbs. YES, the editor agrees with my technical critique. WIN.

Twilight is readable, but why? I work with books, but I'm not an editor, so I'd love your take on why you can't put Stephenie Meyer's books down. (Also: New Moon is different for the characters present in it I think; if you get to Breaking Dawn I'd just love to know how far into it you get.)Another question: Any comments on editing a blockbuster author with very strong opinions on her work?

Thanks so much for posting your Terminus talk on The Elements of Harry Potter! It is a very helpful analysis and I think I'm going to have to print it out and read it a couple more times.

Thank you!

I found no book on Amazon by Orson Scott Card titled CHARACTER AND VOICE, but I did find one titled CHARACTER AND VIEWPOINT. Is that the book you meant?Thanks for posting your Potter analysis, as well as all the other information on your website. It's all tremendously helpful.

Yes, CHARACTER AND VIEWPOINT -- foolish me for not double-checking! I'm going to correct that in the post.

Thanks so much for the book suggestions. My dad has always suggested Bird by Bird and Shrunk & White, but I hadn't heard/thought about the others.

Card's book is good, but honestly, I had some trouble getting through it. Part of it wasn't his fault. The format of the book is really dense, with long, crowded pages. The content is definitely worth reading, although I liked "Characters, Emotion, and Viewpoint" by Nancy Kress a lot better.And now that I've discovered Card's insane political spewings (a recent development, so it didn't affect my

just bought the orson scott card one. yay! thanks for the rec.

I want to thank you for this post. It comes at a time when I am again struggling with confidence in my opening.And, possibly just listening to too many voices on the internet.

I want to thank you for this post. It comes at a time when I am again struggling with confidence in my opening.And, possibly just listening to too many voices on the internet.

Cheryl,Thanks always for being so generous on your blog.Jean

Wow, Cheryl, awesome speech! I expected it just to be about HP lore, but what a meaty writer feast!pj

Cheryl,Thanks for sharing another talk. They are inspirational and educational. I hope to see you in person one day. Now that would really be inspirational!Kai

Cheryl,You are so insightful and generous. I have a question about literary and how it applies to picture books. Can you tell us the difference between a literary one and a non-literary one?Thanks!

One of my favorite writing books is Madeleine L'Engle's HERSELF: REFLECTIONS ON A WRITING LIFE. It is deeply poignant and honest with some wonderful insight into her journey as a writer.Thanks for posting the link to your TERMINUS speech. I love reading your speech transcripts-- they are full of delicious writing tips and guidance. Sarah Frances Hardy

Another writing book I'm really enjoying is the new HOW FICTION WORKS by James Wood. It's a bite-sized gem, easy to read and full of very thoughtful yet applicable info on writing. A fabulous read!

I can't thank you enough for posting this. Reading that speech just made me realize what exactly it is that I love about the Potter series. The speech is superbly written, but the last few things that you said- about writing for yourself, and not others- is what I needed to hear the most. And there is seriously nobody else I'd rather hear this from. Thanks again.Ps- In case you're wondering, the

Thanks for sharing your incredible insight and wisdom! Your Terminus speech is invaluable.

All great books on writing. Also, Stephen King's On Writing is a must for all writers.

Hi Cheryl,Thank you for posting your fabulous Terminus speech. I keep reading it over and over because I want to absorb all of your writerly thoughts & insights. I think my favorite part is the encouragement you offer in your closing thoughts, because it lifts me up when I read it. :)All the best -- and like Kai, hopefully one day I can meet you in person!miss skye

I love Bird by Bird and wish I hadn't loaned my book out. I fear I'll never see it again. grr.

Ooooh, lovely article, Cheryl! And I adore the hat.

So I know it's impossible to replace such a great hat. I've lost a few dear hats in my time.But you should give this a look. The fact that it's called an "I Feel Pretty Hat", might just hook you.http://www.etsy.com/view_listing.php?listing_id=10500008I purchased this hat for a dear friend and she loves it.

It was a fun read!

Great article, and a very pretty hat! I hope you find another you like as much.

I left my beret from Paris in a Joseph-Beth bookstore. At least it has gone on to a better place.And I love the picture! It looks like a painting!

I agree! The picture does look like a painting. And you look super-pretty in the hat :)The article was fantastic. Your sincerity is inspiring, Cheryl. It's not often that people spend ages agonizing over commas and full stops just so that it would make a perfect sentence, and understand that it makes ALL the difference(Eats, Shoots, Leaves?!) Of course, it IS your job but the fact that you love

You're right, it was a beautiful hat that you looked great in. Wouldn't it be nice if Harry Potter (or one of his fans) could work a little magic and return it to you? I love hearing about the subtle details, such as a capital letter or a period, that capture the power of an entire book. Very cool.pj lyons

Can I jump up and down and add my endorsement and encouragement for the bone marrow registration program? A little girl in my daughter's kindergarten class and her younger brother both have a very rare, deadly blood disorder that can only be cured by a stem cell transplant. The good thing is that it's very easy to donate this blood product--at least in Germany, you can even donate it in a process

Reading your posts always makes me happy. I even took a peak at the Celine video. Did you know Meatloaf did a version as well? (I only know this because it popped up at the end of the video.) It's very interesting!http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i_XT7zDuuZg&NR=1

Oh, I'm excited that you're speaking at Terminus--I'm on a panel there as well, so I'll get a chance to hear you!

Meat Loaf is a genuine guilty pleasure, I love Paradise by the Dashboard Light but I possibly love the utterly over the top I would do anything for love ... more. And what he won't do, of course, is hurt the person the song is addressed to.

Thank you for calling attention to the need for more people to join the bone marrow registry. It is easy to do, and you might save someone's life. Think of it as a not-so-random act of kindness.A very small relative of mine received a BMT last June. Thirty (!) family members celebrated with her in Disneyland last month, and if things continue to go well, she'll begin school this fall.Serious

Barack's speech was incredible. It was one of those speeches where you remember years later where you were when you first heard it. Here's hoping for good things in PA.

Thanks for bone marrow donation link -- the free kits are great news.I thought that speech demonstrated a leadership and authenticity that I rarely see in the political arena.Total Eclipse of the Heart! I'm going to call someone Bright Eyes today (maybe throw in some hand-wringing and face-scrunching too).

Hey now, to be fair, Celine was one of my very first CDs back in fifth and sixth grade. I could belt "It's All Coming Back to Me" like none other.Though, it's more like THIS kind of soap: http://www.nbc.com/Passions/video/#mea=179524

It's heartening to know that conferences like these exist...it's a very happy thought. PLEASE PLEASE post your speech here on your blog after the conference (or before if it's ok, I'm not complaining :D) I'm so looking forward to reading it!

Thanks, Cheryl. I knew you would have something profound to say about this. :-)

all i have to say is a great big resounding AMEN!!!! thanks Cheryl!

Wow, that was such a great quote from that man. I'll remember that - that Jo wrote about a man who was great who was also gay, not the other way around. There are so many well written arguments coming out now, it's really cool. Although I am very disappointed in the lack of tolerance of some Harry Potter "fans".

I think you hit on the one thing that really gets to me when it comes to, not just homophobia but heterosexism. When people say "It's nobody's business what you do in your bedroom" or something to that effect.My answer to that is always "being gay is about more than what goes on in the bedroom. It's not just about being sexually attracted to the same sex. It's about falling in love, wanting to

That was an amazing summary.I was getting madder by the minute at all those who suddenly turned up their noses at Albus, having claimed to be his biggest admirer all this time. Hurts, it does. I wanted to say so much and I didnt know where to start. Now however, thanks to you and TrustSnape...that line was so well written-"The reason so many of us think it is cool is because she told the story of

Cheryl,Thanks for your feedback on our submission. It helped to make our manuscript stronger. We missed your critique on our revision. Any info on what worked for you or didn't would be appreciated.Regards,Phyllis-Sue

Thank you for posting this. I wouldn't have read it at Leaky.This is a great response to this revelation.

