
Guest Blogger: Chuck Sambuchino, editor and writer for Writer’s Digest, and host of the Guide To Literary Agents blog.
Here’s Chuck:
September 2015 sees the release of three of my new books, the 2016 Guide to Literary Agents, the 2016 Children’s Writer’s & Illustrator’s Market, and the anti-clown humor book When Clowns Attack: A Survival Guide.
To celebrate their release, we are bringing back a popular recurring contest: The “Worst Storyline Ever”—a competition that encourages terrible loglines. Winners get prizes.
The “Worst Storyline Ever” Contest 2.0
A logline is one sentence that explains what your story is about and shows the “hook” – the unique idea that makes people want to see more. You see loglines all the time on the back of DVD boxes. Here are some examples:
- “Three middle-aged men defeat their midlife crises by starting a college fraternity.” (Old School)
- “When a Roman general is betrayed and his family murdered by an evil emperor, he comes to Rome as a gladiator to seek revenge.” (Gladiator)
- “In a future where criminals are arrested before the crime occurs, a cop struggles on the lam to prove his innocence for a murder he has not yet committed.” (Minority Report)
But that’s all the examples I’m going to give you, because I’m not looking for good examples of a logline; I’m looking for bad examples. Terrible, stupid, “oh-my-gosh-that-idea-REEKS” examples.
Examples of Bad Loglines (Previous Winners/Finalists):
- “After an unidentified cow swallows an armed nuclear device in a botched Homeland Security raid, Agent Tom Anderson is thrust into an unlikely partnership with buxom organic farmer Daisy Jones to sift through three hundred cows and 10 barns full of manure as the clock runs down in a desperate quest to save Kansas City from a moo-clear disaster.”
- “A young woman discovers she is half unicorn after farting a rainbow at her bat mitzvah, and must go on a hijinx-filled voyage of self discovery to find her real father and fit as ‘one of the herd.’”
- “Leonard the narcoleptic snail sets out on his lifelong dream of running the Boston Marathon while humming ‘Macarena,’ and invites you to join the excitement in real time.”
Stick to the format, but have fun with the idea. Your logline must be one sentence, 60 words or fewer, and explain what the movie/book is about. It’s what you put in that one sentence that will win you this competition. The trick is to make your logline a terribly creative idea that’s pitched in a minimal, professional manner.
The contest will go until the end of the day, 11:59 p.m., PDT, Tuesday, October 20th, two weeks from today. Submissions received after that will not be considered.
Chuck will judge the contest, with some possible input from other WD and WD Books staffers.
To participate, simply leave a comment at the end of this post with your submission and your full name. Make sure we are able to reach you through your website or email. Comment by clicking: HERE.
You can submit up to two (2) bad loglines. You can include both in the same comment if you wish.
The contest is open to everyone of all ages, save those employees, officers and directors of GLA’s publisher, F+W: A Content and eCommerce Company (formerly F+W Media).
If you have any questions about the contest, e-mail Chuck directly at [email protected]. Do not leave them in the comments and do not e-mail Rachelle.
You do not have to share news of this contest to enter, but if you want to share this fun contest with others, here is an easy tweet:
Create the worst storyline you can – and win writing prizes. http://bit.ly/1KClppO via @chucksambuchino and @rachellegardner. Click to Tweet
There will be 3 winners.
Each winner receives:
- A critique by Chuck Sambuchino of either your one-page query letter or one-page synopsis .
- Your pick of a free book from any of his 3 recent releases:

2016 Guide to Literary Agents

2016 Children’s Writer’s & Illustrator’s Market

When Clowns Attack: A Survival Guide.
Chuck Sambuchino is an editor and instructor for Writer’s Digest Books. Find him on Twitter.
The post The Worst Storyline Ever Contest 2.0 appeared first on Rachelle Gardner.
I have a post up at PubSmart today. In case you haven’t heard, PubSmart is a new writers’ conference debuting this April in Charleston, SC, with the goal of bringing together self publishing, traditional, small press and hybrid. PubSmart is about introducing new models that lead to smart decisions about how to seize opportunities in today’s transformed book marketplace. I’m thrilled to be on the faculty of this terrific new conference! Keynote speakers are Hugh Howey and Jane Friedman, and the faculty includes heavy hitters from all walks of today’s expanded publishing world.Learn more on the PubSmartCon website.
Here’s a preview of my post:
What’s Your Book About?
