new posts in all blogs
Viewing: Blog Posts Tagged with: 2015 Caldecott contender, Most Recent at Top [Help]
Results 1 - 7 of 7
How to use this Page
You are viewing the most recent posts tagged with the words: 2015 Caldecott contender in the JacketFlap blog reader. What is a tag? Think of a tag as a keyword or category label. Tags can both help you find posts on JacketFlap.com as well as provide an easy way for you to "remember" and classify posts for later recall. Try adding a tag yourself by clicking "Add a tag" below a post's header. Scroll down through the list of Recent Posts in the left column and click on a post title that sounds interesting. You can view all posts from a specific blog by clicking the Blog name in the right column, or you can click a 'More Posts from this Blog' link in any individual post.
And thus, we end. Though, with such a late ALA Media Awards announcement this year (Monday, February 2nd!) my predictions are coming a bit early in the game. Still, it’s not as though I’ll be seeing much that’s new between now and 2/2. I have watched with great interest the discussions on Heavy Medal and Calling Caldecott. I’ve discussed and debated the contenders with folks of all sorts. I’m eyeing the Mock Caldecotts and Mock Newberys with great fervor as they post their results (and I’m tallying them for my next Pre-Game / Post-Game Show). I’ve gauged the wind. Asked the Magic 8 ball. Basically I’ve done everything in my power to not be to embarrassed when my predictions turn out to be woefully inaccurate. And they will be. Particularly in the Caldecott department. Still, I press on!
I should mention that that throughout the year I mention the books that I think we should all be discussing. This post is a little different. It’s the books I think will actually win. Not the ones I want to win necessarily but the books that I think have the best chance. Here then are my thoughts, and may God have mercy on my soul:
Newbery Award
Winner: Brown Girl Dreaming by Jacqueline Woodson
What was it I wrote in my Fall Prediction Edition? Ah yes. “This is Woodson’s year and we’re just living in it.” Even without the National Book Award brouhaha and the fact that this book is being purchased by everyone from POTUS on down, Jackie would win in this category. Why the certainty? Well, I’m a big fan of thematic years. I like to take the temperature of the times and work from there. Look back at 2014 and what will we remember? #WeNeedDiverseBooks for one. The Newbery committee canNOT take such things into account, but it’s in the air. They breathe it just like we do and it’s going to affect the decision unconsciously. It doesn’t hurt matters that this is THE book of the year on top of everything else. Magnificently written by an author who has deserved the gold for years, I haven’t been this certain of a book’s chances since The Lion and the Mouse (and, before that, When You Reach Me).
Honors: West of the Moon by Margi Preus
Not a certainty but what is? It’s just enormously difficult not to appreciate what Preus is doing in this book. Mind you, my librarians were not entirely taken with it. Some disliked the heroine too much. Others found it dense. And perhaps it is a “librarian book” intended for gatekeepers more than kids, but I cannot look at the title and not see the word “distinguished” floating above it like a Goodyear Blimp.
Honors: Boys of Blur by N.D. Wilson
Also not a sure thing but I think we’d do well to remember it. Wilson’s one of those guys who drifts just under the radar until BLAMMO! Amazing book. Read the first page of this book all by itself. Right there, he’s got you. I can’t help but keep thinking about it. I try to bring up other potential winners, but again and again I turn to this one. Zombie Beowulf. It’s about time.
Honors: The 14th Goldfish by Jennifer L. Holm
Hm. Tricksy. Jenni has this magnificent ability to accrue Honor after Honor after Honor. I’m not seeing gold written all over this book (that’s a lie . . . the gold would complement the blue of the cover so well and fit on the left side of the neck of the beaker, don’t you think?) but it’s a contender. Committees adore her writing, and why not? She’s one of the best. Newbery Honor best? I’m going to say yes.
Wild Card: The Family Romanov by Candace Fleming
YA but not too YA. Certainly pushes the old 0-14 age range, but still a beaut. With Brown Girl Dreaming as well, we might end up with a very strong nonfiction Newbery year (and won’t Common Core be pleased with that?). Mind you, if I hesitate to predict this as an Honor it has more to do with the fact that my heart was broken when Candy didn’t receive any award love for her brilliant Amelia Lost biography. Shouldawonshouldawonshouldawonshouldawon . . .
Wild Card: The Night Gardener by Jonathan Auxier
Doll Bones Honored so why not another creepy little middle grade book? Auxier pulls out all the stops here and is seriously literary in the process. Is it distinguished? Yep. There’s serious heart and guts and other portions of the anatomy at work here. It’s a smart book but appealing too. Never downplay child appeal. It’s worth considering.
Wild Card: The Riverman by Aaron Starmer
It’s probably a good sign when you can’t stop thinking about a book, right? Again, we’re pushing up against the upper limits of the age restriction on Newbery Award winners here, but the book is worth it. Objections I’ve heard lobbed against it say that Alexander doesn’t sound like a kid. Well . . . actually, he’s not supposed to but you don’t really find that out until the second book. So does that trip up the first one’s chances? Maybe, but at least it’s consistent. The objection that Aquavania isn’t realistic enough of a fantasy world would hold more weight if I thought it really WAS a fantasy world, but I don’t. I think it’s all in the characters’ heads. So my weird self-justifications seem to keep this one in the mix. The only questions is, am I the only one?
Wild Card: The Crossover by Kwame Alexander
I’m ashamed to say that I hadn’t even seriously considered this one until a friend of mine brought it up this weekend. And OF COURSE it’s a contender! I mean just look at that language. It sizzles on the page. I’m more than a little peeved that he didn’t garner a NAACP Image Award nomination for this title. If he wins something it’s going to make them look pretty dang silly, that’s for sure. They nominated Dork Diaries 8 and not THIS?!? Okay, rant done. In the end it’s brilliant and, amazingly enough, equally beloved of YA and children’s librarians. The Crossover is a crossover title. Who knew?
By the way, am I the only one with a shelf in my home of 2014 books that have Newbery potential and that I don’t want to read but am holding onto just in case I have to read them? They ain’t gonna Moon Over Manifest me this year, by gum! I am prepared!
Caldecott Award
Winner: Draw by Raul Colon
Betcha you didn’t see that one coming, eh? But honestly, I think this is where we’re heading. First off, this isn’t one of my favorites of the year. I’m just not making the emotional connection with it that I’d like to. My favorite Colon of 2014? Abuelo by Arthur Dorros. But no one’s talking about that one (more fool they). No, they like this one and as I’ve watched I’ve seen it crop up on more and more Best Of lists. Then I sat down and thought about it. Raul Colon. It’s ridiculous that he doesn’t have a Caldecott Gold to his name. He’s one of the masters of the field and this could easily be a case of the committee unconsciously thinking, “Thank God! Now we can give the man an award!” We haven’t had a Latin American gold winner since David Diaz’s Smoky Night (talk about a book tied to its time period). It just makes perfect sense. Folks love it, it’s well done, and it could rise to the top.
Honors: The Farmer and the Clown by Marla Frazee
Again, not one of my favorites. I love Marla Frazee and acknowledge freely that though I don’t get this book, I seem to be the only one who doesn’t (my husband berates me repeatedly for my cold cold heart regarding this title). I mean, I absolutely adore the image of the little clown washing the smile off of his face, revealing his true feelings. So since I’ve apparently a gear stuck in my left aorta, I’m going to assume that this is a book that everyone else sees clearly except me. It could go gold, of course. It seems to have an emotional hold on people and books with emotional holds do very well in the Caldecott race sometimes. We shall see.
Honors: Bad Bye, Good Bye by Deborah Underwood, ill. Jonathan Bean
Could be wishful thinking on my part, but look at the book jacket, man. Look at how it tells the entire story. Look at his technique. Isn’t it marvelous? Look at how it’s not just an emotional journey but a kind of road trip through Americana as well. Look at how he took this spare sparse text and gave it depth and feeling and meaning. That is SERIOUSLY hard to do with another author’s work!! Look at how beautiful it is and the emotionally satisfying (and accurate) beats. Look upon its works, ye mighty, and despair. Or give it a Caldecott Honor. I’m easy.
