This is the hardest FoodFic post I’ve had to write so far; in fact, I actually finished the book almost a month ago and am just getting my thoughts together now. My procrastination isn’t a result of my not liking the story; on the contrary – once I got to a certain point, I couldn’t put it down.
No, the trouble is that something major happens very early on (chapter 2, to be exact) that makes almost anything I might say here a spoiler, which is something I try to avoid at all costs. (Apparently the cost here will my sounding completely cryptic and odd. :) So I’ll just say what I can in the best way I’m able and know that when you read the book yourselves, you’ll understand.
In this book, the “dirty little secret” is that Lucy’s mom’s a hoarder. Now, I’ve seen enough episodes of Buried Alive to know what sort of food I should expect in this story – old, moldy, rotten, forgotten…you get the idea. And it’s all here: petrified pizza boxes and takeout containers full of food that had sat long enough to congeal into one black, furry, mess, a no-longer-used sink full of a dark brown mass that…looked like chocolate pudding, and a plastic grocery bag full of some gelatinous brown goo that was probably produce at one point. It’s enough to make you throw up, really – even if you’re expecting it – and more horrifying still because it’s so accurate.
What I hadn’t pre-known, however, was the shame felt by the children of hoarders; they’re embarrassed and scared that other people might find out their family secret, as well as terrified of being thought of as dirty or gross by their peers. I found this both eye-opening and eye-wetting – another way kids suffer internally andexternally because of their parents’ failings.
Omololu certainly gave me some food for thought with this one, and I particularly loved that she included a website (
childrenofhoarders.com) at the end of the narrative for the real-life Lucys out there.
This YA novel takes place over a mere 24 hours, but what a 24 hours it is. It's the day when everything changes for Lucy, a girl whose mother is a compulsive hoarder. For years, that fact has shaped her life. She's worried about the smells of her family's kitchen following her out of the house, worried about friends who invite her to sleep over when she can never reciprocate, and worried that someone would learn her family's dirty little secret. In the early pages of this novel, a tragic turn fo...more
Book by book, I'm reading and recommending my way through the fantastic ARCs I picked up at NCTE. I had been looking forward to C.J. Omololu's YA novel DIRTY LITTLE SECRETS for two reasons. First, I know Cynthia online and had read about her book sale. And second, my Walker editor Mary Kate is also the editor of this book, and I know how excited she is about it. I read DIRTY LITTLE SECRETS in a single sitting -- on the plane home from NCTE, actually -- and it kept me turning pages long after I should have been sleeping.
It's a great, compelling read. This YA novel takes place over a mere 24 hours, but what a 24 hours it is. It's the day when everything changes for Lucy, a girl whose mother is a compulsive hoarder. For years, that fact has shaped her life. She's worried about the smells of her family's kitchen following her out of the house, worried about friends who invite her to sleep over when she can never reciprocate, and worried that someone will learn her family's dirty little secret. In the very early pages of this novel, a tragic turn forces Lucy to make a decision about how to handle her mother's hoarding...and her own future.
Powerful and page-turning, this book would be a great choice for literature circles in grades 7 and up, particularly because it has an ending that will get readers talking in a big way. I still can't stop thinking about it. Highly recommended.
YAY! I have never heard of this but hoarders? this is definitely interesting. LOVE your review, Shelley
LOVED reading Sound, by the way
Your reader,
Soma
http://insomnia-of-books.blogspot.com/
Followed the link from BlogHer, so..."Hi!" I stopped watching Hoarders awhile ago, but what an impact it made on me. My heart hurt for these people, and their families, every time I watched the show. The book sounds interesting, I'll have to check it out!
@Soma - Thank you, thank you! :)
@Alien - Yes, this is like looking at the show from a different angle; the focus is on the teen child of the hoarder rather than the hoarder herself. And of course this is a fictional work, but the actual hoarding part and the emotional toll it takes are very realistically portrayed. Not a hard read, but a deep one for YA.