Everyone attends conference for their own reasons—to learn, to network, to get a break from home. One of the primary advantages of a conference is the opportunity to talk to people, including fellow writers and others in the industry. Naturally, one thing you’ll want to talk about is your work, whether you’re in a formal pitch session or just hanging out having drinks. But talking about our work is sometimes challenging! So here are seven tips for discussing your book(s) effectively.
1. Be prepared. You never know when you’re going to come across someone who will ask, “So what’s your book about?” Mealtimes, hallway chatting, elevator rides, and designated pitch sessions. Prepare ahead of time so you’ll never be caught stammering, “Well, it’s um… it’s kind of an… uh…”
2. While preparing, remember that you’re going to be talking to someone. There are differences between verbal and written pitches. Your speaking voice is different from your writing voice. Make sure you don’t prepare something that sounds too “canned” i.e. written.
Click HERE to read the complete post.
→And don’t forget our special Facebook event today! Books for writers specially priced at 99 cents, plus all-day chats happening with the authors of these books. Click here for more info.
The post What’s Your Book About? appeared first on Rachelle Gardner.
I’ve posted on this topic numerous times, but since I’m going to a conference this week and will be hearing dozens of pitches, I wanted to go over (once again) some tips for pitching to agents and editors. We can probably all agree on the “don’ts” of pitching your project. Don’t pitch in the bathroom. Don’t pitch a novel that’s nowhere near ready. Don’t pitch with your mouth full. What are some positive tips we can all use?
I think the secret to making a great pitch is to start with a bit of context or background, then tell me about your book. It doesn’t have to be in-depth, considering your time restraints. But take a moment to introduce yourself and your project before pitching.
Too often, people sit down and nervously launch into some kind of story and I find myself dizzy with confusion. I sit there like a deer in the headlights and then I say something like, “Let’s back up. What’s your name? And is this fiction or nonfiction?”
To me, the best pitches include the following information without me having to ask for it:
My name is _____ and I wanted to meet with you because _____.
I’m writing ______ (what genre).
My publishing history includes _____(number of books, genres).
Today I want to tell you about my book called _____ .
Then, launch into your pitch. This should be 2 to 3 minutes long, MAX, allowing time for the agent or editor to ask questions. Have a 1-minute pitch prepared, too, in case of mealtime or elevator pitches.
Here are some guidelines:
→ Don’t try to tell the whole story. Start with the plot catalyst, the event that gets the story started.
→ Then give the set-up, i.e. what happens in the first 30 to 50 pages that drives the reader into the rest of the book. Include the pressing story question or the major story conflict.
→ Fill out your pitch with any of the following: plot elements, character information, setting, backstory, or theme. You want to include just enough information to really intrigue your listener. Note that your pitch doesn’t have to be all “plot.” If your story is more character driven, then fill out your pitch with interesting character details. If the setting is an important element, talk about that. If the backstory plays heavily, round out your pitch with that. Be intentional in how you structure your pitch.
→ Finish by giving an idea of the climactic scenes and the story resolution.
→ Try not to tell too much of the story in the pitch. The pitch is supposed to get somebody interested, not tell the whole story. Stick to the high points, but be sure to tell enough that you don’t leave your listener confused.
→ Include only a couple of characters.
→ Include one plot thread, or two if they’re closely intertwined. You can hint at the existence of other characters and plot lines.
Be prepared to answer questions that could include things like:
→ How does your story end?
→ What published author’s style would you compare your writing to?
→ Who are your favorite authors in your genre?
→ Is this a series? And if so, what are the subsequent books about?
→ Have you worked with a critique group or a professional editor?
→ Have you pitched this to publishers in the past? If so, what was the response?
Important: Know all the key points of your pitch, but don’t memorize your pitch verbatim. You want to be ready to speak it aloud and sound natural, whether during a planned meeting, a meal, in an elevator or a random encounter. Having your pitches prepared ahead of time (and adjusting them as necessary if you learn new things in workshops) will raise your confidence level.
And most important: To help raise your confidence and lower the nervousness, realize that agents and editors are regular people just like you. We clean our toilets, we change our kids’ poopy diapers, we stress over what to wear and whether we’re having a bad hair day. Also, we REALLY like chocolate. How much more normal could we be?
Have you had any mortifying experiences pitching at conferences? Any great experiences? If you haven’t pitched verbally before, what’s your biggest fear?
Comment below or by clicking: HERE.