Perfect way to sum it up! The revelation doesn't change my opinion of Dumbledore. He was a saving grace for me because I felt so bad for Harry Potter. Dumbledore was a caretaker that cared about Harry's welfare.

Good answer....

I agree in every single aspect you mentioned! And I usually use the same reasons when someone asks me what I see in those books....Now I have your post to show them... probably I'll print it out and show them! LOL

As part of the complexity issue, I think the themes of death, desire, loss, melancholy, longing, the unresolved open-endedness of grief (and love), the ordinariness of being compassionate (the ordinariness of being extraordinary), and the circuitry of power (particularly significant in childhood) also really make this book a classic. Actually I think all (most?) classic kids books are really

That was a wonderfully thought out post! I'm going to send it to my friends, if that's alright. It might help them to understand the Harry phenomenon.

It was simply amazing to read your reflections about the books. Is always great to enjoy the pleasure of reading about why we love them so much.And just so that you know, we didn't have a "Time Square" countdown here in Brazil, but we had some crazy countdowns all around the bookstores. :)Is amazing to find a book that is capable of creating that kind of engagement and commitment in people from

It was so beautifully written. Specially point 2-accessibility. I never understood how to put down or sort out that particular point in my head...Now you've done it.. Thank you so much!

Well said. Thank you for this. I'm particularly in awe of her skill in plotting. Reading Deathly Hallows, I was struck by how many details go all the way back to book 1.

Since you're listing things...I tag you for "8 Random Things".Rules on my bloghttp://dmcordell.blogspot.com/

I still really really disliked it. Growing up reading the books for 10 years I found myself cut short. I felt it was really rushed and like the story was being told by someone who writes fanfiction for Harry Potter in a livejournal community. It was just far too "butterflies and rainbows and 546464 kids."My two cents.

All excellent reasons! I miss Harry already...

Beautifully said! I don't know that I've ever seen someone's reasons for liking the series articulated quite so well. I really agree with you on the "complexity" of the characters. Even our hero Harry is not perfect.

I've done a lot of thinking on this, too. It gets old to see so many new books slapped with "the next Harry Potter!" label. Because while a big marketing plan might have made Harry known, it wasn't what made him loved. Nor was it just that it was about cool magic stuff (although it is very cool!). It's all those inner things you mention, and they come from writing about real things, with heart,

What I loved most about the series was the zest it put into kids' books. All of a sudden it was cool to read them. Thus a gift for parents, kids, teachers and authors. Thank you JKR!

This was such a great list and wonderful reflection on such an accomplishment as this series is. As a future librarian, there was nothing more exciting than all the hype that was produced by a book!

May I add a few?1. Humor. While Rowling at times had clunkers in characterization or plot, she almost always nailed it on humor.2. Connections to genres. After the third book, my family realized that each one fit into a genre (or sometimes with traits of two genres). In order: fairy tale, mystery/horror, adventure, Victorian novel, tragedy, Bildungsroman, quest/epic. Doing that with the same set

The second Tonks' pregnancy was announced, I predicted her and Lupin's death, and Harry stepping up as surrogate father, to fill the role of the father figure he never had. Then I realized that 17 year old Harry was in no way old or mature enough to deal with a baby, and figured that none of that was going to come true. I think the only thing that kept me together when Tonks and Lupin died was

You're so right. Harry's Teddy's godfather not his grandmother. I don't think he was equipped to completely parent a baby at age 17 - and why would a grandmother be incapable of looking after her grandson? Neville! I am still a little depressed that it's all over but at least there was a happy ending. I was in turmoil last week unable to sleep for worry about what was going to happen. All the

Also don't beat yourself up about the misspelling (did I even spell that right?) It's so not important!

haha, i basically died when i saw the Colbert Report. It just made my day so much happier!-Bubbles

The Colbert Report is indeed hilarious! Mostly because I can so see that happening! As a matter of fact, last night I went to an orientation meeting for the EdS program I am beginning and, sure enough, one of the people there had her book and was reading it the whole time! As for the rest, I can't wait for the encyclopedia! See! We still have a lot to speculate about!!!

'So, how are things in the Department of Magical Law Enforcement? We're really revolutionizing things over in the Auror Department! And have you had a letter from Luna recently? Wonder if she found those Blibbering Humdingers in Bolivia, ho ho ho!'" You make me laugh out loud, Miss C

Oh Cheryl, I noticed a couple of "continuity" errors;) But I'll forgive you.Laura (your old friend from WAY back dwg days)

Regarding wandering around in a tent for a long time, I found this picture of the very real Forest of Dean (where they found the sword), and hm, I can see why someone might want to linger awhile! http://www.cinderfordbrassband.co.uk/tall-forest.jpg

The epilogue surprised me. Mainly because I was expecting some sort of Animal House-esque thing of"Harry Potter married Ginny Weasley and had lots of babies. He became an auror.Delores Umbridge went to prison for a very long time for being a really big meanie.Teddy Tonks was raised by his grandmother and started dating Victoire whom he later married and had lots of very pretty babies with bright

Teddy was about two months old - it was mentioned that it was an April evening when Lupin visited Shell Cottage and basically freaked out. :) Given that the Epic End Battle usually happens in June, Teddy must've been about two months old!(Late reaction, yes, but I only now read it.)

Ron's return kicked me in the gut. I was on the subway, almost back to the safety of World Headquarters, when I started getting choked up. I kept going, because I don't care what people on the subway think, but, yikes.

I'm with you on the epilogue. I loved it.

Graceful, thoughtful, and true, everything. It's not that I didn't love the epilogue, I did. I just wanted more. I wanted to know what Luna was doing and who married Draco. I wanted to know what these moms and dads were doing besides being moms and dads. I did love that part, and little Albus Severus already needs a book about him, perhaps, but I just wanted to know, well, more. And she left us

I did seem to not be tripped up by the adverbs as I was when reading the previous books, but just thought I was reading too fast. There are really fewer? Good for her!

If I were to write a list of things I enjoyed about the book, my list would be VERY similar to yours. Loved, loved the humor--Krum's brilliant line, Ron's self-help book, Trelawney's orbs. I would also add that I really appreciated that Harry's closure with Dudley, Draco and Snape were true to character (of all parties involved) and not sappy and drawn out.

Not only a lack of adverbial tags, but a severe want of ellipses! I wasn't sure whether to credit the hardworking editors or JKR herself for that one. It's definitely a tight book for how quickly she wrote it (relatively, compared to other ones and the distraction of a new baby, etc.). I have a feeling some of the "promised" items that are "missing" might have fallen by the wayside as she

Whoops, got cut off.I think one can get too caught up in fanon, become so convinced of one's pet theories that anything different seems wrong. The ending fit the series. And I was surprised how many of the predictions (Harry the Horcrux, the final battle at Hogwarts, Snape loves Lily) were actually in there. I'll shut up now. :-)

I love your commentary, Cheryl! Its so eloquent, thought out and logical. I really enjoy reading the opinions of someone with a brain...there are so many wacky, negative opinions out there that only bring me down. Thanks for making me be more excited to be a part of this great fandom!

I curious to hear what you didn't like about the book, if any?Like you said, I do absolutely love the book, but there are still some parts I'm not so sure about.

When I finished the book I was so happy that, if circumstances had required it, I'm quite sure I could have produced a full-blown patronus!I thought the epilogue also definitively said that the the series was over. No book 8. There's no more tension left. (I must say that I was rather pleased with Ron and Hermione's name choice for their daughter--I've always said that if I didn't have my family,

Your list is pretty much my list, though I'm still processing. (I finished at 5:30 this afternoon.) I would like your perspective as the US copyeditor on the excessive colon usage, though. I passed it off as a Britishism, but most British English lit I've read didn't use them quite in that fashion, at least so much.

