by John Patrick Green [Discussing the meanings and symbology of Star Wars The Force Awakens has become a national passtime, and i the interests of leaving nofacet of this cultural landmark unexamined, our resident Stawr Wars expoert John Patrick Green has put forth a radical new theory, which you can read below.] So the movie […]
new posts in all blogs
Viewing: Blog Posts Tagged with: rey, Most Recent at Top [Help]
Results 1 - 2 of 2
By: Heidi MacDonald,
on 1/3/2016
Blog: PW -The Beat (Login to Add to MyJacketFlap)
JacketFlap tags: the phantom menace, Top News, anakin, John Patrick Green, star wars: the force awakens, Controversy!, rey, Movies, Star Wars, Add a tag
Blog: PW -The Beat (Login to Add to MyJacketFlap)
JacketFlap tags: the phantom menace, Top News, anakin, John Patrick Green, star wars: the force awakens, Controversy!, rey, Movies, Star Wars, Add a tag
10 Comments on Opinion: Why The Force Awakens is a retread of The Phantom Menace, last added: 1/4/2016
Display Comments
Add a Comment
By: Heidi MacDonald,
on 12/21/2015
Blog: PW -The Beat (Login to Add to MyJacketFlap)
JacketFlap tags: Movies, Star Wars, Disney, finn, luke skywalker, han solo, Shipping, earthsea, star wars: the force awakens, emo vader, general leia, kylo ren, kylo ren fanfic, poe dameron, rey, reylo, Add a tag
Blog: PW -The Beat (Login to Add to MyJacketFlap)
JacketFlap tags: Movies, Star Wars, Disney, finn, luke skywalker, han solo, Shipping, earthsea, star wars: the force awakens, emo vader, general leia, kylo ren, kylo ren fanfic, poe dameron, rey, reylo, Add a tag
Okay gang you've all had a chance to see Star Wars The Force Awakens. I know some of you haven't but the time has begun to discuss important things. So if you've seen the movie, go after the jump. If you haven't here's some pictures.
3 Comments on Star Wars The Force Awakens: which character is going to have the most fanfic? [Spoilers], last added: 12/22/2015
Display Comments
Add a Comment
Except that this movie (TFA) is really well done. The actors are great, the story is good, the CGI is 21st century, there is no input from George ‘franchise killer’ Lucas and, wait for it…. Jar Jar is nowhere to be seen!!!
If you don’t know why the bad guys are on that planet in the beginning then you clearly weren’t paying attention to the movie
swing and a miss, or something
No, it’s a retread of the original Star Wars. A pretty shameless one, but it seems to be working.
“Except that this movie (TFA) is really well done.”
Except that wasn’t the focus of the article. Oops.
Was someone actually paid to write that?
Here a more interesting topic. What does it say about the future of movies and movie-making that the 3 biggest box office successes (not adjusted for inflation) are films where a high level of skill was applied to utterly formulaic melodramas?
Mike
What it says is that TV is the future of the medium. Because hollywood’s photocopiers must sooner or later run out of toner.
The point is, those that argue that TFA is lifted from the original star wars would be just as reasonable in saying that it was lifted from the Phantom Menace. This satirical article is highlighting the manipulation and cherry picking that needs to be made in satisfying the former argument by using it to equate phantom menace, which people do not complain about being too similar to the originals (they complain about other things) to the new movie.
Or you could look at it like this.
Random droid with important map installed in it, wonders a sandy planet.
Main character happens to find said droid
Main characters flee an attack in a “piece of junk/garbage” spaceship that just so happens to be the Millennium Falcon.
Bad guys have a Death Star, an Emperor/Supreme Leader and main bad guy who wears a back, helmet like mask. Which is totally fine cuz we already we already who his super favorite sith lord is in the trailer
Main characters meet up with rebel’s / resistance, and find out that said death star has a weak point and plan an attack with x-wings. at least Naboo fighters where new.
One of the main characters is killed by one of the main bad guys as the main character looks on and shout’s “Nooooooo”….. Oh wait Obi Wan did that when Qui-Gon got killed.. Nah Obi Wan was killed and Luke shouted Nooooo… or did Darth Vader say it in III? such confusion.
Death Star blows up Alderaan and a bunch of other planets cuz the new Death Star is a planet, that absorbs mass from stars so it can shoot cause something or whatever.
Death Star gets blown up.
I think rhyming was what Lucas called it when he made his prequels, they mirror a lot on the originals. Personally I just thought this film had more of a IV vibe going put that’s just me.
It all just boils down to a certain point of view, point of view? point of view.
“The point is, those that argue that TFA is lifted from the original star wars would be just as reasonable in saying that it was lifted from the Phantom Menace.”
That’s a stupid point because it’s NOT TRUE.
The similarities with the original Star Wars are clear and concrete, both plot-wise and in the emotional beats of the story. The comparisons made with Phantom Menace in the article are vague and obtuse to the point of being ridiculous. For example…
“They need to find a new ship or repair parts so they can get off this planet”
.
The reason why they go to Maz Kanata’s planet in TFA has nothing to do with they they go to Tatooine in the Phantom Menace. Literally. Nothing.
Again, did someone get paid to write that?
Mike