Honors: Viva, Frida by Yuyi Morales
Admittedly it’s not a shoo-in. In fact I’m a bit baffled that it didn’t show up on the recent list by Latinas for Latino Lit called Remarkable Latino Children’s Literature of 2014. There are admittedly some folks who want this to be a biography and have a hard time dealing with the fact that that is not its raison d’etre. Still others aren’t blown away by the text. That said, we’re not looking at the text. We’re looking at the imagery and the imagery is STUNNING. I mean, it could win the gold easily, don’t you think? Models and photography and two-dimensional art? Yuyi Morales should have won a Caldecott years ago. I think it’s finally time to give the woman some love.
Wild Card: Three Bears in a Boat by David Soman
“I still . . . I still, beeelieeeve!!!!” Okay. So maybe it’s just me. But when I sit down and I look and look and look at that image of the three little bears sailing into the sun with the light reflected off the water . . . *sigh* It’s amazing. I heard a very odd objection from someone saying that the bears don’t always look the same age from spread to spread. Bull. Do so. Therein ends my very coherent defense. It’s my favorite and maybe (probably) just mine, but I love it so much that I can’t give it up. I just can’t.
Wild Card: Neighborhood Sharks by Katherine Roy
Because how cool would it frickin’ be? Few have looked at this book and considered it for a Caldecott, but that’s just because they’re not looking at it correctly. Consider the cinematic imagery. The downright Hitchcockian view of the seal up above where YOU are the shark below. The two page attack! The beauty of blood in the water. I mean, it’s gorgeous and accurate all at once. I don’t think anyone’s giving the woman enough credit. Give it a second glance, won’t you?
And that’s it! There are loads and loads of titles missing from this list. The actual winners, perhaps. But I’m feeling confident that I’ve nailed at least a couple of these. We shall see how it all falls out soon enough. See you in February!!
By:
Betsy Bird,
on 9/15/2014
Blog:
A Fuse #8 Production
(
Login to Add to MyJacketFlap)
JacketFlap tags:
Uncategorized,
Newbery Award,
Caldecott Award,
Newbery/Caldecott predictions,
Caldecott Honors,
Newbery Honors,
Best Books of 2014,
2015 Newbery contender,
2015 Caldecott contender,
Add a tag
Now we’re in the thick of it. Do you hear that? That is the clicking ticking sound of the reanimation of the Heavy Medal and Calling Caldecott blogs. They’re a little groggy right now, trying to get their bearings, figuring out which foot to try first. But don’t be fooled by their initial speed. Very soon they’ll be acting like well-oiled machines, debating and comparing and contrasting like it’s nobody’s business. But why let them have all the fun? Time for a little predicting on my end as well! I’ve been discussing these books with folks all year and through our debates I’m getting a better sense of the titles that are more likely than others to make it in the end. So, with the inclusion of some fall books, here’s the latest roster of predictions. Please note that as the year goes on I tend to drop books off my list more than I add them. This is also my penultimate list. The final will appear in December.
2015 Newbery Predictions
The Night Gardener by Jonathan Auxier
It’s so satisfying when you like a book and then find that everyone else likes it too. This was the very first book I mentioned in this year’s Spring Prediction Edition of Newbery/Caldecott 2015 and nothing has shaken my firm belief that it is extraordinary. It balances out kid-friendly plotting with literary acumen. It asks big questions while remaining down-to-earth. And yes, it’s dark. 2014 is a dark year. It’ll be compared to Doll Bones, which is not the worst thing in the world. I could see this one making it to the finish line. I really could.
Absolutely Almost by Lisa Graff
You know what? I’m sticking by this one. Graff’s novel has the ability to create hardcore reader fans, even though it has a very seemingly simple premise. It’s librarian-bait to a certain extent (promoting a kid who likes to read Captain Underpants will do that) but I don’t think it’s really pandering or anything. It’s also not a natural choice for the Newbery, preferring subtlety over literary largess. I’m keeping it in mind for now.
West of the Moon by Margi Preus
Notable if, for no other reason, the fact that Nina Lindsay and I agree on it and we rarely agree on anything. As it happens, this is a book I’ve been noticing a big backlash against. It sports a complex and unlikeable heroine, which can prove difficult when assessing its merits. She makes hard, often bad, choices. But personally I feel that even if you dislike who she becomes, you still root for her to win. Isn’t that worth something? Other folks find the blending of historical fiction and fantasy unnerving. I find it literary. You be the judge.
Boys of Blur by N.D. Wilson
I could write out yet another defense of this remarkable novel, but I think I’ll let N.D. Wilson do the talking for me instead:
brown girl dreaming by Jacqueline Woodson
The frontrunner. This is Woodson’s year and we’re just living in it. I’m waiting to hear the concentrated objections to this book. Waiting because I’m having a hard time fathoming what they might be. One librarian I spoke too complained it was too long. Can’t agree myself, but I noted her comment. Other than that, nobody disagrees that it’s distinguished. As distinguished as distinguished can be, really. If it doesn’t get the gold (look at all the nice sky-space where you could fit in a medal!) I will go on a small rampage.
Dory Fantasmagory by Abby Hanlon
Betcha didn’t see that one coming. You were probably expecting a discussion of Revolution or A Snicker of Magic or something, right? Well darling, I’ll confess something to you. I like simple books. Reeeeally simple books. Books so simple that they cross an invisible line and become remarkably complex. I like books that give you something to talk about for long periods of time. That’s where Hanlon’s easy chapter book comes in. What do I find distinguished about this story? I find the emotional resonance and sheer honesty of the enterprise entirely surprising and extraordinary. And speaking of out-there nominations . . .
Once Upon an Alphabet: Short Stories for All the Letters by Oliver Jeffers
Face facts. Jeffers is a risky Caldecott bid, even when he’s at his best. The man does do original things (This Moose Belongs to Me was probably his best bet since moving to America, though I’d argue that Stuck was the best overall) but his real strength actually lies in his writing. The man’s brain is twisted in all the right places, so when you see a book as beautifully written as this one you have to forgive yourself for wanting to slap medals all over it, left and right. A picture book winning a Newbery is not unheard of in this day and age, but it requires a committee that thinks in the same way. I don’t know this year’s committee particularly well. I can’t say what they will or will not think. All I do know is that this book deserves recognition.
Let the record show that the ONLY reason I am not including The Key That Swallowed Joey Pigza by Jack Gantos in this list is because it does require a bit of familiarity with the other books in the series. I struggle with that knowledge since it’s long been a dream of mine to see a Joey Pigza book with the Newbery gold and this is our last possible chance to do just that. Likewise, I’m not including The Madman of Piney Woods by Christopher Paul Curtis only because knowledge of Elijah of Buxton makes for a stronger ending to the tale But both books are true contenders in every other way.
And now for the more difficult discussions (because clearly Newbery is a piece of cake….. hahahahahahahaha!!! <—- maniacal laughter)
2015 Caldecott Predictions
Bad Bye, Good Bye by Deborah Underwood, ill. Jonathan Bean
I only recently discovered that if you take the jacket off of this book and look at it from left to right you get to see the entire story play out, end to end. What other illustrator goes for true emotion on the bloody blooming jacket of their books? Bean is LONG overdue for Caldecott love. He’s gotten Boston Globe-Horn Book love and Ezra Jack Keats Award love but at this moment in time it’s downright bizarre that he hasn’t a Caldecott or two to his name. Hoping this book will change all that.
A Dance Like Starlight by Kristy Dempsey, ill. Floyd Cooper
I’m sticking with Floyd here. The man’s paid his dues. This book does some truly lovely things. It’s going to have to deal with potentially running into people who just don’t care for his style. It’s a distinctive one and not found anywhere else, but I know a certain stripe of gatekeeper doesn’t care for it. It’s also one of three African-American ballerina books this year (Ballerina Dreams: From Orphan to Dancer by Michaela and Elaine DePrince, ill. Frank Morrison and Firebird by Misty Copeland, ill. Christopher Myers anyone?) but is undeniably the strongest.
Viva Frida by Yuyi Morales, photographs by Tim O’Meara
People don’t like it when a book doesn’t fall into their preexisting prescribed notions of what a book should do. Folks look at the cover and title of this book and think “picture book biography”. When they don’t get that, they get mad. I’ve heard complaints about the sparse text and lack of nonfiction elements. Yet for all that, nobody can say a single word against the art. “Stunning” only begins to encompass it. I think that if you can detach your mind from thinking of the book as a story, you do far better with it. Distinguished art? You better believe it, baby.
