Sitting down with an agent from CAA yesterday the conversation turned, as all conversations must, to Olivia. The Falconer pig, that is. There was some speculation as to why Olivia is as popular as she is. Her personality is certainly in the vein of Eloise, of course, albeit with better influences in her life. But lots of characters are born every year with Eloise-like personalities. What is it about Olivia that contributes to her staying power? Well, might part of it have to do with the fact that she’s a pig?
Here’s my thinking. Folks like animal icons. They like to mention a species and have a single character pop into your head. Now in the field of children’s literature when I say “pig” the first name most people think of is “Wilbur”. So what if I say “girl pig”? Well, unless Miss Piggy is your de facto feminine swine, Olivia is it. Sure, Toot and Puddle had their day and Piggie from the Elephant and Piggie books will always occupy a place in my heart but for most folks Olivia has managed to become your layman’s go-to lady pork (Note to Self: Find a better description than “lady pork”).
It got me to thinking. What are the other iconic animals out there? If we’re playing the association game where I call out an animal and you say the first children’s literary character to come to mind, would your answers be the same as mine? Let’s find out! Here’s my take:
Cat: Bad Kitty by Nick Bruel. That’s a surprise! Harry Kitten from A Cricket in Times Square or Jenny and the Cat Club probably should have been the first to come to mind but I guess it’s a sign of the times that Bruel wins this round.
Dog: Harry the Dirty Dog by Gene Zion. Hmmm. Went kind of classic with this one.
Cow: Click, Clack, Moo: Cows That Type by Doreen Cronin. Not really a single iconic cow here. Single cows are a lot harder to think up than you’d think too. Clearly there’s a gap in the marketplace here.
Bull: The Story of Ferdinand by Monroe Leaf. No bones about it.
Bear: Winnie-the-Pooh by A.A. Milne. No brainer (bear of very little brainer?) there.
Elephant: The Story of Babar by Jean de Brunhoff. Because of the spats, I suppose. I’m a sucker for spats. We would have also have accepted Horton.
Monkey: Monkey With a Toolbelt by Chris Monroe. Sorry, Curious George. Maybe if you had a cool name like Chico Bon Bon I would have thought of you first.
Gorilla: Goodnight, Gorilla by Peggy Rathmann. Anthony Browne, you were my second choice. Honest.
Duck: Make Way for Ducklings by Robert McCloskey. If, however, you just wanted a character named “Duck” then either Doreen Cronin’s hero from Duck for President (though I already nominated her cows so how f
Not Lobel’s Toad? Blah, said Toad.
Horse?
Chicken?
For cat, I’m going to have to go with Scarry’s Huckle, if for no other reason than shortly after my son could speak, he began identifying himself as Huckle.
Cat is clearly the Cat in the Hat. For Ducks I’d go with Gossie and Gertie. Chicken is obviously Minerva Louise.
Since Curious George is technically not a monkey, you don’t have to apologize to him!
While I easily give you Click, Clack, Moo for cows in general, if you’re looking for a specific individual Cow, I’d like to nominate the cow from Jan Thomas’s books.
I can live with Toad from Wind in the Willows, but only if you add Frog from Lobel’s Frog and Toad books.
Have to agree that much of Olivia’s success is her species!
Lyle would be in there for the crocs!
For Dinosaur, I immediately picture the little red fellow from Bob Shea’s books (what do you mean, “dinosaur” isn’t really a species?)
I have to disagree on Hippos – it’s got to be Sandra Boynton’s creation in BUT NOT THE HIPPOPOTAMUS.
Spider: Charlotte
Fish: Swimmy
Dog: Dominic.
Mouse: all Lobel’s mice, especially the seven little ones in bed.
Duck: Jemina Puddle-Duck.
Elephant: yes, Babar.
Bear: Buzzati’s invaders of Sicily.
Toad: of course Lobel’s.
Frog: well…
Rabbit: Peter.
Pig: Bumble-Ardy.
Cow: the one who jumped over the moon.
Hippopotamus: George, with Martha close second. Or maybe Martha first.
Monkey: Zephir.
Cat: any one of those millions.
Pigeon: Pinocchio’s.
Whale: Boris, the friend of Amos’.
Ahem, Chicken???
P.S. still laughing over “lady pork.”