{Trisha’s note: My most recent post at the Kirkus blog is about Neesha Meminger’s new novel, Jazz in Love. I said, among other things, that it was predictable but fun, and I was intrigued by Neesha’s response on her blog: “I don’t mind ‘predictable’ – there are thousands of predictable books on the shelves featuring white teens. In a sea of books about PoC who suffer nobly, are rescued by white or western saviours, or are living amidst despair and violence, I am delighted that in this book, South Asian teens get to star in a light, fun, somewhat predictable read that was compared to some of Meg Cabot’s (The Princess Diaries) writing .” Oh, I thought, I want to hear more about this! So I asked Neesha if she’d be willing to write a guest post about why predictable can be a good thing, and (yay!) she agreed.}
My first novel, Shine, Coconut Moon, which I am very proud of, was about race and identity–not groundbreaking themes in South Asian literature, or literature by and about people of colour in general. The book explored issues of racism, discrimination, terrorism. These themes have been done time and again, superbly, by many an author of colour before me.
My second novel, Jazz in Love, is steeped in teen culture and gets very close to the teen view of life. I was clear at the onset that I wanted to write a light, fun, contemporary novel featuring South Asian teens. I didn’t want to focus on the identity of my characters, but I didn’t want to ignore it either. I wanted to place my story smack dab in the middle of popular culture, and I wanted to create a world that consisted of teens from a variety of cultural backgrounds. While there are issues of class (Jazz’s parents are working class, unlike the usual Indian-American narrative), caste, spousal abuse and dating violence, there is no identity struggle, no overt racism or racial issues, no overt mention of discrimination and no references to terrorism. The “heavier” issues are dealt with using a light touch, and the focus is the universal journey of teens navigating the often volatile landscape of teenhood.
My first novel was picked up by a large, New York publisher and my second novel was self-published. I think the reasons Jazz in Love didn’t get picked up by a large publisher are complex. But one of them had to be the big economic crash in 2008. My (then) agent sent the manuscript around on Monday and on Wednesday news broke of what became known as “Black Wednesday” in publishing. Editors were laid off left and right, and most were afraid for their jobs. The last thing, I’m sure, an editor was thinking of doing at that time, was fighting to acquire a manuscript others might consider “risky”. There are so many reasons a book is successful or not, and a lot of them have to do with a publisher’s expectations for a book at the onset. One editor respon
[...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Trisha, Library Feed. Library Feed said: An Equal Place at the Table: A guest post by Neesha Meminger http://bit.ly/i3hm1b [...]
I found Jazz in Love through The Rejectionist, read it and loved it. I hadn’t read much South Asian literature before, but because of Jazz’s lighthearted and easily accessible I’m eager to read more about the lives of these teens. Besides, not every teen’s life is full of meaningful and important “issues”, sometimes life is just fun and sort of silly, no matter what color or class you are.
I love this post! It is so true
WORD.
I really thought that Bindi Babes series was fluffy — but I liked it like a guilty snack of salty taro chips in bed, and that’s where I read it, wrapped in soft comforters and snickering at their ridiculous adventures.
I thank you very much for eliciting this interview from Neesha — this is the type of stuff I need to tattoo on my hands so I remember: not every story featuring a person of color must be about The Struggle. I always wanted to write fiction which depicted the commonality of the HUMAN experience …and in that experience must be both lightness and grief, comedy and confrontation, and the occasionally fluffy novel about boys and girls in love.
YES. Thank you so much for this, Neesha. And I have to agree with Tanita, my new mantra is now not every story featuring a person of colour must be about The Struggle too. That’s exactly what I’m trying to write at the moment – a story about a girl who has to join the witness protection programme, who also happens to be mixed race – and I keep questioning whether I’m getting the balance between acknowledging that the MC is a CoC and not beating the reader over the head with it. I’ve found it very difficult so what you said is so reassuring. Thank you again. And I wish you every success with Jazz in Love.
I love this post, and I am looking forward to reading Jazz In Love. I completely agree with everything Neesha Meminger says! I had a hard time placing my YA novel about LGBT teens which is NOT about coming out or how hard it is to be gay, but just an entertaining time travel story where the main characters happen to be queer. I am impressed at the flexible way Neesha decided to self-publish, and what gorgeous cover and book design Jazz In Love has.
Loved this! Thank you Neesha Meminger for saying so clearly how so many writers and readers feel. We are not, none of us, one monolith “community” that all think and feel the same. And, let me add, I know plenty of African American readers who are reading and loving Meminger’s books. Wish you continued success!
I loved how you said that teens of color need to have books with fantasy, play, and romance. All books don’t necessarily need to delve into the “dynamics.” Great reads also involve escape and fun.
I think the industry may underestimate how much teens of color would love to see more of these types of books featuring characters that reflect themselves.
What an excellent post! Thank you for sharing it.
[...] for addressing equity in publishing. Make sure you read Neesha Meminger‘s guest post at The Ya Ya Yas Blog: Fantasy and play and romance. Play. It’s the space where creativity happens. It’s a place of [...]