Title: Orange Genre: Slice of Life, Romance Publisher: Futabasha (JP), Crunchyroll (US) Story/Artist: Ichigo Takano Serialized in: Manga Action A review copy was provided by Crunchyroll I tend to find straight up romances boring these days. Kuniko Ikuhara (lately of Yuri Kuma Arashi) says it very well here, that [straight] romances have been done so ... Read more
Title: Millennium Snow Genre: Romance Publisher: Hakusensha (JP), Viz Manga (US) Story/Artist: Bisco Hatori Serialized in: Lala in 2001, Lala DX in 2013 Original Release Date: June 3, 2014 Review copy provided by Viz Media Bisco Hatori’s name may not be well-known in the west but her most famous work, Ouran High School Host Club, still finds new ... Read more
By: Jennie,
on 7/23/2014
I’m just going to review this entire (finished) series because I devoured them all together and it’s too hard for me to separate out each volume, especially as the review part (as opposed to the plot summary part) would basically be a copy/paste job from one volume to the next.
All the girls at Ninako’s school are in love with the quiet and elusive (and totally hot) Ren, but he’s turned them all down. Ninako doesn’t get it, until she ends up next to him on the train home one day. They end up together on the train a lot and become friends, until Ninako’s feelings turn to something more.
Ren rejects Ninanko romantically, because he already has a girlfriend, but the two stay friends as she tries to quash her feelings. Meanwhile, Ren’s former best friend has come to their school and falls for Ninanko. She likes Ando as a friend, but can’t return his love.
I loved Ninanko. She was a little hyper and a lot of fun. She's a bit taken aback when guys like her, but not because of a "but I'm so plain and boring" thing we usually see, but more that she's been too busy being awesome and having fun that she hasn't really noticed guys in that way before, so she's a bit bemused that guys have been noticing her. but she's a great friend and has a good outlook on life--it's not hard for the reader (and her friends) to see why guys like her.
I also like that she actually liked Ren in a way we don’t often see. So halfway through the series, Ren and his girlfriend break up (for reasons I won’t spoil). Everyone tells Ninanko to go for it because now’s her chance, but she doesn’t, because she see Ren’s hurting and he needs her as a friend right then. She really did understand Ren (because they were actual friends) and her love for him isn’t selfishly focused on her--it’s genuine love for him.
I also liked the depth that Sakisaka was able to give to some of the side characters (something you can do over 10 volumes). There are a few bonus stories at the end of volumes that often deal with side characters or something that happened before the series began.
In her many intro letters, Sakisaka says she wanted to capture that heady feeling of falling in love and that moment everything could change (she called the series strobe edge because she compares the feeling to being on the edge of a strobe light, which I really like.) Overall, I think she really succeeds. The series does drag a bit in the middle, which is something I may not have noticed if I hadn’t been binge-reading.
One thing I noticed with this series that I haven’t seen with others* is that we get a lot of letters from the author--both at the start of each volume, but also some random sidebars. I thought it was a fun touch and a behind-the-scenes look at her process and life.
Overall, a fun series that I enjoyed. (Also, shout-out to Drea, who when I asked her which of the Great Graphic Novels for Teens I should read first, pointed me in this direction. THANK YOU DREA!)
*Not that I’ve read a lot of other manga, especially shojo, this just might be a new thing for me
Book Provided by... my local library
Links to Amazon are an affiliate link. You can help support Biblio File by purchasing any item (not just the one linked to!) through these links. Read my full disclosure statement.
This goes way beyond being a review, and contains spoilers and too much about the story. Naho’s future self only warned that Kakeru would no longer be there. They don’t find out that it’s suicide until much later. In fact it’s believed that he died in an accident. None of this is confirmed before volume three. The same can be said for Kakeru’s feelings of guilt over his mother. Why would you basically describe the whole story(that’s been released so far) in a review? A review should give the basics (without spoiling the whole story for a new reader). I am so glad I had already read this story because all the moments that really touched me or shocked me, would have been ruined. There is magic in the reveal of new information when you read and you need to try harder not to tell the whole story or give spoilers.
I love this series and also hope it’ll get picked up for US release.
There are no hard and fast rules out there over how much is too much in a review and I don’t feel that I posted too much here (if you’ve read my other reviews here and on my home blog you might notice that I am slightly more cavalier about spoilers than some other reviewers out there). This is a shorter story and paced quickly so I felt that those details were part of the story’s set up and therefore it was appropriate to include those details in my review (especially since this story is much more concerned about why the characters acted or felt a certain way than the initial event).
On the suicide part in particular, this is a story set in Japan (with a notoriously high suicide rate) and Naho’s letter doesn’t tell her make sure Kakeru never gets into the accident but to become closer friends with him, I immediately read that as suicide and didn’t realize that some people wouldn’t have. I also specifically wanted to include the word “suicide” in the review in case someone was thinking of trying the story but is triggered by that or just feels uncomfortable, I’d much rather people realize that during a review instead of not seeing it in the review and then being distressed when reading the actual story.