Every year, about this time, we start to see lots of posts and comments online about the upcoming ALA awards. It’s one of my favorite seasons for this very reason. I love following the blogs, engaging in discussions about the frontrunners, learning from what other people have to say. I like to read prediction posts, and to hear about the mock Caldecott clubs around the country. I like to discover new books.
But every year I’m a little dismayed by how overwhelmingly women illustrators seem to get overlooked in early Caldecott conversations.
To be clear– I LOVE the books that win. I love the men who (mostly) make the books that win. Many of these men are my friends, and I believe that they are talented and creative and brilliant and worthy of awards. ABSOLUTELY. Last year, despite all my ranting about gender-bias, my own top pick for the medal was illustrated by a man.
BUT.
I also believe women are worthy. Yet, somehow, when we start to generate buzz within our own little community, we PREDICT success for men. Which creates a certain sense of inevitability.
How does it begin? I don’t know. Maybe there are more marketing dollars for dudes. Maybe men are more inclined to illustrate. Maybe we, the women who buy most of the books, simply adore dudes. Maybe men are more inclined to make “Caldecott-style” illustrations. Or maybe MEN ARE SIMPLY BETTER AT ART THAN WOMEN AND I AM WRONG ABOUT EVERYTHING I HAVE EVER SAID ON THE MATTER.
In any case, it happens. Statistically.
So…
Last year I made this list of AMAZING PICTURE BOOKS CREATED BY WOMEN. It was great fun, and I heard from a lot of folks that they were introduced to books they hadn’t seen before. I know some folks even sold a few books via the list.
So I invite you to help me make a 2014 edition, by leaving a comment below, with your very favorite woman-illustrated picture book of the year. Please don’t self-nominate or self-promote in this space. If you’ve truly created something awesome, no doubt someone else will mention it for you! Just link to your favorite book in a comment, and I’ll pull an image of the cover, and add it below.
And if you’re a list-maker yourself, a blogger or journalist or librarian who runs a mock Caldecott… and you find yourself with a dude-heavy list, consider adding a few women to the mix. If women-illustrated titles don’t jump immediately to mind, you might want to ask yourself why that is…
I’ll kick things off myself, with a few favorites of my own:
A BOY AND A JAGUAR, by Alan Rabinowitz, illustrations by Catia Chien
LIFE, LIBERTY, and the PURSUIT of EVERYTHING, by Maira Kalman
TELEPHONE, by Mac Barnett, illustrations by Jen Corace
NANA IN THE CITY, by Lauren Castillo
FIREFLY JULY, by Paul B. Janeczko, illustrations by Melissa Sweet
EXTRAORDINARY JANE, by Hannah E Harrison
AVIARY WONDERS, INC, by Kate Samworth
FLIGHT SCHOOL, by Lita Judge
VIVA FRIDAY, by Yuyi MOrales
FLASHLIGHT, by Lizi Boyd
A PIECE OF CAKE, by LeUyen Pham
A Piece of Cake by LeUyen Pham!
I realize this might officially come out today, but thought I’d include The Right Word, Melissa Sweet. http://www.eerdmans.com/Products/5385/the-right-word.aspx Also Maple (Lori Nichols). I never know if graphic novels count or not, but it is my dream for El Deafo (Cece Bell) to win big.
Oh, and Louise Loves Art!
And the Numberlys…
I don’t see why Cece couldn’t win it! How awesome would that be?
I’m pulling over a bunch of FB suggestions too, btw, these aren’t all mine…
If Selznick could win for HUGO CABRET, I don’t see why El Deafo would somehow be out of the running. Picture books are wild and diverse and MIGHTY.
I love Louise Loves Art! But man, it is TIME for Melissa Sweet to get a Caldecott. I am TEAM MELISSA SWEET this year. We’ll see. I think Beekle is the monster to beat, and Beekle is a very strong contender.
This may be a *teensy* bit self-promotion, as the illustrator is my boss’s client, but I had no hand in it and would think it was a gorgeous book anyway:
WHERE’S MOMMY? by Beverly Donofrio and illustrated by Barbara McClintock http://www.randomhouse.com/book/41968/wheres-mommy-by-beverly-donofrio
I think we’ll allow it.