By Anatoly Liberman During five and a half years of its existence, this blog has featured the periodical Notes and Queries twice. Why I am turning to this subject again (now probably for the last time) will become clear at the end of the post. Notes and Queries appeared on November 3, 1849. In a series of short notes (naturally, notes) spread over the years 1876-1877, its first editor William John Thoms (1803-1885) told the world how the periodical had become a reality and how almost overnight
Viewing: Blog Posts Tagged with: thoms, Most Recent at Top [Help]
Results 1 - 4 of 4
Blog: OUPblog (Login to Add to MyJacketFlap)
JacketFlap tags: william thoms, Oxford Etymologist, word origins, anatoly liberman, thoms, jubilee, *Featured, notes and queries, Lexicography & Language, Add a tag
Blog: OUPblog (Login to Add to MyJacketFlap)
JacketFlap tags: Blog, The, Oxford, John, folklore, Queries, A-Featured, Oxford Etymologist, Lexicography, and, Notes, Etymologist, Anatoly, Liberman, OUP, William, thoms, Athenaeum, Add a tag
All words must have been coined by individuals. This statement surprises and embarrasses not only the uninitiated but also some language historians. We are used to thinking that “people” created ancient language and art, but what is people? (This question, though in another guise, will recur below.) A group of activists working together and producing in chorus meaningful sound complexes like big ~ bag ~ bug ~ bog? Or a committee like those on which we sit, organs of collective wisdom? As a rule, every novelty that does not die “without issue” passes through a predictable cycle: someone has something to offer, a small group of enthusiasts surrounding the inventor adopts it, more adherents show their support, the novelty becomes common property, and (not necessarily) the originator is forgotten. We have no way of tracing the beginning of the oldest words, and even some neologisms remain etymological puzzles, but the names of some “wordsmiths” have not been lost. For instance, Lilliputian was coined by Jonathan Swift, gas by J.B. van Helmont, and jeep (which later became Jeep) by E.C. Segar. As a rule, inventors use the material at hand. Swift seems to have combined lil, the colloquial pronunciation of little and put(t) “blockhead,” a slang word common in the 18th century. Van Helmont was probably inspired by the Dutch pronunciation of chaos. Jeep is sound imitative, like peep. In similar fashion, we have no doubt about the structure of the noun folklore (folk + lore), but the story of its emergence is worth telling.
William John Thoms (1802-1885) began his literary career as an expert editor of old tales and prose romances. He also investigated customs and superstitions. Especially interesting are his studies of popular lore in Shakespeare: elves, fairies, Puck, Queen Mab, and others. They were published in the forties, the decade in which he met his star hour. Special works on Thoms are extremely few (the main one dates to 1946), and the archival documents pertaining to him remain untapped, but he related some events of his life himself. It was not by chance that California Folklore Quarterly printed an article about him (“’Folklore’: William John Thoms” by Duncan Emrich, volume 5, pp. 155-374) in 1946. A hundred years earlier a letter signed by Ambrose Merton appeared in the London-based journal The Athenaeum. Those who have leafed through its huge folio volumes probably could not help wondering how the subscribers managed to find their way through such an enormous mass of heterogeneous materials. Yet that weekly had a devoted readership, and its voice reached far.
The 1846 letter is available in two modern anthologies, but outside the professional circle of folklorists hardly anyone has read it, so that I will quote its beginning and end. “Your pages have so often given evidence of the interest which you take in what we in England designate as Popular Antiquities, or Popular Literature (though by-the-by it is more a Lore than a literature, and would be most aptly described by a good Saxon compound, Folklore,—the Lore of the People)—that I am not without hopes of enlisting your aid in garnering the few ears which are remaining, scattered over that field from which our forefathers might have gathered a goodly crop. No one who has made the manners, customs, observances, superstitions, ballads, proverbs, etc., of the olden time his study, but must have arrived at two conclusions:—the first how much that is curious and interesting in those matters is now entirely lost—the second, how much may yet be rescued by timely exertion…. It is only honest that I should tell you I have long been contemplating a work upon our “Folklore” (under that title, mind Messes. A, B, and C,—so do not try to forestall me);—and I am personally interested in the success of the experiment which I have, in this letter, albeit imperfectly, urged you to undertake.” Not only did the editor of The Athenaeum welcome the letter. He opened a special rubric for “folk-lore,” and “Ambrose Merton” (this was Thoms of course) became its editor.
The letter was followed by an injunction, part of which is so much to the point that it must be reproduced here: “We have taken some time to weigh the suggestion of our correspondent—desirous to satisfy ourselves that any good of the kind which he proposes could be effected in such space as we are able to spare from the many other demands upon our columns; and have before our eyes the fear of that shower of trivial communication which a notice in conformity with his suggestion is likely to bring. We have finally decided that, if our antiquarian correspondents be earnest and well-informed and subject their communications to the condition of having something to communicate, we may… be the means of effecting some valuable salvage for the future historian of old customs and feelings…. With these views, however, we must announce to our future contributors under the above head, that their communications will be subjected to a careful sifting—both as regards value, authenticity, and novelty; and that they will save both themselves and us much unnecessary trouble if they will refrain from offering any facts and speculations which at once need recording and deserve it.”