TWEETABLES
Pitching: Start with context or background, THEN tell me about your book. Click to Tweet.
Too often, author pitches leave me feeling like a deer in the headlights. Click to Tweet.
The pitch is supposed to get somebody interested, NOT tell the whole story. Click to Tweet.
The post Pitching Your Projects appeared first on Rachelle Gardner.
Upstart Crow Literary agent Chris Richman demonstrates how to boil a novel down to twenty-five scintillating words in an excellent post on the Upstart Crow blog. Check it out!
One thing I've noticed lately in fiction pitches - verbal pitches or queries - is that some writers want to tell all about the theme or the emotional journey of the story, but they have a hard time conveying the actual story.
Every novel has a theme. There's a character arc, in which a character grows and/or changes over the course of the story. There's an emotional progression. But that is NOT the story. That is what is illustrated by the story.
What's a story? It's a plot. It's scenes with action and dialogue. It's people going places and doing things and talking to other people. It's characters taking action to make something happen, to change their situation, to solve a problem, to avoid danger.
Over the weekend as I listened to writers' pitches, I often heard something like (this is hypothetical):
A woman is distraught and angry about her teenage daughter's drug use, but finally comes around to be able to forgive her and help her.
To this, I might ask, "Good, so what's the story?"
Well, the mother has a hard time with this because of her own past drug use, and she vowed her own children would never use drugs, and she has to learn that we're all human and that her daughter needs her help.
Me: "Okay, so how does all of this happen? What's the story?"
Um, the mother finally forgives her daughter, and gets her into rehab.
Grrr. Can you see that this is not a novel? At this point, I've been given a premise and a resolution, but I still have no idea what happens between page 1 and page 400.
Sometimes, this is not about the pitch - it's a problem with the book. Some of you are writing entire 100,000 word novels with no actual real-world story, but instead you've chronicled in devastating detail a character's emotional journey.
Take note: the emotional journey is illustrated and reflected in the real-life action of the story. Again: people going places, doing things, interacting with other people, solving problems, and always working towards a goal.
In the words of my friend the Query Shark (agent Janet Reid), your pitch needs to show:
1. Who is the protagonist?
2. What choice does s/he face?
3. What are the consequences of the choice?
Just to be safe, take a step back from your query. Make sure your book has a protagonist with a choice to face (a conflict), obstacles to overcome, a desired outcome, and consequences (the stakes) if the goal is not reached.
And when it comes time to pitch your novel, talk about the actual real-world story, bringing in your protagonist's emotional journey (or the theme of the book) at the end of your pitch.
Have you been pitching themes and emotional journeys instead of stories?
P.S. The phrase emotional journey could also be replaced with spiritual or psychological journey.
.
Thank you so much Rachelle, for this clear direction. It's so easy to focus on the emotional journey and not the actual one. I'm going to remember this post in my future writing and pitching!
Good morning, Rachelle,
I am often amazed how the words we write speak uniquely to each person who reads them. The comments to your post show the proverbial "lightbulb" going on over people's heads in so many different ways.
I am no exception to that rule. I am working on a children's book with a story that, according to one professional, is a "solid start with a good voice." This person also told me the manuscript lacked that "something" that would cause the reader to care what happens to the main character. Your post brought to my attention that the "something" is a lack of the emotional quality you often get instead of the story line.
Thank you!
Be blessed,
Lynnda
Thank you for this reminder! It's easy to get caught up in "the journey" and forget about "the story"!
I think I started out doing this long ago... but realized the difference quickly. I think sometimes the problem is that people call their stories "Character-driven" and not "plot-driven" and explain their lack of story this way.
But just because a book is more heavy on character than plot doesn't mean there can be NO plot. Same the other way around. I think mine is more "plot" driven but that doesn't mean I can ignore or not develop my characters.
Could it be that this is because we spend so little time talking about everything but what happens in a story? We talk about things like First Person or Third Person, adjectives and adverbs, Protagonists and Antagonists, hooks and cliffhangers, punctuation and editing—you name it, we talk about it, but we don’t see that much talk about what actually happens in a novel. With so much emphasis on other things, it shouldn’t be surprising that people don’t talk much about what happens when they discuss their stories.
You'd like my book, if it were only written. Thank you for the post!
As always, perfectly stated, Rachelle. I'll be starring this for later. Thanks.
I am reminded of something Stephen King said in his On Writing book:
"… starting with the questions and thematic concerns is a recipe for bad fiction. Good fiction always begins with story and progresses to theme; it almost never begins with theme and progresses to story."