Three Bears in a Boat by David Soman
Seriously, look me in the eye and explain to me how this isn’t everybody’s #1 Caldecott choice. Right here. In the eye.
Grandfather Gandhi by Arun Gandhi and Bethany Hegedus, illustrated by Evan Turk
What can I say that I haven’t said a hundred times before? I’ve heard vague whines from folks who don’t care for this art style. *sigh* It happens. I’ll just turn everything over to the author for her perspective on the story behind the story then.
Remy and Lulu by Kevin Hawkes and Hannah E. Harrison
Okay, try to think of a precedent for this one. Let’s say this book won the Caldecott gold. That would mark the very first time in the HISTORY of the award itself that two unmarried artists got a medal for their work, yes? And yet the book couldn’t exist without the two of them working in tandem. Remy and Lulu is an excellent example of a book that I dismissed on an initial reading, yet found myself returning to again and again and again later. And admit it. The similarities in some ways to Officer Buckle and Gloria can only help it, right?
I don’t think I gave this book adequate attention the first time I read it through.
Have You Heard the Nesting Bird? by Rita Gray, ill. Kenard Pak
I heard an artist once criticize the current trend where picture book illustrators follow so closely in the footsteps of Jon Klassen. And you could be forgiven for thinking that animator Kenard Pak is yet another one of these. Yet when you look at this book, this remarkable little piece of nonfiction, you see how the textured watercolors are more than simply Klassen-esque. Pak’s art is delightful and original and downright keen. Can you say as much for many other books?
This is one of those years where the books I’m looking at have NOTHING to do with the books that other folks are looking at. For example, when I look at the list of books being considered at Calling Caldecott, I am puzzled. Seems to me it would make more sense to mention Blue on Blue by Dianne White, illustrated by Beth Krommes, Go to Sleep, Little Farm by Mary Lyn Ray, illustrated by Christopher Silas Neal, or Dragon’s Extraordinary Egg by Debi Gliori (wait . . . she’s Scottish and therefore ineligible?! Doggone the doggity gones . . .).
For additional thoughts, be sure to check out the Goodreads lists of Newbery 2015 and Caldecott 2015 to see what the masses prefer this year.
So! What did I miss?
By:
Betsy Bird,
on 8/29/2014
Blog:
A Fuse #8 Production
(
Login to Add to MyJacketFlap)
JacketFlap tags:
Reviews,
Best Books,
picture book reviews,
Houghton Mifflin Harcourt,
Deborah Underwood,
Best Books of 2014,
Reviews 2014,
2015 Caldecott contender,
2015 Geisel contender,
Add a tag
Bad Bye, Good Bye
By Deborah Underwood
Houghton Mifflin Harcourt
$16.99
ISBN: 978-0-547-92852-4
Ages 3-7
On shelves now
As a mother who recently spent the better part of twenty hours in a car with a three-year-old and a three-month-old baby, I feel a special kinship with parents who have also engaged in the ultimate endurance sport: travel with children. If you feel no particular sympathy for those engaged in this activity that is because you have not experienced it firsthand yourself. But even when my daughter was projectile vomiting regularly and even when the breast pump tipped to one side spilling milk all over my pants and EVEN WHEN I found myself wedged in the backseat between two car seats trying to change my son’s diaper on my lap while parked, I could still feel grateful because at least it was just a vacation. It wasn’t like we were moving to a new town or anything. Because if I’d had to deal with the abject misery of my three-year-old on top of the vomit/milk/diapers I don’t know how my sanity would have remained intact. And yet, other parents do it all the time. Every day someone somewhere packs up all their worldly possessions, their pets, and their miserable offspring and heads for a whole new life. It’s daunting. You can’t help but admire their guts. And boy, you’d sure like to hand them a book that they could use to show their kids that as scary as a move like that can be, ultimately it’s going to be okay. Enter a book so sparse and spare you’d never believe it capable of the depth of feeling within its pages. Deborah Underwood lends her prodigious talents to Bad Bye, Good Bye while artist Jonathan Bean fills in the gaps. The effect is a book where every syllable is imbued with meaning, yet is as much a beautiful object as it is a useful too.
“Bad day, Bad box” says the book. On the page, a boy wrestles with a moving man for possession of a cardboard box, doomed to be loaded into the nearby moving van. The boy, we see, is in no way happy about this move. He clearly likes his home and his best friend, who has come with her mother to bid him goodbye. On the road he and his little sister pitch seven different kinds of catfits before sinking into a kind of resigned malaise. Time heals all wounds, though, and with the help of a motel swimming pool, diners, and multiple naps, they arrive in their new town in the early evening. As the family and movers pile boxes and other things into the new house, the boy meets another kid who just happens to live next door. Together they collect lightning bugs and star gaze until that “bad bye” at the beginning of the book morphs into a far more comfortable “good bye” when the new friends bid each other goodnight.
This isn’t Underwood’s first time at the rodeo. The art of the restrained use of language is sort of her bread and butter. Anyone who has seen her work her magic in The Quiet Book is aware that she says loads with very little. I sincerely hope someone out there has been bugging her to write an easy book for kids. The talent of synthesizing a story down to its most essential parts is a rare one. In this book there is a total of 57 words (or so). These usually appear in two word pairs and by some extraordinary bit of planning they also rhyme. We begin with all “bads”. It goes “Bad day, Bad box / Bad mop, Bad blocks / Bad truck, Bad guy, Bad wave, Bad bye.” The book then slips into neutral terms as the initial misery wears off. Then, as we near the end the “goods” come out. “Good tree, Good sky / Good friend, Good bye.” Such a nice transition. You could argue that it’s pretty swift considering the depths of misery on display in the early pages, and that’s not too far off, but kids are also pretty resilient. Besides, motel swimming pools do indeed go a long way towards modifying behavior.
Jonathan Bean’s one to watch. Always has been. From the moment he was doing Wendy Orr’s Mokie & Bik books to the nativity animalia title “One Starry Night” to all those other books in his roster, he proved himself a noteworthy artist. Watching his work come out you have the distinct sense that this is the calm before the storm. The last minute before he wins some big award and starts fielding offers from the biggest names in the biz. In this book I wouldn’t necessarily have said the art was by Bean had I not seen his name spelled out on the cover. It’s a slightly different style for him. Not just pencil and watercolors anymore. A style, in fact, that allows him to try and catch a bit of Americana in the story’s pages. When Underwood writes something like “Big hair, White deer” it’s Bean’s prerogative to determine what that means exactly. His solution to that, as well as other sections, is layering. Time and landscapes are layered on top of one another. America, from diners and speed limit signs to windmills and weathervanes, display scenes familiar to traveling families. A great artist gives weight and meaning to the familiar. Jonathan Bean is a great artist.
Now the cover of this book is also well worth noting. I don’t say that about a lot of picture books either. Generally speaking a picture book’s cover advertises the book to the best of its ability but only occasionally warrants close examination. Jonathan Bean, however, isn’t afraid to convey pertinent information through his cover. In fact, if you look at it closely you’ll see that he’s managed to encapsulate the entire story from one flap to another. Begin at the end of the book. Open it up. If you look at the inside back flap the very first thing you’ll see underneath the information about the author and the illustrator is the image of the boy in the story straining against his seatbelt, his face a grimace of pure unadulterated rage. Now follow the jacket to the back cover of the book and you see the boy crying in one shot and then looking miserably back in another. The weather is alternating between a starry night sky and a windy rainy day. Move onto the front cover and the rain is still there but soon it turns to clear skies and the boy’s attitude morphs into something distinctly more pleasant. In fact, by the time you open the book to the front flap he’s lifting his hands in a happy cheer. The attitude adjustment could not be more stark and it was done entirely in the span of a single book jacket. Not the kind of thing everyone would notice, and remarkable for that fact alone.
