How to use this Page

#75 The Saturdays by Elizabeth Enright (1941)
27 points

This book and its sequels are some of my favorite books of all time. The characters are well defined and the stories feel fresh and immediate. – Laurie Zaepfel

#51 on the last poll and #75 today.  By now you’ve probably noticed that most of the books seem to have fallen on this poll.  What’s supplanted them in the hearts and minds of readers?  Oh.  You will see.

The plot according to American Writers for Children, 1900-1960 reads, “In The Saturdays, Randy, Rush, their older sister Mona, and their younger brother Oliver decide to pool their allowances so that each Saturday during the winter one of them can afford to do something special in New York City; the book follows their escapades, some of which are more successful than others: Mona, to the distress of her parents, spends her share of the money at the beauty parlor; Oliver gets lost at the circus; Rush goes to an opera; and Randy goes to an art museum and meets Mrs. Oliphant, who becomes a fairy godmother of sorts to the children.”

According to American Short-Story Writers Since World War II: Fifth Series, “Thimble Summer remained Enright’s most popular children’s book until 1941, when the first of the Melendy family stories, The Saturdays, was published.”  I would dare say that it remains her best known work to this day (Newbery winner aside).  For the interested, there are three other books in the Melendy series.  The Four-Story Mistake (1942), Then There Were Five (1944), and Spiderweb For Two (1951).

And the dialogue really is good in this book.  I mean really really good.  I don’t usually quote large swaths from the books on these lists, but this just had to be noted:

“And for heaven’s sake don’t play Bach,” ordered Randy. “It’s so jumpy for today.”
Rush slung his leg over the piano stool and sat down. With both hands he began to play slow deep chords that fitted together into a wonderful dark mysterious music.
“Yes, that’s better for today,” approved Randy. “What is it, anyway?”
“Bach,” said Rush without turning his head. “Just shows how much you know about music.”
“Not an awful lot,” admitted Randy humbly.
“Not any,” said Rush.
He played another bar.
“Not many people your age do, though,” he added kindly.

Of her characters, Ms. Enright herself would say, “”Perhaps they are always a little more reasonable and ingenious than live children are apt to be. . . Their conversations are to the point; in the tales about them, as in tales about adults, they cannot be allowed all the ragtag slack of daily life, all the humdrum comings and goings and yawnings and coughings and desultory chatter.”

J.D. Stahl in the April 1998 edition of Hollins Critic points out, though, that “Unlike the majority of writers for children during the era of World War II, she did not exclude awareness of the war from her children’s fiction. In The Saturdays, Rush and Randy, two of the memorable Melendy children, stare at the Rorschach-like outlines of a leak on the ceiling of their New York City house. Rush sees a shape like a big fat fish, or a heart, ‘and a thing like a baseball mitt, and a kind of lop-sided Greyhound bus.’ But Randy sees something else: ‘You’ve missed Adolf Hitler,’ she says. ‘See up there? That long fady line is his nose, and those two little chips are his eyes, and that dark place where you threw the plasticine is his mustache

#80 The Four-Story Mistake by Elizabeth Enright (1942)
25 points

Seems fairly funny that not only would The Saturdays make it onto this list but its sequel to boot!

The plot from Wikipedia reads, “During the height of World War II, the Melendy family find themselves moving out of New York City and into the countryside. Randy, the third child of the Melendy family, feels saddened and sombered by the move. But the house they move into turns out to be an adventure unto itself. The Four-Story Mistake is an odd-looking house with a rich architectural history, surrounded by bucolic countryside. The four Melendy children soon become absorbed in the adventures of the country, adjusting themselves with all their accustomed resourcefulness and discovering the many hidden attractions that the house has to offer. Oliver discovers buried history, Rush is stranded in a tree during a storm, Randy finds a diamond in the most unlikely of places, and Mona learns what it truly means to be an actress. And none of them could have ever guessed at the secret hidden in their very own play space, the office—a secret that had been shut away for over 60 years.”

There is a truly beautiful article at NPR by author Mairsa de los Santos called Taking Comfort in a ‘Four-Story Escape’ that puts this book into the larger context of children’s literature and what books mean to kids.  At one point she says, “Enright, the author of The Four Story Mistake, is a writer who gives you an an entire, flesh-and-blood person in two sentences. Mona, Rush, Randy, and Oliver are utterly alive, and are complicated, but they are uncomplicatedly happy. They stage elaborate plays, ice skate at night, and collect scrap metal. Always together, always living with an abundant, freewheeling joy. They have reasons to worry — motherlessness, World War II — but they don’t. When I was with them, I didn’t either.”

There’s also a top notch review of the book at Jen Robinson’s Book Page.  Jen really knows how to get inside the heads of the child characters.  Plus I like this quote she located:

” ‘That suitcase looks as if it were laughing out loud,’ Randy said.
‘Oh, stop being whimsical,’ snapped Rush.”

• Check out the original interior art on the book’s website (isn’t it nice that Macmillan cared enough to give it all these bells and whistles?).

Publishers Weekly said of the book, “The Melendys are the quintessential storybook family…[their] ardent approach to living is eternally relevant.”

0 Comments on Top 100 Children’s Novels: #80: The Four-Story Mistake by Elizabeth Enright as of 1/1/1900