With
Behind the Beautiful Forevers, Pulitzer Prize winner Katherine Boo does more than merely bear witness in Annawadi, the slum that grew up in the shadows of the Mumbai airport and features a sewage lake, horses painted to mimic zebras, and every possible form of corruption.
She does more than sit with the trash pickers, the schemers, the envious, the hungry, the souls who conclude that death is the only way out.
She tells a story. She involves her readers in the intimate dramas of an open-wound place. She compels us to turn the pages to find out what will happen to the prostituting wife with half a leg, the boy who is quick to calculate the value of bottle caps, the man with the bad heart valve, the "best" girl who hopes to sell insurance some day, the "respectable" rising politician who sleeps with whomever will help her further rise, the police who invent new ways to crush crushed souls.
She engages us, and because she does, she leaves us with a story we won't forget. Like
Elizabeth Kolbert, another extraordinary
New Yorker writer, Boo takes her time to discover for us the unvarnished facts, the pressing needs, the realities of things we might not want to think about.
But even if we don't think about them, they are brutally real. They are.
A passage:
What was unfolding in Mumbai was unfolding elsewhere, too. In the age of global market capitalism, hopes and grievances were narrowly conceived, which blunted a sense of common predicament. Poor people didn't unite; they competed ferociously amongst themselves for gains as slender as they were provisional. And this undercity strife created only the faintest ripple in the fabric of the society at large. The gates of the rich, occasionally rattled, remained unbreached. The politicians held forth on the middle class. The poor took down one another, and the world's great, unequal cities soldiered on in relative peace.
Like the photos featured in
this earlier blog post, the picture above is not Mumbai; I've never been to India. It is Juarez, another dry and needing place on this earth.
Last week, over dinner, I was telling friends about Juarez—about the trip we took years ago to a squatters' village, where we met some of the most gorgeous young people I'll ever know. We'd gone to help build a bathroom in a community without water. The children emerged from homes like those above, impeccably dressed and mannered.
Yesterday and today I am reading, at last, Katherine Boo's
Behind the Beautiful Forevers. I bought the book the week it came out. It has sat here ever since, waiting for me to find time. I am, as most people know, a devotee of well-made and purposeful documentaries. Reading Boo is like watching one of those. Her compassion, her open ear, her reporting—I'll write more of this tomorrow. But for this Sunday morning I want to share again the faces of the children I fell in love with, the children who eventually worked their way into my young adult novel,
The Heart Is Not a Size. They are breathtaking. Still. And I, as a writer, remain most alive when I feel that the story I tell might make a difference.
When my American Express bill came in this past month, something odd and spectacularly unprecedented occurred: I owed a mere ninety-nine cents. True, I have been so holed up here, so focused on work, that I've been operating as a blinkered horse, my eyes on the finish line (s), my mind shutting out all purchase-able distractions. Also true: Except when it comes to buying gifts (I buy many, many gifts) I have never been exactly profligate. Malls drive me batty. Excess crowds me in. My decorating aesthetic is whatever lies between homey and uncluttered, warm and just enough. My wardrobe features three pairs of jeans, some turtlenecks, some sweaters/coats, an occasional skirt, and some dresses, for when I have to wear dresses. My mother used to buy me my most interesting, most meaningful clothes. She passed away several years ago, and I never rose to the challenge.
(I do like shoes. By my count, I have too many shoes.)
Still, what I do buy is books—I buy a lot of books—in support of an industry, in specific support of specific authors. Thus, I rectified my no-buying spree yesterday by adding a number of titles to my personal library, all of them, I realize, falling into the nonfiction camp. That's nonfiction the way I define it, and not the way
John D'Agata wishes I would. (For more on the D'Agata controversy, I suggest you read the
Gideon Lewis-Kraus RIFF in the
New York Times.)
Among the titles that will (at one point) be reported on here are the following:
Rough Likeness: Essays (Lia Purpura)
Create Dangerously: The Immigrant Artist at Work (Edwidge Danticat)
Behind the Beautiful Forevers: Life, death, and hope in a Mumbai undercity (Katherine Boo)
Winter: Five Windows on the Season (Adam Gopnik)
House of Stone: A Memoir of Home, Family, and a Lost Middle East (Anthony Shadid)
Istanbul: Memories and the City (Orhan Pamuk)
The Naive and the Sentimental Novelist (Orhan Pamuk)
I don't read a ton of nonfiction, but some of these titles intrigue me. I also tend to buy many gifts...I see a thing and pick it up for someone's birthday down the road.
What a great list! My vice is buying books . . . and not getting them all read! I have drawers full, a canvas tote bag full, counter and tabletops stacked. And yet I buy more.
I am always reading at least two books, but I think to become a truly serious reader I must give up as much movie watching as I do. Hard choices in life, you know?
First of all, there are never too many shoes. :)
And I just love that you went out and bought books after realizing you spent so little the month previously. :)