People are always talking about “the great American novel”, as if that’s an attainable ideal. We don’t ever hear anyone talk about “the great American picture book”. I don’t know that Bad Bye, Good Bye would necessarily fit the bill anyway. This is more the picture book equivalent of On the Road than To Kill a Mockingbird, after all. It’s a road trip book, albeit a safe and familiar one. For children facing the frightening prospect of the unknown (and let’s face it – adults hardly do much better) it’s good to have a book that can offer a bit of comfort. A reassurance that no matter how things change, good can follow bad just as day follows night. They are not alone in this uprooting. Somewhere out there, in another car, with another family, there might be a kid just as miserable as they are and for the exact same reason. And like all humans this knowledge ends up being comforting and necessary. Therefore give all your love to Bad Bye, Good Bye. It has necessary comfort to spare.
On shelves now.
Like This? Then Try:
- A New Room for William by Sally Grindley
- Herman’s Letter by Tom Percival
- The Good-Pie Party by Liz Garton Scanlon
- Alexander, Who Is Not (Do You Hear Me? I Mean It!) Going to Move by Judith Viorst
- Tim’s Big Move by Anke Wagner
Misc: And I interviewed Ms. Underwood about the book here.
Sloooooowly the predictions begin. As I post this I’m hitting the sweet spot right between Book Expo and the annual American Library Association conference. Which is to say, this is the moment in time when some folks have seen the fall galleys from BEA while other folks are about to see them at ALA. On maternity leave, I am hampered significantly by what I see. Most galleys are being sent to my workplace where they are out of my reach. So while I’ve still seen a wide swath of things, I know that there are books I’m missing. The fall prediction edition will be more complete, I am certain. Plus, by that time we’ll see Heavy Medal and Calling Caldecott back up and running and predicting as well.
Meantime, I’m not the only one making predictions these days. If you missed it, Travis Jonker did a heckuva great post when he predicted this year’s New York Times Best Illustrated. These are books that might not be eligible for the Caldecott but that would be complete and utter contenders under different circumstances. Worth your glance.
And now, some thoughts on the matter!
2015 Newbery Predictions
The Night Gardener by Jonathan Auxier
I’ve been very happy with the buzz surrounding Auxier’s latest. When I reviewed it back in March I suspected that it had fine, outstanding qualities worthy of award consideration. That suspicion has since been confirmed several times over by the multiple starred reviews and the online conversations I’ve observed. Typical of the dark fantasy trend in middle grade in 2014 (aside from Snicker of Magic, everything’s pretty gloom and doom this year) Auxier’s book does what Doll Bones did last year, blending classic horror elements with deeper themes and questions for young readers. His is a book that asks kids to question the nature of storytelling and lying (another 2014 trend, and a prevalent one that I intend to explore more thoroughly). At the very least, I predict that this will be showing up on many many Mock Newbery lists this year.
Curiosity by Gary L. Blackwood
This is actually not garnering the buzz I’d expect of it this year. Surprising since the release of a new Blackwood is a cause for celebration. My suspicion is that the man has been out of the middle grade field for so long that new crops of young librarians are unaware of his work. This is a true pity since Curiosity hits all the pleasure points of a Brian Selznick story. With a killer cover and some superb writing, my hope is that the buzz is just on a low-boil and will be turned up significantly as we near the award season. Perhaps this is my dark horse candidate this year, but I don’t think you should count it out. It could definitely pull a Paperboy or Breaking Stalin’s Nose surprise win out of its hat.
Absolutely Almost by Lisa Graff
For years I’ve wanted a Lisa Graff book to make it onto my prediction lists, but every time there was just something holding me back. No longer. The remarkable thing about Absolutely Almost is that it dares not to be remarkable. Or rather, it celebrates kindness over being special. I’ll keep my thoughts to myself for the review I’ll write of it but Graff has accomplished here is something incredibly difficult. Plus I love the idea of a major award going to a book that celebrates Captain Underpants like this one does.
The Nightingale’s Nest by Nikki Loftin
Another dark horse, and maybe one of the more divisive books on this list. Loftin makes a lunge for magical realism with her story, which is a very difficult thing to do in middle grade novels. The controversy surrounding it concerns The Emperor and what he did or did not do to the story’s heroine. To my mind, any child reader who goes through this story will only recognize that he stole the girl’s voice by recording it. End of story. But because this book can be read very differently by adults vs. children, that may inhibit its chances. Only time will tell. The writing, few can argue, is superb.
The Greenglass House by Kate Milford
One of my favorite books of the year. Pure pleasure reading through and through. I’ve heard it described as “Clue meets The Westing Game” and that’s not too far off. We haven’t had a Westing Game kind of book win a Newbery in a while, unless you count When You Reach Me. It would be awfully nice for a mystery to win once more, and Milford’s talents at creating a whole and complete world within her pages is stellar. Definitely a contender.
West of the Moon by Margi Preus
There are only two books out this year that I think are surefire Newbery contenders, and this is one of them (you’ll meet the other soon). Preus is a marvel. This book, again, taps equally into darkness and storytelling vs. lies while also managing to pluck all the use out of fantasy and yet remain fairly historical fiction-y. It’s a quick read and a gripping one. Additional Bonus: Lockjaw!
Boys of Blur by N.D. Wilson
Good buzz is surrounding Wilson’s latest, which is excellent. I’ve already felt a little pushback to it, but the strong writing is working very well in its favor. It’s not a sure thing, but if any Wilson book can finally make a decent lunge for the Newbery it is this. Already I can predict that Heavy Medal will have a hard time with it (I would LOVE to be mistaken about this, though). Plus it probably has the best book trailer of the year thus far.
brown girl dreaming by Jacqueline Woodson
The frontrunner, as far as I can tell. No question. There is nothing one can call a sure thing when it comes to Newbery or Caldecott books. Heck, a couple of years ago I would have said that One Crazy Summer was a shoo-in. Shows what I know. That said, if this book does not win the Newbery proper then there will be blood in the streets. Gushing torrents of scarlet red blood. In a year of #WeNeedDiverseBooks what a capper it would be to give the Award to what is, not only, the best book of the year but also one that stands as a necessary piece of African-American history. Not that the committee can think in those terms. All that they can do is say whether or not the book is one of the most distinguished of the year. Spoiler Alert: It is.
That’s what I think in terms of the frontrunners. But there are plenty of other books that people are discussing. Consider, for example, Rain, Reign by Ann M. Martin. She won a Newbery Honor years ago. Will she be able to recapture the magic with her latest? Maybe, but not with this particular book. It’s nicely done but as a woman hepped up on postpartum hormones, it tried to make me cry and didn’t quite get there. That’s telling. The Fourteenth Goldfish by Jennifer L. Holm is another fantastic and fun read (and pure science fiction, which is very rare indeed). It feels like a slightly younger When You Reach Me, which is a fine and fancy pedigree. But Newbery? I didn’t feel it. The Riverman by Aaron Starmer was definitely one I was thinking of when I first read it, but when I heard it was the first in a series that changed my interpretation of the ending. Will the committee feel the same way? The writing is, after all, fabulous. Upside Down in the Middle of Nowhere by Julie T. Lamana was a book I loved earlier in the year. I still love it, though in the wake of other strong contenders I’m not sure if it’ll make it to the award finish line. And, of course, there is Snicker of Magic by Natalie Lloyd. Forget what I said about Nightingale’s Nest. THIS is the most divisive book of 2014. The writing is very accomplished and it’s got great lines. Plus it’s nice to see something But Newbery? To win it’ll have to convince the committee that the (totally unnecessary and occasionally infuriating) cutesy parts are overwhelmed by the good writing. Its win relies entirely on the tone of the committee. I don’t envy them the debates.
Phew! Moving on . . .
2015 Caldecott Predictions
Um . . no idea. Honestly, I haven’t felt this out to sea in terms of the Caldecott in years. I’m just not feeling it this year. There are some superb books but surprisingly few of them grab me by the throat and throttle me while screaming “CALDECOTT!!!!” in my ear. I always fall apart on Caldecott predictions anyway. Last year at this time I only mentioned two of the eventual winners, not even mentioning the other two (and HOW on earth did I fail to mention the glorious Flora and the Flamingo, I ask you?!?). This year I just keep coming back to the books I mentioned in my spring prediction edition. Fortunately, a couple additional books caught my jaded eye . . .
Bad Bye, Good Bye by Deborah Underwood, ill. Jonathan Bean
Bean wowed the world last year with his Building Our House, a winner of the Boston Globe-Horn Book Award. But you know what Caldecott committees really like? Variety. That’s why his latest change of style is so exciting. The beautiful simplicity of Underwood’s text, which manages to tell a complete story with a minimum of words, is matched page for page by Bean’s art. The pairing results in a particularly strong product and since Caldecott committees are extraordinarily interested in books that pair art and text well, it seems to me we may have a winner on our hands here.