If basalisk poison destroys horcruxes and Harry was bitten by the basalisk in the chamber of secrets how could he still be a horcrux after that?

My favorite part was when Mrs. Weasley finally got to put down her cooking pots and knitting needles to kick some major butt. What a deliciously perfect moment. I found the epilogue -- and the rest of the book, for that matter -- to be entirely satisfying and just right, as did my 11 y.o. son (despite having his heart broken over all the deaths).

I bet most child readers like the epilogue. And as a wayyyy past childhood adult, I loved it. We get to see Harry enjoying his hero's reward--the good thing he's been hungering for all his life and through all the books: a happy family.

Great comments, Cheryl. Thanks. I especially like the Ron and Hermione romance as something out of Jane Austen--YES! (Karin Westman has written about this nicely.) I also like how, in general, the female characters seemed a little less sidekick-y in this one. We really need Hermione, MacGonagall, Mrs. Weasley, etc. Finally!

I laughed. I cried. It was better than Cats. Congrats and THANK YOU for such good and fast work. Your efforts are appreciated. I loved it all. I started crying before I read it knowing it was the last one. I was bawling by the stone scene. It was fantastic and so cathartic!

I went to church that next morning, and printed on the front of the program was, "Please don't tell me if Harry lives or not. I'm only on page 413." Oh, Cheryl, it was just fantastic. My favorite by far. The Snape and Lily thing blew me away. I've been finished for 37 hours now and I still have a hard time wrapping my head around that. But how poignant! When Snape told Harry to look at him... Oh,

Applause! Applause!A brilliant ending to series I almost gave up on after disliking the fifth book.My own 100%-spoiler-free review can be found at blog.scottrhoades.com.As for the epilogue. I didn't like it. I knew it was coming because of JKR's own comments, so I prepared myself for it.But then, to be fair, it's not the fault of the epilogue or its writer. I just don't like those kinds of

"...Snape's last request for Harry to look at him, and "the green eyes meeting the black" -- I gasped out loud when I hit that line and realized what it meant."What did it mean, what did it mean?! Oh, geez, I'm missing something deeper here, I just know it. Was Snape looking into Lily's eyes as he died?And excellent point about the basilisk venom destroying a horcrux. How did Harry survive that

I'm 'resting' a bit with my reader joy before I dive into one of the many discussions about it, but:This book made me love Harry as none of the others have -- that 'long walk home' to meet Voldemort and the epilogue (especially Albus Severus' name) removed all of the frustrations I've had with him over the years, he was just beautiful. Dobby's death broke my heart...Neville's getting to kill

I was a little anxious going into this book, as I am sure many people were. But I have to say that it moved way beyond my expectations of JK Rowling. She is truly talented like no other. I just finished reading it a little over an hour ago and am still reeling from its effects. Everyone here has hit on many of the great points in the story. The emotion of the story was incredible, so much more

I liked the epilogue too. I wanted to know more, of course, but leaving the reader wanting more is part of the allure of these books.Wonderful post. You make some excellent points.

I liked the epilogue. I agree with all that you have said. That name, Albus Severus Potter. WOW!

I loved the last Harry Potter book so much! Yes, I do believe Ron is very much like a Jane Austen character. Here are a few haiku highlights for me (though there were many, many more!):First time Harry seesSirius' room, he findshis mother's letter.Last page missing. Tornphoto. "She had made her "g"sthe same way he did."Tricking Death Eaterswith his goat patronus andcranky attitude,Hog's Head's

On the colons: J. K. Rowling seems to adopt a new favorite punctuation mark for her action scenes in some books book. In Book 5, it was the emdash, and in 7, it was definitely the colon. Roxyanne, the gasp-making significance of "green eyes" was that they were Lily's eyes, and if Snape wanted one last look at Lily's eyes, that meant that the Snape-loved-Lily theory was true. And so it was.

Did everyone notice the lack of adverbial dialogue tags in this book? I did not. Which means, I think, congratulations on a job well done. It's when you notice these things that something has gone wrong.

Aiee, a correction to my comment above: That should read, "a new favorite punctuation mark for her action scenes in each book."

I have to agree with Mrs. Pilkington about Harry himself - I found him absolutely breathtaking. He spoke with such authority, overruled the adults in his life, thanked people for the services they had rendered him. It was really thrilling to see him really live up to what had originally been thrust unwillingly onto him. He showed that he had greater willpower and strength than even Dumbledore.

Thanks so much for these insights. You've definitely helped me like the epilogue more. I guess my main problem with it was that it didn't seem to acknowledge the ongoing struggle between good and evil, except maybe in the evidently continued rivalry between the Malfoys and the Weasleys/Potters. 19 years (?) is a long time for all to be well... but I guess I'd also have been annoyed if JKR waxed

I liked this book very much. I found it satisfying and much preferable to books 5 and 6 (though I liked those better on re-reading than originally). Your points 1 and 5 are what I like about the epilogue -- that Harry has a large, loving nuclear and extended family, which is what he's missed most all these years, and that he's a good father, the kind he would've wanted to have; and that his

I loved the book. I loved the epilogue. I loved the series.I hated Hedwig's death. Was it really necessary? It colored my reading for a great many pages. I also didn't like the manner of Dobby's death. A bit stark for a children's book.For an author to keep all that foreshadowing and later revelations straight over 7 books is quite an amazing feat. I realize she had help with that, but still.My

I loved your thoughts, Cheryl. Book 7 was definitely the best one of the series. Truly remarkable! I had no idea the epilogue was coming, and it felt like a surprise gift from JKR to us, her readers. I definitely felt the writing was much stronger and tighter in this book (perhaps due to the lack of adverbial tags... Yay!) And I loved the humor throughout. One of my favorite lines was when Ron

Just found your blog, and I love it! Can I just say how jealous I am that we are almost the same exact age, and you are editing Jo's copy, and I'm editing local reporters' copy? :) Overall, I loved the book. I had a few nitpicks (Ginny's being forced to stay out of the action, not more scenes from Neville vs. Snape at Hogwarts, too much camping), but overall, it was a great ending to a great

Where is the "Barry Crouch"? People have been telling me it appears, but no one's given me a page reference yet. Also, "Jane" appeared in a JKR interview, not in a previous book, so it isn't strictly 100% canon . . . and the author could certainly have changed her mind between 2004 and now (perhaps after she realized Hermione then had the same middle name as Umbridge).

As the plane I was on made an emergency landing Saturday night, do you know what was going through my head? Yes, that if it crashed, I was not going to get to find out what happened to Harry Potter!Luckily, we didn't crash, and I have just finished the book. Harry got what he wanted all along, and love defeated evil. To my mind, that's a perfect ending to the series.

I'm so surprised that people are having problems with those things!! I loved the epilogue -- it's just the sort of life I would hope for for Harry! When I got there I shouted, "Nineteen years later!" to my husband. I agree I wouldn't have minded knowing a few more things -- I always love the wrap-up portion at the end of a book with lots of characters -- but she told us the important stuff. I'm

beautiful review. i'm confused though, what was the significance of the green eyes meeting the black eyes? and what are adverbial tags?

"there’s a fanfic waiting to be written"Already done: http://bibliophile20.livejournal.com/73547.html

I found a liveblog somewhere where a reader remarked, “I knew Regulus Black was R.A.B. as soon as I saw the handwriting!” This made me throw my arms in the air and shout “YES!”, as we deliberately set the handwriting on the door in the same font as the note to give readers (and Harry) precisely that clue and payoff. Yay!I noticed the handwriting too, but my first reaction was, "Is it what JKR

It was wonderful to be able to read this. Thanks for posting it.I didn't understand the significance of Snape's wanting Harry to look at him until you mention it. Oh man. Now that line's like a dagger.Also, now that I see it mentioned, I realize that I wasn't once tripped up by the word "coolly" - which was literally the only thing I hated about Book 5.Bravo!

