Ida M. Tarbell: The Woman Who Challenged Big Business--and Won! by Emily Arnold McCully. Clarion Books, Houghton Mifflin Harcourt. 2014. Library copy.
It's About: Ida M. Tarbell, born in 1857, who became one of the first American journalist and also helped found investigative journalism. Her noteworthy articles included a biography of Abraham Lincoln, and an expose of John D. Rockefeller and his company, Standard Oil Trust.
The Good: I really enjoyed learning about Ida M. Tarbell, whose name seemed vaguely familiar from history class.
I was impressed with Ida's many accomplishments and the things she did -- starting with her love of the sciences, attending a co-educational college, her start in journalism, traveling to Paris, freelancing, and then joining the staff of McClure's Magazine, where she wrote her most memorable articles.
One of the things that struck me is how matter of fact it was, how "of course this is what Ida is going to do" it was. While Ida was a pioneer, her story is also a reminder that her life, while not typical of the time, was also just that -- her life. She, with other women, did go to college. She, as others did, created a career, lived away from her family, traveled to Paris, working, having her own home.
I confess: that part of Ida's life, the pre-McClure part, fascinated me the most. I wanted to know more about those things, and those people in her life.
Of course, then, there is Ida's actual journalism, a career she came to sort of sideways. She began loving science, thought she'd be a teacher, and found herself working as an editor at a magazine. It wasn't until her early thirties and her trip to Paris that her work as a journalist really began. So, you can see all the reasons I kept turning the pages -- here, a women in the nineteenth century, having multiple careers. Pursuing her dreams. Living her life on her terms.
One cannot make generalizations about people: for all of Ida's accomplishments, which resulted from drive and determination, she had what seems to be mixed feelings about women's suffrage and equality. McCully explores this area in detail, noting that Ida's being against women getting the vote is probably one of the reasons she is a bit forgotten. What struck me was how modern, actually, Ida's beliefs were: I could easily imagine her in the present, being someone explaining how she didn't need feminism and wasn't a feminist because look at what she accomplished, on her own, and if she did it anyone can so stop with the feminism already.
I would like to learn more about Ida, and her life -- always a good sign in a biography, being left wanting more! I wonder if the things I want to know more about are things that McCully didn't cover because of length (this is a long, detailed biography) or if it's because there aren't the source documentation to answer the questions. For example, I wanted to know more about Ida's unnamed roommates during her 20 but imagine that was left out because of space. I also was curious as to Ida's relationships with her family and those family dynamics. Ida loved her father dearly, and ended up being the main provider to her mother, sister, brother, and brother's family. And yet certain things here left me asking for more and wondering things like whether her father was as wonderful as she painted him, for example. Is that not explored more because of space? Or because there is very little surviving from that time that would fill in the gaps about Ida's family?
Being left with questions, wanting more -- excellent. Learning more about Ida M. Tarbell, and also about what it was like for a woman pursuing a career over a hundred years ago? Even better. I'm so happy that this is a finalist for the YALSA Excellence in Nonfiction Award! I read it because it was a finalist, and I'll be chatting it up because it's a finalist.
Amazon Affiliate. If you click from here to Amazon and buy something, I receive a percentage of the purchase price.
© Elizabeth Burns of A Chair, A Fireplace & A Tea Cozy
Viewing: Blog Posts Tagged with: Emily Arnold McCully, Most Recent at Top [Help]
Results 1 - 5 of 5
Blog: A Chair, A Fireplace and A Tea Cozy (Login to Add to MyJacketFlap)
JacketFlap tags: reviews, history, non fiction, Emily Arnold McCully, 2014, clarion books, YALSA nonfiction finalist, Add a tag
Blog: Picture Books & Pirouettes (Login to Add to MyJacketFlap)
JacketFlap tags: Ballet, Author Interviews, Holiday House, Emily Arnold McCully, Allegra Kent, New York City Ballet, George Balanchine, Ballerina Swan, The Dancer's Body Book, Once a Dancer, Add a tag
Blog: the pageturn (Login to Add to MyJacketFlap)
JacketFlap tags: AG Ford, Jan Spivey Gilchrist, kente cloth, Ntozake Shang, Rod Brown, Libraries, Books, holidays, Authors, Picture Books, booklists, Black History Month, crafts, teachers, Don Tate, Illustrators, Storytime, James Ransome, African-Americans, Jonah Winter, Emily Arnold McCully, Diane Z. Shore, Arnold Adoff, teaching guides, Eloise Greenfield, Andrea Davis Pinkney, Audrey Vernick, Smithsonian Institute, Brian Pinkney, Jessica Alexander, storytime ideas, Add a tag
My daughter’s 4th grade class is celebrating Black History Month in the most wonderful way by creating a version of Kente cloth. While it’s traditionally made with silk and cotton interweaving threads, her class used pens, paints, and colored pencils to create theirs.