A Dance Like Starlight by Kristy Dempsey, ill. Floyd Cooper
A Floyd Cooper. An honest-to-god Floyd Cooper prediction. Considering the man’s output, this may strike some as surprising. No one ever contests that he’s accomplished but he’s one of those perpetual Caldecott bridesmaids never brides (see my post on such folks here). It doesn’t matter how gorgeous his art is, he gets passed by time after time. Except . . . something about this book is different. My librarians, for one thing, who have always been Cooper-tepid are GAGA over this. It’s not just the fact that the text manages to do the whole Live Your Dream storyline without getting cheesy. There’s some stellar art at work. This is a bad scan, but if this book does well I think it’ll be because of this image:
Viva Frida by Yuyi Morales, photographs by Tim O’Meara
Speaking of always bridesmaids . . . but this book. I mean, just wow. Not that a Caldecott committee has ever, to the best of my knowledge, awarded three-dimensional art (scholars, correct me!). But that’s the wonder of this book. It isn’t JUST three-dimensional art, but two-dimensional as well. The book itself celebrates the very concept of being an artist (a swell thing for a Caldecott committee to reward) and as I learned last year, Ms. Morales has residency here in the States so she certainly could win this thing. Some folks don’t like that it isn’t a straight biography but something a little more artistic and esoteric. Pfui to them, sez I. You simply cannot read this and not find it stunning.
Hi, Koo! A Year of Seasons by Jon J. Muth
Never count out a Muth. Though this book has far less lofty ambitions than his past Caldecott win, it has heart and lovely watercolors. This could easily be sidelined altogether, or go for the big gold. Certainly hard to say at this point.
Three Bears in a Boat by David Soman
It’s my personal #1, which makes me worry for its future. When I get emotional about a book I find it sometimes hampers my view of its award chances. That said, no one doubts the sheer beauty of the art here. Soman’s always been someone to watch, even when working on something as popular as the Ladybug Girl series. Can he win hearts and minds with bears? I say yes.
Firefly July and Other Very Short Poems selected by Paul B. Janeczko, illustrated by Melissa Sweet
We know Sweet is automatic Caldecott bait, but you’re never quite sure which of her books will attract the committee. This book isn’t afraid to be long and strong on the poetry. I’ve heard grumbles in some quarters that the poems don’t always necessarily pair with one season or another, but that’s nothing against the art. Still, it might affect its chances in the end.
Grandfather Gandhi by Arun Gandhi and Bethany Hegedus, illustrated by Evan Turk
If any debut deserves love it’s this one. A remarkable combination of art and heart, with different styles and a heckuva great take on the subject matter. Turk’s one to watch and this book is already one of the year’s favorites. Even if it doesn’t win, it bodes well for the artist’s future.
In terms of books getting some nice buzz, I’ve heard some folks mentioning The Adventures of Beekle: The Unimaginary Friend by Dan Santat. I love me a good Santat and Dan certainly poured his heart and soul into this one. So why don’t I think it’s a surefire winner? Hard to say. The art is certainly nice enough. Meanwhile, Back at the Ranch by Anne Isaacs, illustrated by Kevin Hawkes hasn’t shown up on a lot of lists, but Anne Isaacs has a way of writing books that catch the eye of award committees. My own librarians are very taken with this latest effort, and Hawkes should at least get a mention if only for the sheer disgustingness of his desperadoes. Baby Bear by Kadir Nelson is one of those books that should, by rights, be a Caldecott contender. Indeed there are some stirring images here. Unfortunately there’s something off about this particular Nelson book. It’s hard to pinpoint but it lays in the art. Nelson’s due for a big gold someday. This, however, probably won’t be “the one”. Breathe by Scott Magoon is absolutely lovely and I would love Magoon to get an award one of these days. It definitely belongs to the whale trend of 2014. Will it get an award? It may be too subtle for that. We’ll see. Finally, Sparky! by Jenny Offill, illustrated by Chris Appelhans, is the book getting a lot of the buzz. I loved the story and the art but while I found it lovely and funny by turns I didn’t feel the award hum at work. I think Appelhans is definitely one to watch. You’re just going to have to keep watching.
For additional thoughts, be sure to check out the Goodreads lists of Newbery 2015 and Caldecott 2015 to see what the masses prefer this year.
So! What did I miss?
By:
Betsy Bird,
on 4/8/2014
Blog:
A Fuse #8 Production
(
Login to Add to MyJacketFlap)
JacketFlap tags:
Best Books of 2014,
Reviews 2014,
2014 reviews,
2014 biographies,
2014 nonfiction,
2015 Sibert contender,
2015 Caldecott contender,
Arun Gandhi,
Evan Turk,
Reviews,
nonfiction,
nonfiction picture books,
biographies,
Simon and Schuster,
Atheneum,
Best Books,
picture book biographies,
Bethany Hegedus,
Add a tag
Grandfather Gandhi
Arun Gandhi and Bethany Hegedus
Illustrated by Evan Turk
Atheneum (an imprint of Simon and Schuster)
$17.99
ISBN: 978-1-4424-2365-X
Ages 4-8
On shelves now.
Are you familiar with the concept of booktalking? It’s a technique librarians developed to get people interested in books they might otherwise not pick up. The whole concept is to develop a kind of movie trailer style talk that gives a sense of the book’s allure without giving up the plot. Typically booktalking is done for middle grade and young adult works of fiction, but enterprising souls have had a lot of luck with nonfiction as well. Now with an increased interest in nonfiction in our schools it’s more important than ever to make the books we hawk sound particularly good. It doesn’t hurt matters any when the books actually ARE good, though. Now let’s say I’m standing in front of a room of second and third graders with a copy of Grandfather Gandhi in my hands. How do I sell this book to them? Easy peasy. Some books practically booktalk themselves. Here’s how you sell it:
“Have any of you ever heard of Einstein? Yes? He’s the guy that was a total genius. Now imagine you’re his grandkid and you’re not that smart. Okay now, have any of you heard of the Beatles. Yes? Well imagine you’re one of THEIR grandkids . . . and you’re bad at music. Now here’s the big one. Has anyone heard of Gandhi? He was a great guy. He managed to free his country and stop a lot of oppression and he did it without any violence at all. Martin Luther King Jr. got some of his ideas from Gandhi about nonviolence. All right, well, now let’s image you are Gandhi, the most peaceful man IN THE WORLD’s grandson. What if you get mad? Can you imagine what it would be like to have everyone whispering every time you got a little steamed about something?”
So there you go. Quick. Simple. To the point. I’ve met a fair number of picture book memoirs in my day, but Grandfather Gandhi may well be my favorite. Smartly written with an unusual hook and art that will just knock your socks off, this is one title you are going to have to see firsthand for yourself.
When young Arun and his family first arrive in his grandfather Mahatma Gandhi’s village, he’s mighty shy around his incredibly famous relative. Yet right away Grandfather is warm and welcoming to them, and when he praises Arun for walking the distance from the train station the boy swells with pride. Unfortunately, having Gandhi as your grandpa means having to share him with the 350 followers who also live in the village. Arun struggles with his lessons in Gujarati and the fact that there are no movie theaters around, but there are upsides to village life too. He’s pretty good at soccer with the other kids, and occasionally Grandfather will take him for a walk just mano a mano. But then, one fateful day, Arun gets into a skirmish on the soccer field and his anger is overwhelming. Shamed that the grandson of Gandhi himself would react in anger he confesses to his Grandfather immediately, only to find the man isn’t angry or disappointed in him in the least. Anger, Gandhi explains, is like lightning. You can use it to destroy or you can use it to light the world, like a lamp. Which will you choose?