Thanks for this Cheryl. I love what you had to say and I hope your comments and viewpoints help more people to appreciate some of the more debated parts of the book. As for myself, I too have not cried much in these books, though I have loved and enjoyed them immensely, but I do have to say that the point at which tears started to fall for me, was during the battle, when Harry, Ron, and

so well said. I have never read fan-fic because I don't see the point. I also completely stopped listening to podcasts around January because I didn't want to have any expectations of "what better be in there". This is Jo's creation and I wanted to thoroughly enjoy it, and I SO did. I loved every bit of it. I was 100% convinced that Harry was going to die and it would end there. For her to

The Epilogue was a nice way to tie up the story. I loved the part where Harry told Albus about his name. One of the best parts of the Battle at Hogwarts were the house elves attacking with the kitchen ware. Also the fact that I hear music building up while the were preparing and then blasting in my head during the heart of the battle.Overall it was a fantastic book, I would have liked to see a

Bravo Cheryl!!!! Very eloquently put. I loved this book. I have been shocked at the response by those who were (to put it lightly) less than thrilled with it. Your insights have made me love it all that much more.I also have to say that one of my favorite parts was when Mrs. Weasley called Bellatrix out. I jumped up and shouted "YES! You Get Her!"I feel honored to have been able to be apart of it

that's a lovely summation of the book. i noticed that you didn't touch on the "King's Cross" chapter, though. i'd love to know what you thought about that--perhaps in a future PotterCast? =]

Great work and I can easily say this is my favorite in the series. The editing was tighter, the emotional roller coaster was better than anything Universal could produce and you left with the same feeling you have after a truly amazing dinner and evening. Full, satisfied, ruminating over the flavors and memories but still wanting more, although you are completely elated with an amazing

Quick question- in the epilogue she writes, "He checked the battered old watch that had at once been Fabian Prewett's." Who was Fabian Prewett?Thanks!

I liked the epilogue..... I just wanted to know what they (Hermione especially) were doing for a living (as she's not going into magical law... she wants to make a difference). I guess that's what the encyclopedia's for... right?I loved when Ron came back.The only book I really sobbed during was HBP. I got choked up when Sirius died, and got teary-eyed during this book, but I think I just

All I can say is WOW! I loved it. AND, having just found out that Jo said she would be putting out an encyclopedia where it would fill in more of the 19 years I am more content with the book than ever. I never had a problem with it, and I thought that the epilogue makes for a good mysterious and left us to our imaginations. I am excited that some day we will find out what happened to the whole

Fabian Prewett was Molly's brother. When Moody is showing Harry the picture of the first Order of the Phoenix, he mentions both of the Prewett brothers having been killed, but taking out many Death Eaters with them. Rowling confirmed that the Prewetts were Molly's brothers on her web site.

Thanks for defending the epilogue and the deathly hallows Cheryl. I work for Leaky and have been noticing the discord cropping up in the lounge, but really haven't had a chance to go back, reread the book, and gather my thoughts nicely enough to face off against raging posters. It was nice to read your take on it, and recognize that I understand and feel very similarly to you. I've felt almost

Snape asking Harry to look at him with Lily's eyes ask he slipped into death was worth the whole series. I knew it was coming, and it still hit home. I could so be Snape.Yep, I noticed not noticing the adverbs. I didn't have to gloss over the tags nearly as much.TiTANic? Bloody mental, you are.

I think a lot of fan disappointment with the epilogue will fade with a second reading.I was a little perturbed by it the on the first read, for several reasons which may hold true for others. In all of the first six books, there are at least 20 or more pages following the "final battle" in which loose ends are tied up and the characters reflect on what just happened. Therefore, there is a sense

Well done. Your comments mirror so much of my own thoughts, it's gret to see them articulated so well.Yes - about the Deathly Hallows - ultimately I felt that the objects were not important. It is the emotions, the moral challenges and the relationships between the characters that felt painfully real to me. The objects are just objects - it is Voldemort's greed, Harry's courage, the growth of the

This was a lovely summation and I can agree with most of what you said here. I too, had no tears until Harry walked the walk towards death and self sacrifice. That he remained limp afterwards was a master stroke of story telling. He surrendered all his vanity, pride and anger, which is a place I think we all wish to attain some time in our own lives.I did not appreciate the epilog, I wanted to

I am curious, what did the "green eyes meeting the black" mean? For some reason I'm just not understanding. If someone could explain I'd really appreciate it :) I'm trying to understand, I might have to go through it all again I spose...

Snape wanted to look into Lily's (Harry's) eyes as he died.Also, the Barry Crouch seems to be on page 94 in some editions. I have the deluxe edition, and it's right in mine, but I saw page scans that showed it wrong on 94.

Hello! Melissa from Leaky put me on to your blog, and I have to say I agree with you whole heartedly. A friend of mine said he was shocked that "as a person with a degree in English" I had liked the book. His ensuing arguments sounded as if he could not accept how JKR finished *her* novel because, seemingly, he'd dived far too deep into the dark side of the fandom that makes you angry when Jo

I'm not an epilogue kind of person in any kind of book. i really think that all those things which you said were reflected in the epilogue were obvious just from reading the series and the last installment. of course harry would value family life and being a regular no one over anything else. He saw his family in the mirror and he did get rid of the hallows (except for the cloak). and it was

I agree with you! LOVED the epilogue! I LOVED Albus Severus! I LOVED Snape and Lily! I LOVED Aberforth! I LOVED the humour through the darkness! I LOVED Teddy Lupin! I LOVED Dudley's goodbye! I LOVED the book!!!!!!!!

Cheryl, thanks for this: really well put and insightful.I have to say that I was so moved at the moment when Hermione finally kisses Ron at the mention of House Elves, it was funny, moving and enormously significant of the development of the characters, as you have well explained.I also thoroughly enjoyed the wandlore that was included in this book: I know that many people felt that there was a

I agree with your feelings on the epilogue 100%. As a parent, I felt terribly comforted and at peace with that chapter. Parents have an unceasing desire to look into their childrens' futures just to see how they will be in twenty odd years. Alhtough impossible to know, the fantasizing about how their lives will turn out: happy, content, and yes, normal, are hopes that keep you going. Although

After I read your post, I really came to agreements with the epilogue and the whole series in general. :-)

Thanks for the "Barry/Barty" page reference, Melissa. It clearly says "Barty" in my regular edition too, so unless someone sends me a copy of a printed page that says "Barry," I'm going to assume it was simply a blurry scan and not a real typo.

1) I feel badly for Severus Snape. He really didn't catch much in the way of breaks, did he? But at least he gets to have some immortality along with the other headmasters. (He and Dumbledore get to be little Albus Severus' ghostly godfathers, I suspect, with McGonagall being godmother. And with the initials A.S.P., you know the kid's going to be a Slytherin.)2) A lot of people are angry at

I have to disagree with the people who found the camping unnecessary. I felt it illustrated their isolation and frustration with their task, committed though they were they had very little to go on. It took me a day or so to really appreciate the epilogue, the more I thought about it the more I realized what it revealed about Harry's life now. I laughed and cried through this book and at the end

Thank you for writing this. I have been trapped without internet since reading DH on the 21st, with no other readers to talk to, and I came up with similar thoughts after a lot of reflection. I was part of the small "Harry must die" camp, after reading the first three (five?) books and looking at the literary tradition from which JKR arose. At our Predicitions Party I admitted that the books may

Absolutely wonderful review! Just ran across your blog and think it brilliant.Thank you so much for the thoughts on the epilogue. I think you got it exactly right.