So THAT'S why all my queries sank without trace...
Seriously - a number of people read the book and loved it, and the queries went nowhere. Now I know.
Thank you ever so much, Rachelle. I think you may just have made the difference between my being a writer, and being an also-ran.
I think a lot of our problems with queries and pitches stem from at least 12 (for some, more) years of book reports. We were taught to pitch a book something like this:
"I read this great book.... it made me feel.... I'm not going to ruin the book by telling you what happened... I think you should read it."
People need to know it's ok to "ruin it" for the agent/publisher. These aren't book reports.
I have nominated you for the Kreative Blogger Award:) www.martzbookz.blogspot.com
Another great post.Always enjoy reading what u have to say.
Hmmm, possibly have. Thanks so much for this post! It's definitely something I needed to read.
Right on. I'd like to say I didn't pitch themes, but I'm sure it crept into my appointments a little but hopefully not completely.
Great post. Hope you're recovering from your ACFW weekend. I think I've just about recovered. It's taken a couple days though. :-)
Have a great day, everyone.
Thanks Rachelle for the timeless insight to a would be author's success.
You are proving to be an invaluable help to so many people. I will be making a note to remember this in my writing. I consider myself character-driven rather than plot, but I want the story God gave to shine forth.
Blessings to you...
Good advice!
Does every conflict involve making a choice? What if the story involves a outside antagonist causing problems or if the story involves the protagonist learning new things?
Very timely post for me. I'm struggling with a memoir that is reading more like a series of events (an emotional journey) but not an actual story. Thanks for the post - this helped me a lot today!
I think this is tough for us because so many published books are pitched from a character perspective. The story of four reunited friends. The story of a man who triumphs against the odds.
Take, for example, the book I'm reading right now, Justine Larbalestier's LIAR (which many people know about because of the kerfuffle over the book's cover image). What do we know about the book? The main character is black with short hair (hence the brouhaha when the cover originally showed a white girl with long hair). The main character is a compulsive liar. BUT WHAT HAPPENS? I bought the book without having any idea.
The book's cover says that Micah is a compulsive liar whose dishonesty begins to catch up with her after her boyfriend's brutal death. THAT'S IT. And, to my mind this is not terribly different from saying that a book is about a former drug user who must learn forgiveness after her own daughter begins using drugs. In both cases, we're shown one character and one pivotal moment, and no other plot information.
Maybe this is the difference between a teaser and a pitch? But I can definitely see why people think it IS a pitch to just talk about the characters.
I have almost the opposite problem. I summarized the main points of the entire story in two paragraphs ( which was not easy) and realized that I might be giving to much information?
I just don't know what the right thing to do is.
I totally get what you're saying about the emotional journey problem. I'm still confused though. Don't agents always say they want to see a hook? Where's the hook if you tell the beginning middle and end of your story in three sentences? I think maybe that's why writers subconsciously leave their pitches open ended. They don't realize they sound cliche, they want them to entice you to read their book, not give you the whole story so you can yawn and move on.
So you're saying is the story is more important than the hook?
In other words... the writers pitch the theme, and the problem is that they might come off pitching a book that sounds like a zillion other books that the agent has seen.
Maybe the point is they have to take what they have and figure out what makes THEIR story different and find a way to emphasize that?
Guilty...this has been the most difficult part for me. But it's also made me look deeper into my story, plot and character arch. Thanks! May God's wisdom and discernment shine through the block!
Awesome distinction, thanks!
Guilty as charged. Thanks for asking the tough questions and pushing us to examine the core of our stories.
I find it hard to do this after the story is written because all of the layers are fresh in my mind. The next book I start WILL have the story crystal clear before I put a word on the page, and therefore save me headaches at the end when trying to pitch/query.
Thanks again for your honesty and the willingness to help us as we grow in our craft.
I'm new to your blog, Rachelle, and was very happy to read your explanation about the difference between the protagonist's emotional journey (or internal story) and his or her external story (the actual, real-world story). I think you're right that often the problem with a pitch is not the pitch at all, but rather a problem with the story. Thanks very much for this post.:)
Terrific summary. On the other hand, while I was pitching I was actually afraid that I might be delving too delving too deeply into the story and not mentioning enough of the spiritual changes occurring in my protagonist. After all, it IS a Christian novel. But two people asked for samples chapters, so I guess I did something right... ;)