I think it’s fair to say that there have been a fair number of children’s picture books from family and relatives of famous peacemakers. Most notable would be Martin Luther King Jr.’s clan, where it sometimes seems like every son, daughter, niece, and nephew has his or her own spin on their infinitely famous relative. Gandhi’s a bit different. One wouldn’t expect his own descendants to have much in the way of access to the American publishing industry, so biographies of his life in picture book form have concentrated occasionally on his life and occasionally on The Great Salt March. When I saw that this book was co-authored by his fifth grandson I expected the same sort of story. A kind of mix of “this guy was fantastic” with “and I knew him!”. Instead, Hegedus and Gandhi have formulated a much more accessible narrative. Few children can relate to having a famous relative. But what about controlling their anger in the face of injustice? What’s fascinating about this book is that the authors have taken a seemingly complex historical issue and put it into terms so child-friendly that a five-year-old could get the gist of it. That Gandhi’s anger went on to become what spurned him to make lasting, important changes for his people is the key point of the book, but it takes a child’s p.o.v. to drill the issue home.
Above and beyond all that, this is a book that advocates quite strongly for peace in all its myriad forms. Hardly surprising when you consider the subject matter but just the same I sometimes feel like “peace” is one of those difficult concepts without a proper picture book advocate. I went to a Quaker college where PAGS (Peace and Global Studies) was a popular major, and it was in making Quaker friends that I learned about picture books dedicated to the concepts embraced by that particular religion. Books like The Story of Ferdinand by Munro Leaf, The Table Where Rich People Sit by Byrd Baylor, Thy Friend, Obadiah by Brinton Turkle, and more. I’m sure that many is the Quaker household, or really any household that believes that peace is a practical and attainable solution, that will embrace Grandfather Gandhi as one of their own.
It’s been a long time since I ran across a picture book with as long and lengthy a list of materials used in the illustrations as I have here. On the publication page it reads, “The illustrations for this book are rendered in watercolor, paper collage, cotton fabric, cotton, yarn, gouache, pencil, tea, and tin foil. Cotton hand spun on an Indian book charkha by Eileen Hallman.” Phew! You might think that all that “stuff” might yield something clogged up or messy, but that would be doing Mr. Turk a disservice. Observing how well he gives his pictures depth and texture, life and vitality, you might be shocked to learn that Grandfather Gandhi is his first picture book. From the spinning wheel endpapers to montages of sheer explosive anger, Turk makes a point of not only adhering to some of the more metaphorical aspects of the text, but finding new and creative ways to bring them to visual life. To my mind, the materials an artist uses in his or her art must, in the case of mixed media, have a reason for their existence. If you’re going to use “cotton fabric, cotton” and “yarn” then there should be a reason. But Turk clearly did his homework prior to doing the art on this book. He doesn’t just slap the images together. He incorporates the fibers Gandhi knew so well and turns them into an essential aspect of the book’s art. The art doesn’t just support the text here. It weaves itself into the story, becoming impossible to separate from the story.
It’s Arun’s anger that proved to be the most visually interesting aspect, to me, in the book. Turk deftly contrasts the calm white thread produced by Gandhi’s spinning with the tangled black ones that surround and engulf his grandson whenever his feelings threaten to break free. The scene where he’s tempted to throw a rock at the boy who shoved him down is filled with thread, Arun’s magnificently clenched teeth, and black shadow figures that reach out across the field to the soccer net, dwarfing the three other little figures below. Later you can see the negative space found in cut paper turning from a representation of lightning into a thread of cotton in the hands of Gandhi illuminating a passage about making your anger useful. Yet Turk doesn’t just rely on clever techniques. He’s remarkably skilled at faces too. Arun’s expressions when he gets to see his grandfather alone or makes him proud are just filled with wide-eyed eager hope. And his frustrations and anger pulse off the page from his features alone.
Picture books for kids about dealing with their anger tend towards the fictional. There’s Molly Bang’s When Sophie Gets Angry . . . Really Really Angry and Robie H. Harris’s The Day Leo Said, “I Hate You”. These are two of the good ones. Others veer towards the preachy and paternalistic. Imagine if you started using something like Grandfather Gandhi instead. More than just a memoir, the book offers a broad look at the benefits of channeling your anger. Better still, it’s a true story. Kids respect the true. They’ll also respect young Arun and his uncomfortable position. Fair play to author Bethany Hegedus for hearing him speak more than 13 years ago about this moment in his life, knowing that not only was there a picture book story to be had here, but a lesson kids today can grasp. As she says in her “Note from the Authors” at the end, “We world we live in needs to heal – to heal from the wars that are fought, to the bullying epidemic, to mass killings by lone gunmen, to poverty, to hunger, and to issues that contribute to internal anger being outwardly expressed in violent actions.” Gandhi’s message never grows old. Now we’ve a book that helps to continue his work for the youngest of readers. A necessary purchase then.
On shelves now.
Source: Final copy sent from publisher for review.
Like This? Then Try:
Other Blog Reviews:
Professional Reviews:
Interviews:
- ReaderKidZ speaks with Ms. Hegedus about the book.
- Meanwhile Kirkus interviewed the two authors and the illustrator here.
Misc: This is a book with a very nicely maintained and updated website of its own. Some of my favorite posts include this one from Evan Turk on how he got access to the spun cotton fiber featured in the book. I also light his piece on Light & Shadow and this one on how he chose his art. Arun even has posts up containing family Gandhi stories that would make an excellent follow up books should the need arise. Be sure to read the one on pumpkins and eggs when you get a chance.
Video:
One of the top best book trailers I’ve seen in a really long time. Accomplished and it does a brilliant job of highlighting Turk’s art.
llustration & Animation by Evan Turk
Voices: Arun Gandhi & Bethany Hegedus
By:
Betsy Bird,
on 3/19/2014
Blog:
A Fuse #8 Production
(
Login to Add to MyJacketFlap)
JacketFlap tags:
Best Books,
Candlewick,
Melissa Sweet,
Paul B. Janeczko,
Best Books of 2014,
Reviews 2014,
2014 reviews,
2015 Caldecott contender,
2014 poetry,
collected poetry,
Reviews,
poetry,
Add a tag
Firefly July: A Year of Very Short Poems
Selected by Paul B. Janeczko
Illustrated by Melissa Sweet
Candlewick Press
$16.99
ISBN: 978-0-7636-4842-8
Ages 4-8
On shelves now
Is reviewing works of poetry essentially a ridiculous thing to attempt? I’m not trying to be facetious or anything, I honestly want to know. It took me a long time to appreciate poetry on any level, but when I did I was able to come to it understanding that its closest relative in the arts world is music. Music that a person enjoys is a deeply personal experience. Only you can replicate the feelings and emotions that certain combinations of notes inspire. By the same token, poetry should be purely a one-on-one experience. And part of the job of books of collected poems for kids is to get each child reader to find that one poem that speaks to them. Maybe if they find one, just one, that hits home then that person will seek out other poems. Maybe it’ll expand their little minds, lead them to modes of thought they might not have reached otherwise. If the ultimate goal of children’s poetry is simply to inspire in kids a love of words and wordplay, then critiquing books that seek to do that is a uniquely difficult proposition. I mean, how can you judge something that’s so subjective? The best that you can do is simply determine if the poems in a collection are good, put together in a logical way, and worthwhile reading. And in the case of Firefly July the answer to all three of those queries is yes and yes and you betcha.
Four seasons yield 36 poems. Selected by children’s poet Paul B. Janeczko, Firefly July slowly introduces each time of year with gentle, short verses that lure you in. Each poem highlights a different element of the season, whether it’s a cat stalking through the daisies in the summer or winter wind “tearing itself to shreds / On bared-wire fences.” A pleasing mix of canon poets (Robert Frost, Langston Hughes, Emily Dickinson, etc.) and canon children’s poets (Charlotte Zolotow, J. Patrick Lewis, James Stevenson, etc.) the book touches lightly on those elements that make a season memorable. With illustrator Melissa Sweet’s interpretations of each poem in tow, this collection proves to be the kind of book of poetry no library or poetry-minded household can seriously be without.
Like I said before, so much of critiquing poetry is subjective. So on an entirely personal level, I can at least tell you that I didn’t really begin to warm up to these poems (no pun intended) until we hit the Summer section. Nothing against the Spring, mind you. It’s there that you’ll find a lot of the old standards like the William Carlos Williams poem “The Red Wheelbarrow”. But Summer proved a lovely surprise. Langston Hughes waxing eloquent on “Subway Rush Hour” followed by Joyce Sidman’s lovely “A Happy Meeting” (which conjures up memories of the e.e. cummings poem “in Just”) and then the titular “Firefly July” by J. Patrick Lewis (which really does deserve to have its name appropriated for the title of this book) combine to give one a true, rounded sense of the season. Teachers and parents would do well to read this book to kids and then ask them what their favorite season is. Mine now appears to be summer. Who knew?