I loved the book the themes, humour, morality questions(euthanasia, sacrifice, bonds of family and friendship choices love, death, etc etc),the including of many references to previous legends and lore. there were however a couple of things which i am unsure aboutHarry being a horux was already mentioned several times in previous books - hinted at anyway - however why when he was bitten by the

I just wanted to say that I agreed with everything you wrote. Thank you for them. I felt the same way reading the comments on all the discussion boards. I loved the book and was disappointed by how many people seemed to miss the point.I have never cried reading a book before but while reading 'The Forest Again' I sobbed. I sobbed harder after he asks his parents, Sirius and Lupin to stay with

I absolutely agree and thank you so much for your thoughts. I, for one, was so grateful to Jo for giving Harry a "normal" life in the epilogue. After all, that is what he longed for throughout all the novels. I appreciate the opportunity that she bestowed on her readers to imagine the "left out" details for themselves. What a gift! PS The comparisons to Jane Austen were spot on.

I loved the epilog, but, overall, found the book too expository and frequently boring. That said, I enjoyed it...just not as much as the rest.Of course, I wanted Snape to get the girl (any girl; and a bottle of shampoo.) I knew he was really a hero!

Hello,Thanks for making your comments public. For me, the success of this series revolved around the conclusion of the Snape story arc. Here, Rowling chose unwisely. She reduced her wonderfully real, powerful, intelligent and complex character to the status of simple pawn who is rightly to be pitied. Then she capped that off by giving said character the most cruel and meaningless death she

Cheryl, that was an amazing analysis of the book, and I have to say I totally agree with you on all points. The epilogue was an amazing chapter and the "The Forest Again" chapter was the first time I ever got teary-eyed at a Harry Potter book as well.I have to apologize, though--I didn't see your awesome editing job of Book 7 because I'm Canadian, and had the Bloomsbury edition of the book, which

Maybe you can answer a question (or debunk a rumor) that I've heard for years: Scholastic "translated" the HP books from British English to American English -- true or false? If the books were "translated", then what was the reasoning behind such a decision?Freddie ([email protected])

Thank You Cheryl for your wonderful insight. It must have been so difficult for you over the past 7 months, virtually having to avoid everyone, I suppose. Finishing the book on Sunday night, I was filled with such a comforting sense of fulfillment. I think JKR is perhaps the most brilliant author to have come out of Britain since Tolkien. Bar none.The most amazing insight I have gotten out of

Nicely put.I hadn't noticed the adverbial dialogue tags, which is of course the point. Great! That makes me happy.My problem with the epilogue was simply that I didn't think it was written as well as the rest of the book. It wasn't the content or the scene, it just seemed a little forced to me. It was like she was trying too hard to put all these details into it, when of course your aim is to

Nice review! I agree with you wholeheartedly!on the whole 'Harry is a horcrux so why didn't the basilisk venom destroy it in book 2' thing, i think it's because the venom must destroy the vessel of the horcrux to destroy the horcrux tself, and because fawkes saved Harry by crying onto his wound, the horcrux remained intact, as it were, inside Harry.Also, don't you think that Sirius' story is

I am soooo sad that the series is over. They have seen me through some tuff times. But alas, all good things must have an ending and I will always have the books to read and I will continue to pick them up and read them. This book was great because it was the end and we have all been looking forwards to it. It was also greatly saddening because of the deaths and the revealing moments and the

I did love the fact that he became a regular joe at the end. It would have been nice to know who was taking care of the son of Lupin and who Luna wound up with, but my wife has many abandoment issues. That's why she was most interested in that aspect.The line I loved was "Yes, this is all happening in your head, but why does that mean it's not real?" (to paraphrase). Having hit that wall many

I have to say that I agree with you Cheryl. I have already started to re-read the 7th book so I can go back and look at the many points all of you readers have been making! The only thing I'm disappointed with, and it's entirely my fault, is that Harry didn't become the Defense against the Dark Arts teacher. I completely had my heart set on that for him. I thought it would have been perfect for

So many comments here speak of the many deaths in the latest book as being inappropriate for a children's book; two points:1)First, I see nothing wrong with death in children's literature; it is a fact of life, and I often wish I had been exposed to it more as a child prior to my grandfather's death--I might then have taken it better.2) Second, one must remember that the real, core audience of

In response to tracyb's question, "CV" stands for curriculum vitae. It's basically a resume, that includes education, awards, achievements, publications, etc.

Hey, thanks for the post.I thoroughly enjoyed reading Deathly Hallows, but I do think the epilogue is corny. I have no problems with Harry and company leading normal, peaceful lives. After what they've been through, they are well deserved. However, I feel that the chapter could have been left out entirely, the details perhaps only hinted at. I realize that by saying this I risk being publicly

I really loved what you had to say on the epilogue. Thanks for that. It did fulfull all those things. And I basically sobbed at Dobby's death and through bits and pieces up until "The Forest Again", where I basically bawled like a baby until the end. But I did laugh at those things you mentioned with the teachers and such. And the gargoyles that guard the teacher's breakroom where so cheeky,

I was thrilled with this book. I also loved the epilogue and how it answered questions wonderfully. My favourite parts were when neville pulled the hat out, when ron and hermione kissed, and when molly killed bellatrix.Hermione(YES THAT IS MY REAL NAME) i promise.

******I mean when Neville pulled the sword out of the hat Gwaaa!!Hermione*

I noticed the handwriting as well and knew in that second, :). So good job, :).And same thing with me for crying, I didn't cry for Dumbeldore or Sirius even though I loved them to death, but I cried in 'The Forest Again' as he was going to face death, I cried so much there.I liked the epilogue, personally, I just wish it had more detail and talked about people like Luna, :). And I guess I agree

I want to know if ASP (Albus Severus Potter) was intentional on JKR's part? (surely it had to be.)Thank you Melissa for sending me to this blog via Leaky, I'm sending the link to all my complaining friends. Cheryl, you ARE the best Secret Keeper Muggle (are you a muggle?) in the world!You are also so good to share your thoughts. They helped me understand my reaction, as I haven't had months to

Thank you Cheryl for sharing your comments. What a treat to hear from someone so close to the "action." I did like the epilogue... and for those who didn't (pick your reason... not enough info, to soon after the emotional battle, etc.) I just wonder what they would be saying if there was NO epilogue. If we hadn't been given those tidbits... I think people would have been very disappointed -- and

I loved the book. Every word. I've been in a fog for days now. It was beautiful, heart breaking, funny, scarey, and joyful. Not since Wuthering Heights or Emma has a book affected me like this.You don't have to defend it. But I'm glad you did anyway.Bravo.

Thank you for this, you speak out of my heart!I first grumbled quite a bit over the poor punctuation of the book (I find it distracting), but after the first 200 pages or so, it didn't distract me anymore because the plot was so damn engaging.I've seen a lot of people complaining about the "senseless" deaths JKR put so many characters through. All I can say to that is that it's a war situation

It's not that I didn't like the epilogue, because I liked it, I just wanted to know what the careers were of the some characters, Harry, Ron, Luna, Ginny, and Hermione.