Thoms may have regretted the fact that he wrote his letter to The Athenaeum under a pseudonym, for a year later, in another letter to the same journal, he disclosed his identity. He more than once reminded his readers that it was he who launched the word folklore. From time to time somebody would derive folklore from German or Danish. As long as he lived, Thoms kept refuting such unworthy rumors (he also suffered from the neglect of his Shakespeare scholarship); after his death others defended him. The word found acceptance both in the English speaking world and abroad. German, Austrian, and Swiss scholars eventually borrowed it with its original spelling (Folklore), though the German for folk is Volk. By the end of the eighties folklore had become an accepted term in Scandinavia, as well as in the Romance and Slavic speaking countries. The British Folklore Society, which was also formed largely thanks to Thoms’s efforts, adopted the title Folk-Lore Record for its journal (now it is called simply Folklore), and Thoms was elected the Society’s director. In the introduction to the first volume he noted, perhaps not without a touch of irony, that the word he had coined would make him better known than the rest of his professional activities.
As we have seen, the “Saxon” term folklore was applied to the vanishing “manners, customs, observances, superstitions, ballads, proverbs, etc.” Thoms did not realize how ambiguous his agenda was. For more than 150 years, researchers have been arguing over whether the subject of folklore is only “survivals” (does modern folklore exist?), who are the people, the “folk” to be approached, and whether folklore is the name of the treasures to be collected and described or of the science (“the lore”) devoted to them. Today folklore is often understood as a study of verbal art, but not less often it passes off as a branch of cultural anthropology. In 1846 folk meant “peasantry,” which excluded urban culture. One also spoke vaguely of common people, of story tellers nearly untouched by the advance of civilization, and of the working people in the “byeways of England” (the phrase, spelling and all, is from The Gentleman’s Magazine for 1885). Railways were the main bugaboo of those who watched the rural landscape disappear under the wheels of the devil, the steam engine. Being run over by a train became a literary motif.
In 1849 an event of great importance happened in Thoms’s life: he began publishing his own weekly that, after rejecting many titles and ignoring the advice of some well-wishers, he decided to call Notes and Queries. His old appeal to the readers to send ballads, tales, proverbs, descriptions of customs, and so forth brought many responses, and Thoms was loath to start a rival periodical, for fear of undermining The Athenaeum, but he received the editor’s blessing. The new journal turned into a main forum for letters that Thoms had invited correspondents to send to The Athenaeum. The rubric on “folk-lore” in both periodicals made the term familiar, and later the derivatives (folklorist and folkloric) emerged. Before resigning as editor, Thoms told the story of his magazine in a series of short essays and published them in Notes and Queries for 1871 and 1872. In 1848 Dombey and Son appeared. One of the novel’s most endearing characters is the one-armed Captain Cuttle. Like so many other personages brought to life by Dickens, the good captain has a tag: he likes to repeat the maxim “When found, make a note of.” Thoms used this catchphrase as a motto for his journal, and it was printed on the title page of each issue.
I have already written about the value and the worldwide success of Notes and Queries. This magazine is one of a kind. Personally, I owe a tremendous debt of gratitude to it, for suggestions on word origins were (and still are) common in Notes and Queries, and I have nearly 8000 of them in my database. Some words have been discussed only in its pages, and some first-rate specialists sought no better exposure of their ideas. The man who invented the word folklore and founded Notes and Queries deserves to be remembered, and I am sorry that no one has written a book about him. The reason may be that he was neither a professor nor a madman. Perfectly sane and of humble origin, he was survived by his wife and nine children.
Anatoly Liberman is the author of Word Origins…And How We Know Them as well as An Analytic Dictionary of English Etymology: An Introduction. His column on word origins, The Oxford Etymologist, appears here, each Wednesday. Send your etymology question to [email protected]; he’ll do his best to avoid responding with “origin unknown.”
Blog: Garden Painter Art (Login to Add to MyJacketFlap)
JacketFlap tags: Etsy, dancing, collage, mixed media, Kimberly Wlassak, Etsy, blog contest, dancing, Anthropomorphic animal art, Bull Terrier, Kimberly Wlassak, blog contest, Bull Terrier, Anthropomorphic animal art, contest, Add a tag
Good Morning:
I woke up this morning in the mood to have a contest!!
I will do it the simple, old fahioned way, as I always do. Simply leave a comment. When the contest is over, my daughter will pick a number out of the hat. If the number picked matches the comment number, you win. I know, I know, I could use a randomizer, but I'm computer illiterate and it's too complicated for me to wrap my brain around, so the old hat is good for me!!
When the contest is over, I will contact the winner.
The contest will run through Sunday March 2nd, 8:00 p.m. pacific time.