The real advantage to this book is in the subtitle. “A Year of Very Short Poems”. Though I struggle in vain to find the right way to sell my poetry collection in months other than April, I can’t help but think that maybe size does matter. Books containing long and lengthy poems (like the delightful A Pond Full of Ink by Annie M.G. Schmidt) will be ideal for the already indoctrinated, but if you’re trying to lure in the poetry shy, short is the way to go. Short and sweet. And brother, it hardly gets any sweeter than this.
Melissa Sweet’s art was an interesting choice as illustrator. It makes sense when you think about it. After all, her Caldecott Honor was bestowed upon the picture book biography of poet William Carlos Williams A River of Words. In this book she is the sole artist interpreting these various works. There are no head scratching moments. No times when you feel as though she’s taking advantage of her position as the illustrator. She switches vantage points and views consistently as well, keeping the viewer awake and interested. Of all the pages, my favorite Sweet was the two-page spread accompanying Carl Sandburg’s poem “Window”. There, panel after panel after panel show scenes from a railway car looking at the countryside. Later, Ted Kooser’s “Snow Fence” contains the striking image of crows perched on a simple red fence set against the pure white drifts. One might argue that Sweet takes few risks with this book but if I’m going to trade in beauty for risk, I figure that’s a pretty fair deal.
As I am a librarian and not a teacher I don’t usually think up classroom applications for books when I read them. Firefly July proves to be the exception to the rule. Reading this book I could imagine all sort of interesting uses. For example, teachers might want to actually revive an old school standard and have the kids in their classroom memorize one of these poems for recitation type purposes. We’ve seen some books collect poems for this very specific purpose (see: Forget-Me-Nots: Poems to Learn by Heart, selected by Mary Ann Hoberman) but in this particular case I think the quality of the selections recommend it highly. There is, after all, no better way to learn a poem heart, body, and soul than to incessantly read it over and over and over again.
With its pedigree in place it’s little wonder that Firefly July entranced me as much as it did. I don’t consider myself a poetry connoisseur so it takes something special to break through to me as much as this book did. I still maintain that reading poems of any sort is a personal business and that what suits the goose will never do for the gander. That said, for a work of introductory poems specially selected so as to calm and comfort the reluctant poetry reader, Firefly July ain’t a bad way to go. Lulling and lovely, there’s something for everyone inside. All you have to do is just give it a chance.
On shelves now.
Source: Galley sent from publisher for review.
Like This? Then Try:
Blog Reviews:
Professional Reviews:
Misc: Jules Danielson considers the book at her Kirkus blog.
Happy St. Patrick’s Day! Yes, folks, it’s that time of year again. Just when you had a spare moment to catch your breath after all that award craziness, I come in with my wheelbarrow of 2015 predictions ready to dump them on your proverbial lap whether you want them or not. And on a holiday that has NOTHING to do with children’s books at that! How’s that for gall? If I were to take a guess I’d say you weren’t crazy about the prospect of having to consider what is and is not “distinguished” so early in the year. Well, I feel your pain but I just can’t restrain myself. For evidence of my inability to restrain myself in other years see my lamentable predictions including:
2008 spring predictions: I get one Caldecott right (How I Learned Geography)
2009 spring predictions: I get two Newberys right (The Evolution of Calpurnia Tate and The (Mostly) True Adventures of Homer P Figg)
2010 spring predictions: I get one Newbery right (One Crazy Summer)
2011 spring predictions: I get one Newbery right (Inside Out and Back Again)
2012 spring predictions: I get two Newberys right (The One and Only Ivan and Splendors and Glooms), and one Caldecott right (Green). I’m getting better in my old age! Woot!
2013 spring predictions: I get two Newberys right (Doll Bones and One Came Home) and one Caldecott right (Mr. Wuffles). That ties me with my previous year of three successes. As you can see, I’m better on Newberys than Caldecotts.
And I know I say this every year, but this year is REALLY strong in terms of Newbery contenders. I swear I haven’t seen this many potential Newbery books this early in the season in quite a while. The Caldecott, in contrast, is a little more up in the air. I have no idea where it’s going. In any case, here’s what I suggest you might want to read sometime soon:
2015 Newbery Predictions
The Night Gardener by Jonathan Auxier
If Doll Bones taught us anything it’s that horror has a real shot at a major award when it’s paired with a larger, all-encompassing theme. In this case, the relationship between lies and stories and how people use both as crutches with dealing with their own personal traumas. Heavy stuff? Not under Auxier’s hand. I expect a fair amount of buzz to surround Auxier’s second title, and serious discussion at that. There’s a lot to pick apart here.
Curiosity by Gary L. Blackwood
Back in 1998, Blackwood captured hearts and minds with The Shakespeare Stealer. To this day it remains his best known work, and the title that has proved to have enough legs to keep it on countless summer reading lists every single year. It’s been a long time, but I think we’ve finally found a Blackwood book that surpasses Shakespeare in quality and excitement. Throwing everything and the kitchen sink into his narrative (phrenology, P.T. Barnum, automatons, Edgar Allan Poe, and a kid hunchback, just for starters) this is a fabulous historical fiction read that will keep readers turning page after page after page. Definitely one to keep a very sharp eye on.
Upside Down in the Middle of Nowhere by Julie T. Lamana
A debut author, no less! This may just be optimism on my part, but I recently finished Lamana’s book and I was quite taken with it. I’ve read a LOT of Hurricane Katrina middle grade novels. Almost all of them (though not the I Survived series title set there). With the sole exception of Ninth Ward, almost all of them involve a boy and a dog. Seriously. Look at Zane and the Hurricane, Buddy, and Saint Louis Armstrong Beach if you don’t believe me. So it was with great relief that I read one where the doggie presence was mercifully brief. Lamana tackles the Hurricane from the perspective of a kid with a large family and the result is a book that slices you from throat to sternum, removes your heart, and throws it out the nearest 251th floor window. Let’s just say my fellow subway riders weren’t quite prepared for the crazy pregnant woman sobbing (repeatedly) over this. It’s not flawless, but I think it’ll make for some grand conversations.
The Nightingale’s Nest by Nikki Loftin
We are definitely going to have a conversation about this book. Maybe multiple conversations. Maybe multiple conversations over the course of several months whereupon we pick apart, dissect, and generally go to town on what Loftin has accomplished here. It’s a tough book but an interesting one, particularly when you take into consideration its magical realism elements. I’m going to watch how others feel about it with great interest. Honestly, it’s like nothing else I’ve seen in quite a while.
Boys of Blur by N.D. Wilson
Beowulf for kids. Do I have your attention? Because I should probably clarify that while what I just said is 100% accurate, this is just as clearly a zombie novel set in a Floridian swamp. Wilson has always flirted with big subjects and his remarkable Leepike Ridge went inexplicably unnoticed for all that it was Odysseus modernized. Boys of Blur is a tidbit more obvious with its references (it actually comes out and talks about Beowulf from time to time) but also unafraid to tie big ideas into exciting premises. There’s as much internal strife in our young hero as he deals with his abusive father’s hometown as there are flesh-eating Grens. Your eyes should be closely trained on this one.
2015 Caldecott Predictions
Hi, Koo! A Year of Seasons by Jon J. Muth
Muth is back and he went all adorable on us when we weren’t looking. Sometimes the safest way to try and predict something as elusive as the Caldecott Award is to look at previous winners. Certainly Muth did well back in the day with his 2006 Caldecott Honor winner Zen Shorts. In this book he puts a clever twist on the only haiku format, favoring feeling over form (with understandable reasons behind both). I could easily see this one getting an Honor this time around.
Three Bears in a Boat by David Soman
My own personal favorite, I confess. For all the hundreds of picture books I’ve already read this year (lunch time is picture book reading time where I work) few take my breath away. This is one of the few. Soman’s ability to hone water to his liking will leave you dumbstruck. A good story and killer art make this one of my top picks.