Kente cloth is believed to have originated from the Akan people in West Africa*. The designs are traditionally bright, geometric, and bold. Additionally, the colors and shapes are usually symbolic of historic events, family trees, the seasons, and proverbs. (The Smithsonian Institute has wonderful information online about their “Ghanaian Kente and African American Identity” exhibition)
Making Kente cloths in your library is just one of many ideas to celebrate Black History Month. Texas Library Club has a wonderful list of books, songs, and activities – including a way of making Kente cloths by weaving strips of paper together.
We’d also love to recommend these books for your Black History Month displays:
- BARACK by Jonah Winter, illustrated by AG Ford
- BLACK IS BROWN IS TAN by Arnold Adoff, illustrated by Emily Arnold McCully
- BOYCOTT BLUES by Andrea Davis Pinkney, illustrated by Brian Pinkney (download the Teacher’s Guide)
- THE GREAT MIGRATION by Eloise Greenfield, illustrated by Jan Spivey Gilchrist
- SHE LOVED BASEBALL by Audrey Vernick, illustrated by Don Tate
- THIS IS THE DREAM by Diane Z. Shore and Jessica Alexander, illustrated by James Ransome
- WE TROUBLED THE WATERS by Ntozake Shang, illustrated by Rod Brown
And you can also download our Black History Month Classroom Kit.
What are you doing at your library to celebrate Black History Month? We’d love to hear your ideas (or even photos of any displays you’ve created)!
* As a former librarian, I have to share this disclaimer: I got my information from Wikipedia.
Add a CommentBlog: GregLSBlog (Login to Add to MyJacketFlap)
JacketFlap tags: picture book, Emily Arnold McCully, Lascaux, Add a tag
THE SECRET CAVE: DISCOVERING LASCAUX, by Emily Arnold McCully (FSG 2010)(ages 6-9). Almost exactly seventy years ago, four boys stumbled upon one of the cultural treasures of the world: the Paleolithic cave paintings at Lascaux.
THE SECRET CAVE provides a fictionalized account of that discovery - four boys, seeking hidden treasure, find a hidden cave and go exploring...But how will they keep their find a secret?
Story and art are intriguing and suitably evocative: the brightness of the French countryside is contrasted nicely with the mysterious darkness of the caves, and scope of the Paleolithic art is merely hinted at. An excellent introduction to human prehistory.
Blog: PaperTigers (Login to Add to MyJacketFlap)
JacketFlap tags: Birmingham 1963, multicultural book events, One Thousand Tracings: Healing the Wounds of World War II, Rickshaw Girl, The Escape of Oney Judge: Martha Washington's Slave Finds Freedom, We are One: The Story of Bayard Rustin, Mitali Perkins, children's book awards, E Title, B Authors, B Title, M Authors, O Title, W Authors, W Title, C Authors, J Authors, P Authors, R Title, 1963, Christoper Paul Curtis, Elijah of Buxton, Emily Arnold McCully, Jane Addams Children's Book Awards, Larry Dane Brimner, Eventful World, Birmingham, Lita Judge, Carole Boston Weatherford, Add a tag
The Jane Addams Children’s Book Awards are given annually to children’s books published in the preceding year that effectively promote the cause of peace, social justice, world community, and the equality of the sexes and all races, as well as meeting conventional standards for excellence. On October 17th, winners of the 55th Jane Addams Children’s Book Awards received their awards, gave their acceptance speeches, and signed copies of their books at the United Nations Plaza in New York City.
PaperTigers congratulates:
WINNER - Books for Younger Children Category
The Escape of Oney Judge: Martha Washington’s Slave Finds Freedom, written and illustrated by Emily Arnold McCully
WINNER - Books For Older Children Category
We are One: The Story of Bayard Rustin, written by Larry Dane Brimner
HONORS - Books for Younger Children Category
One Thousand Tracings: Healing the Wounds of World War II, written and illustrated by Lita Judge
HONORS - Books for Older Children Category
Rickshaw Girl, written by Mitali Perkins with illustrations by Jamie Hogan
Honors - Books for Older Children Category
Elijah of Buxton, written by Christopher Paul Curtis
Honors - Books for Older Children Category
Birmingham, 1963, written by Carole Boston Weatherford
You can read Mitali’s acceptance speech and see photos of the event on her blog. Check out Larry Brimner’s Write. Write. Written! — A Writer’s Journal and Lita Judge’s blog as well!
In November our PaperTigers website will focus on the theme of “war and peace in children’s books,” featuring original essays by Lita Judge (One Thousand Tracings) and Jo Montie, former member of the Jane Addams Award committee.