I must say I'm totally with JKR on DH being my favourite book out of the series; it made me love and care for Harry as none of the others did, and I can finally really understand why Harry is her favourite character. ThankthankTHANKYOU so very much, Jo, for sharing this world with all of us.I agree with a lot of the opinions already voiced here, e.g. that in order to destroy a Horcrux its vessel

Me again, sorry, of course I forgot to mention some points in my earlier 'quick' note, haha.I found the Trio's months-long camping/hiding absolutely realistic because where the heck were they supposed to go to look for Horcruxes? They are not precisely listed on a map of Britain's must see sights, complete with instructions on how to destroy them.Ron imitating one word in Parseltongue...come on,

My problem with the epilogue was not exactly what happened in it--I agree that the closure was necessary and I think your thematic analysis is spot on. It was the style that killed me. I've heard that the epilogue has been written and waiting since the first chapter of the first book (or something similar) and if that's the case, then I think it explains my frustration. J.K. Rowling's style has

Thank you Cheryl! These are the first real comments I've read after finishing the book, but my conersations with friends were not to uplifting. I found the book very graceful and true to the story, though I were shocked to hear that some of the teories going strong in the fandom actually were true. It feels like an ending, and the big themes of J.K. Rowlings writing are tied up and continued so

I really enjoyed the manner in which you expressed your thoughts, it definitely shows you had plenty of time to thing about them.How heart-wrenching was the 'death march' Harry had when passing all the friends he wouldn't be saying good-bye to? In the forest talking with his parents/parental figures was the first time I started to tear from the books. (I was at work and had to hold them back) I

Hey, Cheryl. I was linked here by way of PotterCast, and I'm really glad that I was! You've done a great job summarizing the two main points that I've been running around the Internet attempting to stress since all the griping began.Personally, I *loved* the Hallows and thought it was just mind-blowing, that instant where Harry had to choose: Hallows or Horcruxes. It hit me at that moment just

"It was the style that killed me. I've heard that the epilogue has been written and waiting since the first chapter of the first book (or something similar) and if that's the case, then I think it explains my frustration. J.K. Rowling's style has evolved tremendously over the course of this series, along with her characters and readers. By the end of Deathly Hallows, her writing and story are

I loved the epilogue. I loved that it showed us enough to see that Harry was happy in a longterm way, that he was a wonderful dad, and that he got everything he always wanted - plus it also left plenty of room for us fanfic writers to play in this universe for years to come! I only wish we could have seen Harry's reunion with Ginny, but otherwise, I got everything I'd hoped for Harry with this

Thank you, Cheryl! I can't imagine what it must have been like to have lived with the book for so long an not being able to share it with others outside of work. It must have been torture for Jo Rowling!I wasn't looking forward to the epilogue before I had the book in hand, and I think they're always kind of a let-down. At least it was narrative, and not a encyclopedia-like list of who was doing

...forgot to say that the whole reason I started to comment myself was that after reading it, I actually liked the epilogue just fine, and felt it fit in just right (how could it be otherwise, it's her world!).

Cheryl,As a born again Christian, I couldn't help but think of the following scripture when reading Ch. 34 "The Forest Again":John 15:13 Greater love hath no man than this, that a man lay down his life for his friends. People can do comparisons all they want; I don't care. Harry isn't Christ and isn't even close. But he did love his friends so much that he attempted to die for them. I consider

"If Fawkes (reference to guy fawkes bonfires and ashes - nice) has healing tears then how come he couldn't heal Dumbledore's hand?"Because pheonix tears heal wounds, not curses. Dumbledore's hand was like that because of a curse from the ring (that Snape managed to temporarily trap in his hand.)

One thing that bugged me in my Bloomsbury edition was in the "Magic is Might" chapter:"The quality of Kreacher's cooking had improved dramatically ever since he had been given Regulas's locket..."Correct me if I'm mistaken but I'm sure Kreacher had not cooked for Harry until after he had been given Regulas's locket so Harry wouldn't have known what Kreacher's cooking standard was originally to be

Cheryl,Many, many thanks for your excellent analysis of the epilogue, as well as your thoughts on the book in general. I, too, was one of the many who felt only lukewarm towards the epilogue after my first read (That's it?!? Where's the rest? What are the trio doing for jobs? Who raised Teddy? How did George go on? etc.), but after some additional time spent thinking about it I was just deciding

I know this may sound silly, but on page 364 (us edition)Harry puts on a "jumper." Am I right in assuming that this is a british word for shirt or jacket? In the US, a jumper is a dress.

Anonymous - a "jumper" is a "sweater". Harry was cold!

I totally agree with what you said about the epilogue. After all, Harry said somewhere that all he really wants is a quiet life--and I think he deserves it. He deserves to be happy and have the family he never had when he was younger.

Re Kreacher'S cooking abilitiesI'd say Harry was thinking about the times he spend at Grimmauld Place during OotP when Sirius was till alive. Probably Kreacher did a bit of 'cooking' then.

Kreacher didn't do any cooking in OOTP - Molly Weasley did. The reader has never seen Kreacher cook for Harry before DH.

I was one of those that thought the epilogue was a little sickly sweet the first time I read it. But on rereading, I realized that it was just because of the switch off from the battle was so fast (only 3-4 pages after Voldemort's death). My emotions were too strung up and the contrast was jarring. The second time around, my emotions weren't as keyed up and I really liked it.

Here via Pottercast's pointer too - thanks for all the insight! To follow up on Christina's point, I think my reaction to the Epilogue was similarly colored by the cathartic/exhausting effects of the DH roller coaster. I loved the book, but I had been through so many traumas in such a short space that when I read the final two sentences of the epilogue, I read them as threat rather than

Yes! I definitely agree with everything you said. Deathly Hallows was lovely.I just bawled so many times throughout it. I would cry at the most trivial things, too... like the description of Hagrid's hands being as big as dustbin lids just like in the first book. Luna's room was really emotional for me too with the "friends" painting. Wow.The only thing that bothered me was that Hermione says

I loved the book; and on second reading, most of the questions i had are subsiding happily. But what is bugging me now is Dumbledore's treatment of Snape. Yes, one theme is that “it is our choices, Harry, rather than our abilities that determine who we are...” Snape chooses Slytherin, and continues throughout to be an unforgiveable bully. He never learns from his love for Lily to care about

I would just like to say that I agree with the previous comment made about Snape. I think that this is what makes Snape such a powerfully tragic figure. All he has ever wanted or needed was to give and receve love but he never gets it; not from Lily (only a friend), not from his father or, I suspect, his sour-faced mother and he has no friends. He is unable, even, I am sure, to like himself.

It took me 3 days to get through all 118 comments, but I am glad I did. I "met" you through your Pottercast appearances, but I was referred to this entry by someone else.I am not one of those who will say "I never cry at books" or "I only cried when". I will freely admit that I started crying the moment Hedwig died and only stopped during the laugh-out-loud parts.I cheered out loud when Neville

Hello, I heard about your blog through Pottercast's latest podcast where Melissa went over your support for the epilogue. For the most part I agree, at least with the first four points. But the last discussing power and happiness bothers me because I really don't think that is the case. Of course I cannot speak for every individual but I know many didn't like it because of the lack of detail when

Can someone please explain to me what ASP means in relation to Albus Severus Potter? What does ASP mean, anyway? I looked it up on Wikipedia and it was quite unenlightening.

Rowling has an editor? The continuity in the books as well as the at times clumsy prose suggest otherwise.If you have to explain the epilogue, that means it wasn't executed properly. The epilogue read like something out of fanfic net.