Grandfather Gandhi by Arun Gandhi and Bethany Hegedus, illustrated by Evan Turk
You know what I was chanting to myself as I looked up the information about this one? I believe it was something along the lines of “Please let Evan Turk live in America. Please please please let him live in America.” This is because I desperately wanted him to be eligible for the award. And guess what? Not only does he live in the U.S. but he’s a local! A New York City resident (more info here, in case you’re curious). We’re already seeing some marvelous picture book biographies and works of nonfiction this year, Turk’s art elevates what was already a pretty cool story. It’s not just the fact that it’s hugely accomplished. Turk manages to weave in materials and elements that bring to mind books like When Sophie Gets Angry . . . Really Really Angry (not something you’d usually say about a nonfiction text). Hugely rewarding to read, this one’s a keeper. Bear it in mind.
Firefly July and Other Very Short Poems selected by Paul B. Janeczko, illustrated by Melissa Sweet
If the Caldecott Honor win of Red Sings From Treetops is any indication, Caldecott committees love them their seasonal poetry. Add in the artistry of Melissa Sweet and you’ve got yourself a winner. Sweet made a surprise Caldecott Honor win a couple years ago when she illustrated the William Carlos Williams book A River of Words for Eerdmans. Since that time she’s been snatched up by all the big publishers, but her books (while always beautiful and well done) haven’t quite had the oomph to push her back into Caldecott territory. Perhaps it’s poetry that makes for her finest fits. Whatever the case, if you want to see Sweet at her best, this is the book to watch.
So cough it up. You may have some favorites of your own, this early in the game. Anything I should be reading that I haven’t gotten to yet?
Not a book here that would have me scratching my head this time! And I thought I was getting more cantankerous. My dream Newbery would be Brown Girl Dreaming, The Crossover, and How I Discovered Poetry (and if we want to have five, The Family Romanov and Port Chicago 50). Although not poetry, I am enchanted with The Great Green Heist and really would love to see a more diverse Newbery circle this year.
I think, however, if you are wrong about leaving off just one book that book is The Right Word. I am betting that it will be somewhere in that Monday morning announcement.
Also in the Caldecott realm, two other books that I think really have a chance are Sam and Dave Dig a Hole, which is brilliant and odd and layered (and so perfect for teachers) and Firebird, which just foreces my students to dance just looking at Chris’s magnificent artwork. Personal favorites that may not withstand committee scrutiny are the Midnight Library, Chengdu Would Not Could Not Fall Asleep, and Sparky. If only one of all of these Caldecott books can make the announcement cut, I am hoping that Yuyi receives that phone call. I do think that more than one of these will be announced. I do NOT have a good track record predicting Caldecott however (with one year serving as the exception that proves the rule–Lion & Mouse year).
By far the funniest, best written, and most passionately argued list I’ve seen (and I’ve been looking). Always wonderful to hear unashamed opinions. We’ll see how I feel when my book comes out in 2016.
As always I greatly respect you, your always fabulous prose and your eagerly awaited predictions.
First off I am still enormously perplexed over the (so far) lack of serious Caldecott love for Wendell Minor, the national treasure and Connecticut based illustrator who this year gave us the emotionally wrenching and exceedingly beautiful GALAPAGOS GEORGE in collaboration with the venerated Jean Craighead George, and then quickly followed that remarkable book with two other unforgettable 2014 releases – EDWARD HOPPER PAINTS THE WORLD with Robert Burleigh and SEQUOIA with Tony Johnston. This was a sublime hat trick that few illustrators have accomplished. Minor richly deserves to be in the Caldecott equation.
And then we have GRANDFATHER GANDHI, which -depending on what day of the week you ask me- could be the book of the year, with both Newbery and Caldecott attention well warranted. Bethany Hegedus has written with passion and contemporary thematic relevance, and young Evan Turk is one of the up-and-coming talent. His dynamic spinning wheel is one of the year’s most electrifying tapestries, and the book as a whole takes your breath away. I do know Elizabeth, that you are a huge fan of the book and wrote a masterful review on it months back. here is my recent take on it:
http://wondersinthedark.wordpress.com/2014/12/13/caldecott-medal-contender-grandfather-gandhi/
I am no fan at all of either DRAW (emotionally distancing) and the very unremarkable THREE BEARS IN A BOAT, but that’s just me. My wife, a lifelong bear lover, always chides me for not singing that book’s praises. I do like Colon, but DRAW should not triumph over a good number of this year’s amazing crop. Your prediction of it winning frankly has me in shock. yet there are a number of fabulous Hispanic picture books this year that can and deserve to be in the hunt.
One of our finest illustrators is Melissa Sweet, and she well deserves to win for one of her two 2014 masterpieces, the lyrical and ravishing FIREFLY JULY and the painstaking and dazzling THE RIGHT WORD. Do you really think she will get shut out after the kind of year she just had? These are the two greatest books she’s ever done to date, and that perception is saying something.
Then we have American born and very much eligible Frane Lessac who collaborated with her Australian husband Mark Greenwood on THE MAYFLOWER. This book is spectacularly beautiful and I’d like to think some voters have discovered and embraced it. This team has put out a bunch of superlative books over the years, and THE MAYFLOWER is a true historical themed masterpiece.
Is anyone talking at all about the stunning HUGO AND THE BEAR by Katy Beebe and S.D. Schindler, as sure-fire a Caldecott friendly book as there is? Exquisite Middle Age era adornments evoke the picturesque beauty of Chaucer’s era, and the story it serves is wholly irresistible.
I’d like to think that the following books are being passed around by excited committee members, or have been subject to that kind of scrutiny in the past months:
The Iridescence of Birds (exquisite almost to a fault!)
A Letter For Leo (Loving it more and more and more!!!)
Kid Sheriff and Terrible Toads (beautiful Shea and Smith collaboration!)
The Farmer and the Clown (I am with your husband but heck I understand you on this)
Maple (what a first effort!!!)
A Dance Like Starlight (no words to descibe how beautiful!)
Quest (remarkable and magnificent follow up to JOURNEY!!!)
My Teacher is a Monster (more subversive bliss from Peter Brown)
Josephine (masterpiece!)
Bad Bye Good bye (I have a good feeling this will get something and it is a stunning book!!!!!)
Gaston (Ooo la la!!!)
Blue on Blue (just released; lovely)
Mama Built a Little Nest (sublime!)
Neighborhood Sharks (every bit as great as you claim it to be!!!)
Little Melba and Her Big Trombone (deserves wide attention–so great!)
Viva Frida (ravishing!)
The Adventures of Beekle (a work of utter brilliance)
Henny (a future children’s book icon?)
Harlem Hellfighters
The Hug Machine (irresistible!)
Winter Bees (the incomparable Joyce Sidman and her terrific illustrator Rick Allen)
Separate is Never Equal (profound and beautiful!)
Blizzard (More Rocco eye candy!!)
The Baby Tree (sublime!)
Sam and Dave Dig A Hole (brilliant!)
A Grandfather’s Coat
Breathe
Little Red Roja Riding Hood
Baby Bear
Me and Mr. Emerson
Zombie in Love
Firebird (another book that takes your breath away)
Sparky
Green is a Chilli Pepper (another that deserves attention!!)
There is one other very significant book that belongs in my above list. Not sure how I left it off. it is THE PET BOOK by Bob Staake, a spirited and lovingly etched work by one of our great talents.
How do you feel about GREENGLASS HOUSE? It reminds me much of THE WESTING GAME…
THE IRIDESCENCE OF BIRDS. All the way.
I didn’t care for the main character of WEST OF THE MOON at all, and therefore didn’t care what happened to her. I’ve had bookstore customers who purchased it come back and say their kids didn’t like it.
I should say that I adore DRAW. I was also very pleasantly surprised with how well my first graders interacted with this story (and I have the videos to prove it).
Ed, my own first graders were bored and indifferent with it, and I tried with it on two occasions. These are the same first graders who connected with so many books on the list. So go figure. But the book has a lot of love for sure, so Elizabeth’s prediction, even one without her personal enforcement could yet pay dividends.
Agree with some of your selections especially, “Brown Girl Dreaming,” and “Bad Bye, Good Bye.” But, I’d add “A Time to Dance,” “A Snicker of Magic,” “The Key that Swallowed Joey Pigza.” For PB I’d add “King for a Day,” “A Dance by Starlight,” and “Grandfather Gandhi.”