The winner will receive this:
A 4" x 6" print of "Dancing Fiona". This is one of my favorite "Anthropomorphic Animal" pieces to date. She is happy and light-hearted.
Okay, let the contest begin:
Kim
Garden Painter Art
Blog: Garden Painter Art (Login to Add to MyJacketFlap)
JacketFlap tags: Etsy, Anthropomorphic animal art, rabbits, Kimberly Wlassak, Garden Painter Art, Anthropomorphic animal art, ACEO, collage, mixed media, rabbits, Garden Painter Art, Kimberly Wlassak, Etsy, ACEO, Add a tag
Hello There:
I'm off to quite a busy day, but wanted to check in and say "Thank You" to all who commented on my previous entry. Should I change my business name or not is still the question being volleyed around my house. I've come up with several names that I really like, but am dreadful of all that would need to be done if I choose to make the change. Most people think that I should change and that my name is, indeed, misleading. The overall opinion is that, if I'm going to do it, I need to do it now and make a huge deal out of it. Holler it out to the world!! I will keep you posted and may be back to ask for more opinions!!
********************************************
I've been quite busy in my studio, and I'm off to a productive week already. Here's what I've just listed in My Etsy Shop:
LITTLE BERTIE IN THE GARDEN (4" x 6" collage on canvas)
GUARDIAN OF LAZY DAYS (collage ACEO 2-1/2" x 3-1/2" miniature art)
As always, if you don't have an Etsy account, but are interested in either of these pieces, or prints of these pieces, just email me. Up at the top, left hand corner of my blog, just click the "email me" button. Until I get my blog shop in order and get that pesky little paypal button attached, this is the only way to offer my pieces here.
Again, thanks ever so much for your comments and opinions on my newest adventure.
Until Next Time:
Kim
Garden Painter Art
Hi Kim! I love your contests! And, of course, your art!
You are amazing!
Kim- I love your blog- I'm going to post a link to you from my blog if you don't mind... i'm glad you have a photo on your page too- now i have a face with the avatar on etsy...
Hello~
I will go one further, I don't even know what a randomizer is!!!
I would love to have a chance at your art, count me in.
I am so glad to have met you.
Fun to see your photo too, and your work space looks so nice! Pretty lamp and all...
~Kathy
Love your art and enjoyed your blog. Homer and Junior are mighty cute. : )
Hi Kimmers
Thanks for luring me back to your blog - it is always a treat to visit!
joy,
katey-D
blueyeduckstudios.com
Ahh, that doggie-girl is so cute! Have you enjoyed this spring-time weather this week, or what!!? I bet the hills down there in Corona are so beautiful with green loveliness!!
(I hope I win!!!)
-saffron
This piece is wonderful. What an imagination. Lovely. I hope I win. LOL
very lovable indeed! im reminded of the wizard of oz, and also a sort of curious prairie pg wodehouse story!
it's the striped stockings that do it every time!
youve given me an idea for a contest now!
thanks for your recent encouragement, and all the best to you and yours:)
lou x
Hi I love your work too !
Thanks for the heads up on the ACEO forum. I love your work!
I'm probably far too late, but I do love Fiona! Looking forward to my package from you! It will be so lovely to have some of your live right here in my home. Just wonderful!
Marie
http://journals.aol.co.uk/mariealicejoan/MariesMuses/
Thanks for letting me know about the contest, Kim!
Of course I'm in...Fiona is one of my favorites!!!
xo
Di
LOVE THIS! Count me in!
Oh and now I'm singing that Lyle Lovett Fiona song...! What a great contest...can you make it any easier?! You're a doll!
I'm in:)
Wheeeee!
I really like Fiona as well. She's a great Ava for you too, because she's soooo cheerful!
You both make me smile!
-Gypsy
Did you know I'm a sucker for bulldogs, Bostons, frenchies and boxers? Is this meant for me or what? (Is it cheating on my boxer?) Good luck everyone....
Carol of CrowBiz
Kim,
Ya KNOW I love ya, and your art!
Your work is beautiful and very interesting.
Just reading about your contest. Hope not to late.
Oooh...comment comment COMMENT! Thanks for letting me know Kim...I love this one.
Give Junior a kissie on the ear for me...poor baby.
G'day Kim,
I am somewhat clueless about blogs ...and have been resisting doing one for that reason ...and where do you find the time ...LOL
That said ...it is a pleasure to read your blog ...and an even greater pleasure to view your artwork.
Regards,
Belinda :-)
PS. bellsakabin is my username on Etsy ...will just leave this as anonymous comment ...LOL or so the system will think!
Waiting to see the full curtsey or a twirl! This cute doggie in the pink dress is enjoying your garden it looks lovely. I've been reading the ACEO forum threads on etsy and waiting to sign up. I can't decide on a name. Good luck with your new name, whatever it may be. P.S. If you pick me, how will you know to contact me? I haven't a clue how these things work. Signed, Gloria B.
That piece cracks me up,too cute!
Your work is very unique! Good idea for a contest - hope I win. hehe..
Well of course I missed this but had to tell you I loooove it!