As many of you know by now, I'm an acquisitions and developmental editor for Harlequin's e-publishing imprint Carina Press. My job is AWESOME. I get to read, read, readity read manuscripts. When I find books I love, I shamelessly beg the acquisition team to let me have 'em, and then I get to work with awesome authors and help make their books as strong and compelling as they can be.
But sometimes...sometimes, this job drives me to the drink. I'm not just talking about a gentle glass of riesling or chardonnay, either. No, sometimes I need a BIG boozy drink, like what this foxy lady is having:

So, without further ado, I present...the top 10 ways to drive an editor to drinking:
1--Send a manuscript that's insaaaaaaanely long. I'm talking 250,000-word tomes. Those make me cry. They make baby Jesus cry. They make Bobby McFarrin cry, and that dude is always happy. Cut that number in half at the VERY least (and even that's genre-specific, like epic fantasy and historicals...other genres are likely going to be a lower word count) and then, let's talk.
2--Email constantly about the status of your manuscript. My day flies by much quicker than I could ever have dreamed. I typically read new submissions on evenings and weekends because my business day is packed with editing my current authors, among other tasks. So it can take a while to get to new submissions. Please, don't fret. I promise, it's in the pile.
3--Send a manuscript that's a rough draft or hasn't been proofread. Editors know errors are going to happen. I'm totally cool with that, and I anticipate it--I just want a good story, and I'm happy to work with authors on the rest. But if your manuscript is littered with insanely obvious errors (e.g., there's a HUGE difference in spraying your cologne and spraying your colon)...well, it makes me drink. And my eyes bleed.
4--Tell everyone on FB/Twitter/your blog/in the newspaper that the editor is a fatty fat jerk for rejecting you. I can't emphasize enough that it isn't personal. Not every story works for every person. Just keep submitting to other editors. YOU ONLY NEED ONE EDITOR to love it and acquire it.
5--Nitpick to death about house style. Every publishing house has various particulars that are non-negotiable style-wise. Editors abide by these when we're editing your manuscript. Rejecting those edits just makes the job more difficult. And the liver more springy due to heavy drinking.
6--Be a total diva. My authors know I'm a hands-on, thorough editor. I comment a LOT as I read and edit because I'm engaged in the story. When I present an edited manuscript, there's lots of stuff in there that are suggestions and don't NEED to be followed. If you don't want to do those, no skin off my nose. However, there's other stuff I recommend edits for because of more serious content issues. Battling over edits makes me dislike working with you. I'd MUCH rather you take time to consider the edits, and if you don't want to make particular changes, let's talk. We can find a compromise that makes everyone happy.
7--When you get an offer from another publisher, only give, like, 2 minutes to read/decide upon your manuscript. Look, the buck doesn't stop here. Even if for some reason I'm able to read through your manuscript overnight (because typically, I have to push aside all my other work to do so), it still has to go to an acquisitions meeting. And those aren't daily--at least, not in my experience. Harlequin's meetings are usually weekly. I can't move mountains or make it go faster. Please, be patient.
8--In your query letter, say you're the next big thing in X genre. You telling me that your writing is better than
6 Comments on Top Ten Ways to Drive an Editor to Drinking, last added: 9/1/2011
Display Comments
Add a Comment
Great suggestions and rules to follow. We all get anxious, especially new authors. Better to not drive the editor to drink, lol. No one wants a springy liver...
Dottie :)
Now, I wouldn't say I would slavishly roll over and drool if an Editor liked my manuscript, but I'd be telling a lie!!!
Seriously, the relationship between editor and Author has to be one of respect and trust. The Author has to trust that the Editor knows what they are doing and the Editor has to trust that the Author will respect the guidelines that have been laid out.
Thank you for a wonderful post!
Before anyone even knew I existed, I haunted writing forums with some frequency. I had heard these horror stories, but I honestly thought they were archetypical. You know, Distraught Misunderstood Artiste and Heartless, Cruel, Callous, Uncaring (you get the point) Editor.
I've never met the HCCU Editor; my editor only bites when confronted with abject stupidity. (Which, yeah, I've committed, much to my chagrin.)
But DMAs seem to be rampant at every level of writing experience. "I don't need to edit my work." "I think people should just run out and buy my book because I wrote it and that should be enough." "What do you mean, I have to rewrite this whole damn section because I used three POVs and there's only one character in it?"
This should be required reading for authors thinking about submitting work. Better still, everyone thinking about trying to break into publishing should have these rules tattooed in a place that ensures they'll remember them!
This is a hilarious list. And hopefully I've never driven you to drink. ;)
Thanks for the advice...and I love that pic! There are days I want one that size. :)
So funny, and I'm so glad that I wasn't drinking something when I read the "fatty fat jerk" line! It would have come out my nose!