Well then, that just means that we have some truly great writers at FF.net, doesn't it? One of them may just be the next J. K. Rowling. And on behalf of all Potter fans who wish to appreciate this great, beloved book unhindered by hurtful remarks like yours, please confine your book-bashing to your own forums in future. (Goodness knows you have enough of them!)The rest of us are here only to say

Having read your blog, I look forward to rereading the epilogue and having a better appreciation for it. Overall, I was extremely happy with the book and was jolted by the simplicity of the epilogue. Having repeatedly been jerked in new directions throughout the book, the return to a simplistic time was unexpected, and I initially could not understand why Jo had chosen to end the book that way. I

I think I would have been disappointed without the epilogue. I've followed Harry Potter from Book 1 and I was thrilled to see him FINALLY enjoy true happiness without the threat of it being taken away. He started out without a good father figure, and lost everyone he did have down the road. I felt I could "leave" Harry knowing he finally had the happiness he so much deserved. I mean, isn't this

The epilogue is disliked for many reasons,and I think all of them are valid. One: Jo had promised several things in her interviews she did not deliver. This is an obsessive fandom. They remember things like that. She had told us that the epilogue would tell us what happened to the survivors and that we would soon know everything. No one really expected everything, but we got info on only a few

I disagree with most of your points, but most of my reasons have been restated time and time again; I will not reiterate. However, one thing that agitated me greatly about the book was one thing that you pointed out--that Harry rejected power in lieu of a sandwich.But it was that part that I hated the most; after an epic battle, where Kreacher led the house elves into battle and ultimately, aided

Oh, yeah, that was an AWESOME kiss, there, by the way. Really subtle. Thanks for that, we love you right back. You know the one I mean, right? The twisted, evil, OOC-spawned-from-the-NIGHTMARES-OF-THE-WICKED!one that needed to be stabbed to death in horror? Yup. Right. I say again; subtle. Thanks. We appreciate you too.

So exciting . . . all so exciting . . . so exciting!!!!(I'll be in line, so I'll have to tape your Nightline gig.)

Happy Harry Day to you, Cheryl!Many congrats to you on this exciting occasion. I'm getting Tivo fired up for your interview.Ever, ever so cool.Best,Mary Hershey

Do you know what is unpleasant?Having to WORK from 8:30 in the morning until 2 in the afternoon on HARRY DAY! And even more unpleasant is your horrid roommate saying she won't cover your shift because she wants to read, too.Bother, bother, bother. Five and a half hours of selling underwear, and all the while, the book, MY book is just one flight of stairs down...

We're awaiting our own Harry books in Germany--six hours ahead of the States! (no gloating, not at all...)

Nightline?!!! Wowowowowow!!!

I'm volunteering my time at a bookstore just so I can be a part of the magic. And that truly is the right word for it.Honestly, I am so proud to be a children's book writer today!- Jay

I woke up three times in anticipation of this book. I am so excited!You'll always be a rockstar in my book Cheryl.

My daughter works in a small public library...their copy of the Book is even now resting in the basement. She has adamantly refused to break her promise not to read the story until the official release, when she'll pick up her own copy at a local independent bookstore. There is still honor in the world!

I was just down at Harry Potter Place (which is AWESOME) and realized I left some important people out:* Helen Boltson, Joanne Mojica, and Dave Ascher in Planning and Finance* Corinne Van Atta in Sales* Becky Amsel and Tracy van Straaten in PublicityAlso, J. K. Rowling thanks Arthur and Emma and Kris in a lovely "acknowledgements" on her website today: www.jkrowling.com (click on the eraser,

So where will YOU be tonight?I'll be at the Border's in St. Joe if it doesn't get too crazy.

Hey, I'm all for magic moments, but the thing about reading is that you get to have them on your own time--and you get to choose your magic.But you've worked hard, girl, so go out and celebrate.

Hooray! And kudos for all your hard work!

I'm hoping to be at a bookstore party at the appointed hour, but will try to remember to tape Nightline.Congrats to you and everyone else who worked on the book on a job well-done!

This is the first time I've actually worked at my library branch on Harry Potter day, and I can't wait. I'm prepared to help the circ people check out books until every gets theirs when we open the doors at 10 am tomorrow.Then I go back to being a children's librarian the rest of the day. (okay, I"ll have my own copy of book 7 on the Children's Info desk, just in case I have a few spare moments

Oh, I meant to also say, the HP books arrived in our library system's technical center earlier this week. When the Materials Manager (and head of tech services) came to speak at our branch's librarian's meeting, she confessed that she pats them whenever she passes their pile, but they won't be fully processed until Friday. Then delivered to the branches either Friday night after we are closed,

OMG. Roger Sutton reads your blog!

All good things must come to an end. I hope that doesn't include Harry!You must be so thrilled to have been a part of something so thrilling. Kudos, Cheryl!

All so cool -- many congratulations! My daughter asked if there was going to be chocolate cake at "Harry Potter's birthday party". :)

This has been soooooooooo fun. Congratulations to you and your team.Irene

What a wonderful wild ride you've been on. Congratulations to you and the entire Harry Potter team!

My copy arrives by owl at about 11 a.m. tomorrow, then I'm observing radio silence till it is read. But I definitely will check out Nightline tonight! w00t!

Thanks for sharing this fun journey with us! Congratulations on the release (finally!!)!

Oh, Cheryl, you looked so pretty!!

You looked wonderful, Cheryl! So poised and well-spoken. You go, girl.And please tell Mr. Levine he looked great too. That's the first time I've ever seen him. He's quite handsome.

Thank you to you and everyone at AAL for bringing us Harry! (Unlike Africakid, my local German bookstore doesn't sell books at midnight, so I'm off RIGHT NOW to pick up my 9 am copy.)

I just finished the book. Man.I love Jo.

An Ode to Harryby Elizabeth O. Dulemba‘Twas release night of Harryand all through the townnot a reader could sleepor put the book down.We went to the partyand claimed our great tome.We mingled with mugglesthen took our book home.We argued and foughto’er who would read first,and find out who diedas the other one cursed,“Don’t tell me! Don’t tell me!And hide the reviews.I’ll read for myselfthe

Loved your interview. (You're so much prettier than some of the pics you publish on this blog.) I'm glad that the latest HP is such a success!

I was tuned into Nightline and was pleasantly surprised to see the interview. You did a great job! Arthur, too! It's a hoot how so many kids have become HP copyeditors.

Actually, to answer that one young proofreader's question from Nightline, there are actual lilac *trees* out there. They're called Syringa reticulata, or Japanese Tree Lilac, which grow to about 20-30' and have white panicles of flowers. They don't smell as good as regular lilac bushes though. I planted about seven lilac trees when I was horticulturing.

Congratulations!I wanted to go to the Harry and the Potters gig so bad but we were on vacation in Cape May.Coll

Cheryl, I saw a YouTube of your Nightline appearance. Gee, you didn't look like the person I remember from RPHS (or any high school student) - so glamorous, beautiful, and grown up. And, of course, so well spoken (did I need a hyphen there? - glad I'm not an editor). Congratulations on your success!! Suzanne Wischropp

!!!Cheryl is a rock star.

I tried tuning in for the live broadcast, and was treated to a thrilling discussion of the tax code as it applies to charitable religious organizations in Baltimore. I can't wait for your actual audio to go up!

I was driving to work when your interview came on. I was so excited, thinking, hooray! I read her blog! I enjoyed the interview, but thought they made you sound like you do way less in your job than you actually do. :)

Arthur discovered Phillip Pullman's "His Dark Materials"? Swear to God? That is awesome!He just moved up in my mind from genius to double super genius.Any more Pullman in the works? Do dish!Marilyn

I enjoyed your brief but interesting interview on Talk of the Nation!By the way, the caller Jeff, who said that Venus cannot be seen at midnight, was incorrect. Venus usually sets shortly after (or rises shortly before) the Sun, but sometimes it lags (or leads) by as much as a few hours. And since sunset in the northern part of the British Isles is as late as 10 PM BST at the end of June, Venus

great interview -- you were so smooth!

Are you getting excited about Harry's arrival? I want to say congrats or good luck or something, but I'm not sure of the appropriate response in this situation :(

You're on Mugglenet!!!yay!!

Dear Ms. Klein:Speaking as one copyeditor to another, I would like to beg your assistance (if you're permitted to provide it) regarding two typos in one of the purported "leaked" copies in circulation. The so-called "carpet" bootleg of the book includes mention of "Barry" Crouch and Hermione "Jean" Granger. As you may be aware, there is currently a fierce debate over whether the leaked copy is

I will not be commenting on anything related to Harry until after the book comes out, sorry. Except to say that people who read spoilers are depriving themselves of an amazing experience.

You're lucky that you've already been spoiled. The freaking internet is like a landmine of Harry Potter spoilers. I should just avoid all technology at this time. I was almost successful in avoiding spoilers when HBP came out. Almost! Except some idiot yells across the bookstore to talk to his friend: "Hey, Dumbledore died right?" as I walk in to buy the book a few days after the release! I

Seriously. The NYT.... OH, the NYT. Don't even think about going there for the next two days.TWO DAYS! Less than, even! Ohh, Cheryl, I can't even begin to imagine how excited you must be to see work come to frutition like this. Hooray!!!

As you may know (or not), John Green and his brother Hank are doing a vblog project this year called Brotherhood 2.0. Hank's song yesterday was "Accio Deathly Hallows", all about anticipation of the final title. I hope you get to check it out -- I'm sure he'd love it. They are at Brotherhood 2.0 and on YouTube.

I'm in. Too excited for the movie and book release!!The only bummer is I'll become so engrossed in the book that my writing will slack off dramatically. (not to mention the hours of sleep I'll miss)Enjoy all the good vibes coming your way during Potter mania...Hard work always pays off:)

You've got quite an exclusive accomplishment in your life... you're one of maybe 10 people who saw the Deathly Hallows manuscript before its release!

Cool on so many levels.

Many people who use my branch library are racing the clock -- re-reading the whole HP series -- hoping to finish number 6 the day before number 7 comes out.and I am one of them.I am amazed at all the foreshadowing she uses that I completely missed in my first reading of the books.librarian and writer

Thank you for remembering us little people and giving us a glimpse into your fame!BTW, I finally saw The Devil Wears Prada tonight (yes, I know, I'm just a little behind the curve) ... had to laugh at the idea that anyone could score the unpublished ms! I'm guessing it'd be easier to knock over Fort Knox.

I just wanted to let everyone know how dedicated Cheryl is to Harry Potter.I gave her a box of See's Chocolates and she still refused to tell me anything about Book VII. Sigh.(And she kept the candy.)

*apologizing for asking you in an earlier post to leak book 7**now hanging head in shame*

Hm....like your Lois Lane wig and black contacts in that Second Look feature.

I just saw "The Devil Wears Prada" this past spring, and I crossed my arms and glared at Anne Hathaway through the entire HP sequence. AS IF. But the bettere "TDWP" story is probably our entire imprint's reaction to the movie: Arthur said that he saw it, and after Anne was given her mission, he turned to his partner and asked, "Is she going to call *me*?" And my mom saw it and got excited and

I loved the image of you sitting on the manuscript while on the airplane. Did that really happen? It makes sense, but couldn't have been comfortable ;)

That was our lawyer, who picked up the manuscript's first draft. I got the second draft, and just kept it beneath my feet under the seat in front of me.

Great story about the "whole lotta papers" check!Given the size of the ms, I would have been hard to sit on it and not be noticeable, I'm thinking. :) If you're short, then it could make a nice footrest, though. Thanks in advance to you and everyone else who's brought us Potter. I CAN'T WAIT until July 21, at which point I will probably have to borrow the bookstore's secret Potter storage room to

I protest. This looks NOTHING like Cheryl!But w00t! You're famous, and justifiably so! Indeed, I would posit you were already famous. But now you're famouser. :-)Interesting comment about Mary GrandPré drawing herself as Harry. I have the poster B&N did for the last book hanging in my work cubicle, and it has the cover illustrations of Harry from the first six books. All those from Goblet of Fire

For you, I will break my vow to never go back to the Bohemian Beer Garden.

Being part of the college aged crew, I'm rather impressed with your facebook group. And 125 members, too!Because of that, I had to add you as a friend. :)

I just finished reading the TIME magazine...what a cool article! I wonder HOW you are able to keep the details of the new book inside your own head and not say anything to anyone. HOW? That's a real talent, on top of all the others!

My husband and I have been wondering . . . why did you guys transport hard copies of the manuscript, rather than putting it on a thumb drive/flash drive that could be worn on a lanyard? Though the lawyer probably wouldn't want to sit on that.

There's a reason for that, but I'm probably not allowed to tell you what it is, so I won't here. Sorry!

Awesome, Cheryl! Eric here. Phoebe, Hallie and I just had a communal reading of the Time article, during which Phoebe at some point said, "Dad, Cheryl is by FAR your coolest friend!." When I read "Klein has either the worst job in the world or the best, depending on how you look at it," both girls simultaneously said "the best" with conviction. Waytogo!

Ah . . . now that I think about it, I can guess why.

I think there should be tee shirts that say, "Cheryl Klein (the Potterologist)" Fan Club.We are planning our midnight read fest.I was bemused by the hacker with the spoilers. I think the true test of a good story is its rereadability, "The road, not the inn," to mangle Cervantes. If you know that Elizabeth marries Darcy does that ruin the story? Not one bit. What is important is how they get to

You were mentioned in The Times newspaper too (http://entertainment.timesonline.co.uk/tol/arts_and_entertainment/books/article2039650.ece). Oh and JKR's ex-teacher isn't too impressed (http://www.sundaymirror.co.uk/news/sunday/tm_method=full%26objectid=19423032%26siteid=98487-name_page.html)

Is that a Hungarian Horntail? (I am currently re-reading Book 4 and just finished the first task this morning.) And it's wonderful to see Harry, Hermione, and Ron on its back. No one is dead... yet ;)

Yes, that is amazing artwork. Thanks for sharing!(Forwarding the link to my 15-year-old-reluctant-reader-of-a-son, who scorns most books but will stay up till midnight reading Harry Potter.)

Fantastic!

VERY amazing!!!!Kelsey

A DRAGON?! Since when does anyone ride a dragon?! What are the rules pertaining to this? Ahhh, I'm so stoked!

That is so lovely! I like it much more than the "Harry with hand stretched up" version.Serious love!Muuwhaaa, Mary! You have my constant adoration.Marilyn.

Norbert? Is that you?Tying up storylines nicely, are we? No Ann Radcliffes here...

Amazing? It's 3 kids riding a dragon (ERAGON, anyone?). And yes; it's Norbert, since Hagrid is dead. The older Weasley who studies dragons has been helping. They're flying over the sleepy town of Godric's Hollow.Wizardeer

That is so cool! Glad there was a magnifying glass because my eyes aren't what they used to be. Kimberly Lynn

Ah, Wizardeer, you're no fun. It would be commonplace in the world of Eragon, sure, but when have we ever seen anyone ride a dragon in the world of HP (which is the real world tweaked)? Plus it's a beautiful piece of art in its own right. Those two things make it amazing to (highly biased) me.

It is amazing. It made me run to The Lexicon to look up more on the ten breeds of dragons in HP. HaHa.There seems to be a theme in the covers with orange-y skies. Hmmm...I both desperately anticipate and dread the release.

Our intrepid trio on the dragon's back look pretty ragged, as if they've just been saved from a difficult situation, perhaps even by said dragon.

Indeed, and if you'll notice, Ron and Hermione appear to be in school robes? And Harry is in muggle clothes. Iiiiinteresting...

I found this very, very exciting and unexpected.But I have a question about the questions Scholastic is announcing. Does whoever is writing the questions know the answers? Have they read the books? Or are they questions they just think will be important in the last books?And it's Godric's Hollow, not Hollows, right? Can the publisher of the books really not have remembered that little detail in

The people who wrote the questions have not read the books. So these are all questions they're asking as well. And yes, it is "Godric's Hollow," not Hollows . . . I usually work with our online group to be sure every page on Scholastic.com is in proper Harry style, but that one must have passed me by. Ook.

Cheryl, Thanks so much for answering my questions. That explains a lot.